Post New Article

Trump is thinking outside the Ukrainian box

Original Article

Posted By: Big Bopper, 2/22/2025 11:00:38 AM

Inside the box, and the Beltway, the thinking all along has been that we must draw a line at Ukraine, else Putin and the barbarians will soon be on the steps of Warsaw and then Berlin and Paris. Besides, Russian aggression and aggressors are morally bad. We owe it to posterity and civilization not to crumble before them. Those are valid points. On the other hand: We are where we are. Where we are, is Vladimir Putin make some understandable miscalculations. One, he miscalculated America’s willingness to support foreign countries. After all, he had witnessed Joe Biden’s Afghanistan surrender debacle.

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: earlybird 2/22/2025 11:24:38 AM (No. 1901637)
This may be the best, most well-reasoned article on this subject that I have read anywhere. Beaton makes a very good case for how this could end now.
10 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: Quigley 2/22/2025 11:27:56 AM (No. 1901638)
For me the analysis is Ukraine's non neutrality was a redline for Putin, and when Airhead Harris babbled that "Ukraine can join NATO if it wants to, Russia can't tell it what to do," Putin knew the Bidet regime was clown monkeys with hand grenades. To think that Putin could think he could roll over Western Europe in his lifetime is laughable. He undoubtedly believed that the US could very probably send lots of money to Ukraine initially, but that eventually the money would dry up and he would win the war of attrition. If he believes that Ukraine non neutrality is an existential threat, then all that makes sense. The Bidet Administration caused this war with its sophomoric handling of events. They were deadly unserious people.
13 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: DVC 2/22/2025 11:34:00 AM (No. 1901641)
Beaton gets a lot of this right, but I don't think his "option 3" which is nukes is on the list at all. And I do think that if Putin opens the nuclear Pandora's box, he will NOT receive a full on nuke strike back, but a measured nuclear response, probably in the form of an important military base, not too close to a big city, hit with a single nuke, to put a period to the situation. And that would be both necessary, and sufficient to end it. A 'bishop exchange' in chess terms. Beaton is a city ass to call the farmland "cheap land" because it "isn"t Mar-a-lago". In the REAL world, farmland like Ukraine has is rare over the whole planet and EXTREMELY valuable for providing food for the people who own it. Russia, as vast as it is, and most Americans have zero grasp that Russian land area is by far the largest country in the world, but the overwhelming majority of it is essentially worthless taiga, a wet, poor soil subarctic forest, or vast, agriculturally worthless deserts. That prime, best in the world farmland is very valuable to Russia, and is the primary reason that Stalin and now Putin wanted to take Ukraine for their own 'breadbasket". Beaton may be right that the Russian army is spent, but I believe that Putin believes that with five years of peace, he can rebuild it totally, and having cleaned out the rot in three years of war, then be ready to go for Estonia, Latvia, Lituania and Poland. If Trump's intent is the scare the hell out of the Euroweenies, and they RICHLY deserve it, with threats to pull out of NATO, so that their 2% of GDP for their defense, which most cheated hard on, has now become 5% of GDP that they are scrambling to willingly spend, then as a gambit to kick them in the butt, I like it. If it is really pulling out of NATO, I don't like it. The USA as an equal partner, although it can never actually be equal, it can be far more equal, NATO with more members, including the previously neutral and relatively neutered Finland and Sweden, can once again be a REAL deterrent to a resurgent, imperialistic Russia. And don't imagine that "Putin can't last forever" will change anything. There are many more Russian imperialists in line behind him, although not too close, lest they fall out of a 7 story window, to carry on the imperialistic fever to 'rebuild the Soviet Union', a sick fever dream that has never died in the minds of too many Russians. In real poititk, it may be sadly necessary to trade some Ukrainian farmland for peace. This will be a bit more difficult than most ignorant Americans think, and if you react "I'm not an ignorant American", this formerly ignorant American, who was ONLY able to put together a reasonable understanding of the truly unique Russian psyche at the very end of 10 years of working and traveling with them for long periods, will tell you, yes, you do NOT understand the Russian psyche, it is NOT like you think, and the space doesn't permit explanation, and you would not believe me anyway. I know, because I wouldn't have believed it had I not lived it. In any case, we have to live in the real world. The Russian Duma has made the southern oblasts (states) of Ukraine OFFICIALLY and PERMANENTLY, by law, part of Russia. They do NOT control all of that land, so any sane proposal wouldn't give them MORE land than the large amount that they have actually under control by force of arms. So it's harder than most think , Russia has to rewrite their laws, which can happen but is more embarrassing to Putin and Russians. I have to silver bullet for this war, and even if I did, neither Putin nor Trump is listening to me. I will watch and see. But Trump intentionally embarrassing Ukraine and cozying up to Putin has a lot of stink to it as far as I am concerned. A lot.
