Post New Article

The Truth About World
War II

Original Article

Posted By: Mercedes44, 9/5/2024 6:31:22 AM

In a recent and now widely seen Tucker Carlson interview, a guest historian named Darryl Cooper casually presented a surprising number of flawed theories about World War II. He focused his misstatements on the respective roles of Winston Churchill’s Britain and Adolf Hitler’s Germany—especially in matters of the treatment and fate of Russian prisoners, the Holocaust, the systematic slaughtering of Jews, strategic bombing, and the nature of Winston Churchill. Because of the size of the audience Carlson introduced him to, and because of the gravity of Cooper’s falsehoods, his assertions deserve a response.

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: petrichor 9/5/2024 7:43:19 AM (No. 1790678)
Well done by VDH. It is foolish to try and rewrite your own history when in earshot of Victor David Hansen.
54 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: downnout 9/5/2024 7:54:54 AM (No. 1790688)
VDH is a world treasure.
49 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: cThree 9/5/2024 7:56:10 AM (No. 1790690)
Reading VDH is never a waste of time. This concise review of the stupefying magnitude and savagery of World War II is a vital antidote to the natural inclination to rewrite and paper over events and policies that overwhelm reason and morality.
47 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: philsner 9/5/2024 7:56:20 AM (No. 1790691)
I didn't see the interview. Did Carlson buy into Cooper's version?
9 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: BarryNo 9/5/2024 8:06:57 AM (No. 1790699)
Completely agree with Victor on this matter. Historical Revisionism is usually the first step of a new wave of such atrocity. Check who funds Darryl Cooper's lectures. Russia is equally guilty. Hitler may have plotted to backstab his ally, but for Russia, especially under the Communists, this was SOP. Nazism was birthed from Communism, and both were reinforced by the writings of American and European Elites who were enamored of Eugenics and a world "rid of the superstitions of religion". Marx was an open Satanist, who may have believed he WAS Satan. If the West was responsible for WWII or even WWI, for that matter, it was because of Liberal Elites poisoning the minds of Elite wannabes through their abhorrent philosophies.
33 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: Calvinesq 9/5/2024 8:25:09 AM (No. 1790707)
I have not seen the Cooper interview by Tucker, just some snippets of aghast reactions on other sites. But, if Cooper was espousing falsehoods without push back from Tucker, then Tucker needs to get VDH on his platform to allow VDH to state his measured and intelligent reaction to Cooper's blathering. I have read VDH's writings and book on WWII, and each is brilliant. Thanks VDH.
37 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: Wetenschapper 9/5/2024 8:38:47 AM (No. 1790710)
I absolutely agree with reply #6. If Carlson wants to retain so much as a soupcon of credibility after his disastrous and sycophantic Cooper interview, he absolutely needs to host a 'counterpoint' interview with Hanson, or he risks being written off as a crank.
39 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: VAPMAN 9/5/2024 8:50:15 AM (No. 1790720)
I am deeply into VDH’s book ‘The Second World Wars’. I suggest Cooper and Carlson read it before further comment on WW2.
23 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: Corndoggies 9/5/2024 8:57:14 AM (No. 1790725)
Does Darryl’s middle name start with a B?
8 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: VirtuDawg 9/5/2024 9:05:46 AM (No. 1790735)
It appears that Tucker, unfortunately, has jumped the shark . . . getting more into weird conspiracy theories these days.
16 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Kate318 9/5/2024 9:18:43 AM (No. 1790744)
Careful, #10. If experience has shown us anything—especially these last three years—today’s “conspiracy theory” is tomorrow’s “I told you so.”
17 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: Quigley 9/5/2024 9:22:43 AM (No. 1790747)
I wonder how many people born after 1980 have any sense of the monumental history that is WW2. I remember when Dole - a WW2 veteran - was still on the political scene and Clinton, born after WW2, was a newcomer, how Clinton thought that "World War 2 stuff" was so anachronistic for the times. I wonder what currents - both of human natural and societal-geographic - predating WW2 are still at play, and what role whoever runs the US sees the US as having. Big Bidet was born in 1942, Trump in 1946. I can't believe that whoever runs this country believes in the wokeisms other than as a screen behind which to accomplish something nefarious, ie, a war type psyops.
14 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: franq 9/5/2024 9:36:59 AM (No. 1790756)
A well-written rebuttal. The old saying, "In a war, truth is the first casualty" applies. Don't know Carlson's heart. Sometimes, the bizarre sells. FOX is about ratings, just like all other networks.
4 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: Italiano 9/5/2024 9:48:23 AM (No. 1790765)
VDH vs. whoever Darryl Cooper is? Mercy killing. I like Tucker, but he may be going off the rails.
14 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: LadyHen 9/5/2024 11:04:23 AM (No. 1790808)
In a free society, it is never wrong to have the free exchange of ideas and theories and the orthodoxy can be very wrong as we have seen time and time again in countless wars. That said, when VDH literally waits less than 24 hours to rebut your entire premise and relay the documented facts, maybe you should reconsider your career choices.
13 people like this.

Reply 16 - Posted by: DVC 9/5/2024 11:14:49 AM (No. 1790816)
Tucker was stupid to give a lunatic revisionist history jerk such a large audience. Such nutballs exist, but we shouldn't pay attention to their falsehoods. Thanks to VDH for correcting the record.
23 people like this.

Reply 17 - Posted by: RubiconDan 9/5/2024 11:53:17 AM (No. 1790832)
Tucker jumped the shark a long time ago. Now he is not interested in truth, just clickbait and money. I think he is an idiot.
9 people like this.

Reply 18 - Posted by: Luke21 9/5/2024 12:15:28 PM (No. 1790842)
God bless VDH. This answers the call devoid of emotion. The smearing of the great Churchill made my blood boil. What a revisionist scum*bag this dude was. Shame on Tucker Carlson.
6 people