4 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Italiano 2/22/2025 11:35:54 AM (No. 1901642)
Glenn is spot on here. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the acceptable.
4 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: DVC 2/22/2025 11:38:23 AM (No. 1901644)
At the end of my post that should read, "I have NO silver bullet....."
1 person likes this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: jeffkinnh 2/22/2025 11:40:15 AM (No. 1901645)
There's another aspect to consider. Trump will finish this war one way or another because he WILL NOT commit the US to a long term war. If Trump had won in 2020 the war would not have started. But senile Biden let it happen. The article talks about 3 more years of war but Ukraine will not last that long without US help and they will NOT have it. Trump has blazed a path out. It isn't pretty but it is workable. AND, realistically, it's the only plan on the table. To go on as things are, EVERYONE will lose. With America First, Trump is protecting America and then trying to do the best he can for everyone else.
9 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Bur Oak 2/22/2025 12:05:51 PM (No. 1901673)
If Putin weakens himself too much in the Ukraine he risks the Chinese slicing off some of Siberia.
3 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: Dodge Boy 2/22/2025 12:21:04 PM (No. 1901688)
And Trump's part of the deal. He gets to buy Greenland while Putie goes home and watches. The Art of the Deal.
2 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: franco 2/22/2025 1:07:10 PM (No. 1901714)
#3 & #7 - Good insights. To this I would also like to *dispel* the notion that Russia can't be beaten because it has 3x the number of people that Ukraine has. This is favorite talking point of Tucker Carlson. Problem is, by Carlson's logic the nation-state of Israel (outnumbered 15-20 to 1 in various wars since modern-day founding) should also not exist. And yet it does. If "the west" has the stomach to finance Ukraine for 3+ more years (not likely, either in DC or the capitals of western Europe, which are used to Uncle Sam footing their defense bills), Ukraine is showing now that a 3x manpower advantage can be overcome quite easily by flooding the air with drones that kill Russians and Koreans easily for tens of dollars each.
1 person likes this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: earlybird 2/22/2025 1:18:19 PM (No. 1901720)
What #9 is ttalking about? Ukraine Is Daring Russia To Open Fire On Swarms Of New Trembita Drones. Many Of The Drones Will Be Decoys. https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2025/02/21/ukraine-is-daring-russia-to-open-fire-on-swarms-of-new-trembita-drones-many-of-the-drones-will-be-decoys/
0 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: earlybird 2/22/2025 1:28:33 PM (No. 1901726)
Meanwhile Russia has drones: Ukraine's air defence downs 82 drones overnight, 75 more go off radar https://www.yahoo.com/news/ukraines-air-defence-downs-82-060825358.html
0 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: caljeepgirl 2/22/2025 5:50:24 PM (No. 1901848)
This is a wonderful, very clear presentation of all the realities of the situation! Answered all my questions....
1 person likes this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Big Bopper"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Big Bopper"
Trump is thinking outside the Ukrainian box 12 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/22/2025 11:00:38 AM Post Reply
Inside the box, and the Beltway, the thinking all along has been that we must draw a line at Ukraine, else Putin and the barbarians will soon be on the steps of Warsaw and then Berlin and Paris. Besides, Russian aggression and aggressors are morally bad. We owe it to posterity and civilization not to crumble before them. Those are valid points. On the other hand: We are where we are. Where we are, is Vladimir Putin make some understandable miscalculations. One, he miscalculated America’s willingness to support foreign countries. After all, he had witnessed Joe Biden’s Afghanistan surrender debacle.
Colorado wolves are casualties in the
culture wars
7 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/20/2025 9:51:09 AM Post Reply
Wolves roamed Colorado for millions of years. At the end of the last ice age, they managed to survive the mass extinctions of megafauna such as mammoths, mastodons, sabertooth tigers, giant cave bears, and huge sloths, an extinction event that was probably caused in part by the arrival of humans from Asia at about the same time. Until the much later arrival of Europeans, those early Americans were living in the stone age. Their weapons were stone-tipped spears and arrows. They didn’t even have horses. But they hunted in a way that was deadly to large herding animals and the predators of the herds: They used fire.
I wish Trump were right about birthright
citizenship, but he’s probably not
21 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/17/2025 12:58:35 PM Post Reply
In determining citizenship, the United States has a very unusual approach. You’re a citizen if you were born here. (You’re also a citizen if you were born abroad under certain circumstances, but that’s a different issue.) That’s a bit crazy, because it means that if a woman (aren’t you glad we don’t have to refer to them as “child-birthing persons” anymore?) makes it into the United States, legally or illegally, in time to give birth – right on the north bank of the Rio Grande, for example – her baby is an American citizen. The mother doesn’t magically become an American citizen by giving birth in America,
Kennedy had a cult-like following. So
did Obama. Personally, I’ll take Trump.
13 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/16/2025 1:03:22 PM Post Reply
The Trump-is-Hitler crowd dismisses the 77 million Americans who elected Donald Trump to the Presidency, for the second time, as a cult. They aren’t suggesting that these 77 million people are a cult because they were opposed to another four years of Joe Biden’s drooling corruption. Rather, they’re suggesting that these people are card-carrying, Kool Aid-drinking Trump worshippers. Let’s put this in context. One of the defining characteristics of cults is that they idolize a charismatic, authoritarian leader. Such leaders get away with a lot.
Democrats have run out of epithets, now
they’ll have to talk
5 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/14/2025 8:14:54 PM Post Reply
“Hitler” was their favorite. Trump was “just like Hitler,” they warned us. Forget about the fact that Trump has close relatives who are Jewish and was a staunch supporter of Israel in his first term – and also before and after. And forget the fact that it’s the Democrats who proudly exhibit sympathy for barbarians who mass-murder, mass-behead and mass-rape the Jews. Democrats’ proof that Trump was Hitler despite the facts we are supposed to forget was that Trump wanted to disallow the illegal immigration of Latinos into America, just like Hitler wanted to disallow the illegal immigration of Jews into Germany. Er, no, that’s not it. Anywaaaaay, you get the point.
Was Michelle Obama a DEI bride? 15 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/11/2025 6:24:29 PM Post Reply
I have nothing against Michelle. The media tells us that she’s pretty, she’s smart, she’s accomplished, and I’m sure she’s charming. As her husband said about Hillary Clinton, she’s “likable enough.” OK, I’ll admit that I didn’t particularly like her comment that the first time she was proud of America was the night Barack was elected. Surely there was a time in her first 45 years before then that she felt some pride in America. How about when the 1980 Olympic Hockey Team beat the Russians? How about when we put a man on the Moon? How about when we passed the Civil Rights Acts?
Democrats are still owned by their hate 4 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/3/2025 5:46:10 PM Post Reply
It was predicted that the changing demographics of America – specifically, more racial minorities – would deliver permanent control of the government to the Democrats by now. Instead, over the past few years the Democrats have lost the Presidency, the Senate, the House, a majority of governorships, a majority of state legislatures, and the Supreme Court. This isn’t just about Donald Trump, though his approval ratings are higher than ever while Joe Biden’s (who?) are lower than ever. It’s broader than that. The approval ratings of Democrats are at historic lows in general, while the approval ratings for Republicans are near all-time highs.
Test scores suggest that 98% of us are
becoming expendable
3 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 2/1/2025 2:01:54 PM Post Reply
Democrats in the Federal government the past few years sent a couple hundred billion dollars to the teachers’ unions the schools to help them fund teacher vacations recover from the needless and destructive COVID lockdowns. I shouldn’t be so cynical about the COVID lockdowns. After all, they did apparently prevent the pandemic from spreading to children, along with preventing asteroid strikes and on-campus bear maulings, all three of which were notably absent in 2020-2021. Oops, I’m being cynical again. OK, I’ll admit that, as an educational tool, the lockdowns were not entirely wasted. For example,
This just in: Illegals are criminals 15 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 1/29/2025 11:04:57 AM Post Reply
For years, the legacy media (hereinafter the “Leg-Meds”) parroted the Democrats’ line that the population of immigrants can be divided into the “documented” ones and the “undocumented” ones. The euphemism “undocumented” finally became a joke, and so the Leg-Meds and the other Democrats eventually surrendered to the word “illegal.” However, within that category of “illegals,” they clung (bitterly) to the notion that about 99.9999999% were “law-abiding” and only the remaining 0.0000001% were criminals. That lie was called out yesterday by President Trump’s new press secretary.
Elites rediscover the power of religion
– to control you
5 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 1/26/2025 6:51:32 PM Post Reply
Pseudo-intellectual elites like to talk about the “arc of history.” Barack Obama loved that phrase almost as much as he loved the word “existential.” Things in Barack’s rhetorical world didn’t just exist. They were in the state of “existential” and forever bending along the “arc of history.” The elites assured that this “arc of history” will take us inevitably to a world of equity, inclusion and diversity – a utopian world the elites have always imagined. They even have a theme song for the journey: “Imagine there’s no heaven, above us only sky, Blah, blah, blah, blahhhh . . .”
Angels at the podium? 4 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 1/22/2025 11:35:01 AM Post Reply
Political candidates aren’t always seen by 19,000 people in big sexy arenas like Madison Square Garden. They also play the rubber chicken circuit at little outdoor makeshift venues of a few hundred or a thousand people in rural America. These are places you would never visit unless you were looking for votes. Think “County Fair.” So it was for Donald Trump one ordinary day last summer. He was on an outdoor plywood stage in rural Pennsylvania looking for votes from plain folk. He was just a few minutes into his stump speech, or his stump speech du jour.
Trump brilliantly baited Biden into admitting
the guilt of the Biden-ites
7 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 1/20/2025 7:01:32 PM Post Reply
In one of his very final acts as the putative President, literally minutes before Donald Trump was re-inaugurated, the Big Guy issued a pardon to all his siblings and their spouses. Joe’s five pardons together with his earlier pardon of his son Hunter for tax evasion and gun-running convictions (and all other crimes known and unknown over a period of ten years) bring Joe’s pardons of family members to a total of six. In case you’re wondering what crimes these six family members could possibly have committed that required a presidential pardon, let’s just say it was a family business. It was a lucrative one
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
MSNBC cancels Joy Reid’s lefty show
as network makes major shakeup
48 replies
Posted by Skinnydip 2/23/2025 9:18:54 AM Post Reply
MSNBC liberal mainstay Joy Reid’s show has been canceled as part of a major overhaul by the network’s new president Rebecca Kutler, according to a report. The 7 p.m. program hosted by ardent Trump critic Reid, 56, will be replaced by a new panel show featuring co-hosts Alicia Menendez, Michael Steele, and Symone Sanders Townsend, the New York Times reported, citing insiders.
‘We’re Mad as Hell’: Fuming Canadians
Nix U.S. Vacations to Protest President
Donald Trump’s Tariffs
39 replies
Posted by Imright 2/23/2025 2:36:06 AM Post Reply
Miffed Canadians are opting out of American vacations as President Donald Trump imposes tariffs on their country to protect his own nation and its people. The Canadians’ decision not to visit America is having an effect on air and land travel as they push back against the tariffs levied against their nation, the New York Post reported on Saturday. (X) On January 31, the White House confirmed that Trump was preparing to impose fresh tariffs on major U.S. trading partners in an effort to shield American industry and national security, per Breitbart News’s John Carney:
California asks US government for billions
in fire relief funds
37 replies
Posted by snakeoil 2/22/2025 10:41:41 PM Post Reply
California Governor Gavin Newsom has asked the US federal government for $40 billion (£31.6b) in funds to help rebuild areas of Los Angeles devastated by January fires. Newsom sent the request to congressional leaders in a letter on Friday. He said the funds would help both immediate and long-term recovery work. "I'm asking Congress to have the back of the American people and provide disaster funding to help Californians recover and rebuild as soon as possible," he wrote on social media.
Kamala Harris snipes at Trump and Elon
Musk in NAACP Image Awards speech: ‘Shadows
gathering over our democracy’
36 replies
Posted by Imright 2/23/2025 10:16:25 AM Post Reply
She lost the election, but she’ll always have the NAACP Chairman’s Award. Former Vice President Kamala Harris reemerged in the public limelight for her first major speech since departing the White House Saturday night and took not-so-subtle shots at both President Trump and tech mogul Elon Musk. During an acceptance speech at the 56th annual NAACP Image Awards, Harris painted a bleak picture of the state of the country and urged attendees not to lose hope as her own party struggles over its direction amid Trump’s return. (Photo) “While we have no illusions about what we are up against in this chapter in our American story, this chapter will be written
Wisconsin Democratic governor proposes
replacing 'mother' with 'inseminated person'
in state law
32 replies
Posted by Moritz55 2/22/2025 1:35:07 PM Post Reply
Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers, a Democrat, is facing backlash for introducing a budget recommendation that changes the word "mother" to "inseminated person," and "paternity" to "parentage" in certain parts of state law. The Evers administration's budget recommendation for the 2025-2027 fiscal period advises several other gendered terms be changed, as well. References to "wife" or "husband" are changed to "spouse" in the proposal. In other places, the word "father" is changed to "parent," and "mother" is swapped out for the phrase "parent who gave birth to the child.”
Top Trump Officials — Including FBI
Director Kash Patel — Instruct Their
Employees to Blow Off Elon Musk’s Email
Demand to Justify Their Jobs Or Resign
30 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 2/23/2025 12:38:46 PM Post Reply
Top officials of President Donald Trump’s administration — including newly-confirmed FBI director Kash Patel — are instructing their employees not to respond to an email sent late Saturday from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) which asked them to justify their jobs. Trump senior advisor Elon Musk has warned that failure to respond to the email will be considered a resignation. Sent late Saturday with the subject line “What did you do last week?”, the email — which was sent to staff at multiple federal agencies — demanded federal employees justify their jobs.
Pope Francis in critical condition, Vatican says 30 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/22/2025 3:27:59 PM Post Reply
Pope Francis is in critical condition after suffering an asthmatic respiratory crisis that required doctors to administer oxygen, The Associated Press reported, citing the Vatican. [Snip] Vatican News reported that medical professionals say the pope is not "in danger of death," but is not completely "out of danger" and will need to be hospitalized for "at least" all of next week. ... Fox News senior medical analyst Dr. Marc Siegel told "Fox News Live" that he is "looking very closely at the next 12 hours," as he says that time is critical.
Poll: Nearly a Quarter of Gen Z Identifies
as LGBTQ+
30 replies
Posted by Imright 2/22/2025 7:44:58 AM Post Reply
LGBTQ+ identification in the United States has spiked to 9.3 percent — an increase driven by Generation Z adults, a poll has found. The percentage of U.S. adults who say they are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or something other than heterosexual has nearly doubled from 2020 and is up from a mere 3.5 percent in 2012, according to the Gallup survey. “In the 12 years that Gallup has been tracking LGBTQ+ identification, it has nearly tripled, as those becoming adults during that period have been far more likely than their elders to say they are lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender,” Gallup “The recent increase is largely due to
Freaky: Wisconsin Gov. Evers Comes Up
With Truly Bizarre Name for 'Mother'
29 replies
Posted by Hazymac 2/23/2025 8:09:40 AM Post Reply
I’ve written about how the left uses language to (often falsely) shape political and social narratives. Abortion is “health care.” Illegal aliens are “undocumented citizens.” The homeless are the “unhoused,” or recently and more and more ridiculously, “people experiencing homelessness,” while people who have ties to Latin America are “Latinx” (although most Latinos in reality want nothing to do with the term). One the silliest arguments they regularly bring forth, though, is regarding the term “woman”—what does it mean? Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson doesn’t know; meanwhile, many leftists define it as “anyone who identifies as one.” Right. Enter Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers (D, but you probably already knew that),
MSNBC's John Brennan: 'Absurd' To Say
Fired Joint Chiefs Head Had Woke Agenda
24 replies
Posted by Imright 2/23/2025 2:45:42 AM Post Reply
On Saturday's edition of MSNBC's The Weekend, former CIA Director and current MSNBC analyst John Brennan claimed it was "absurd" to suggest that President Trump fired C.Q. Brown, who Biden had appointed Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, because he had a woke agenda. Absurd? Really? After the death of George Floyd in 2020, Brown put out a video in which he focused on his own trials and tribulations as an African-American, and concluded by saying that he wanted "to lead and listen to necessary conversations on racism, diversity, and inclusion."
Unfixable cars? Enough already! 22 replies
Posted by mc squared 2/23/2025 12:02:41 PM Post Reply
I am old enough to have owned a half-dozen cars or trucks with no computers, including a 1941 Ford coup, a 1956 Chevrolet two-door sedan, and a 1966 Chevrolet Malibu. Fixing these vehicles to make them run correctly took some rudimentary skills and a Motors Manual. The electrical system comprised wires, fuses, and a fuse box. The fuel system was simple as well. Diagnosing the problems was simple, and I could fix it all myself. Even the carburetor was not that hard to rebuild. [snip]Under the guise of helping to clean up the environment, the program all but eliminated all cars and parts
Poll: Most Democrats Oppose Trump’s
Embrace of Biological Truth Recognizing
Two Sexes
22 replies
Posted by Imright 2/22/2025 12:31:36 AM Post Reply
A majority of Americans agree with President Donald Trump’s embrace of biological truth in recognizing only two biological sexes — but most Democrats do not — a Quinnipiac survey found. The survey — gauging sentiments on many of Trump’s early moves — asked respondents, “Do you support or oppose President Trump’s executive order recognizing only two sexes, male and female, in the United States?” Most, 57 percent, support it, compared to 38 percent who oppose it. There are varying opinions on party lines, as over three-fourths of Democrats — 77 percent, oppose the executive order recognizing biological truth. Only 14 percent of Democrats support the order.
Post New Article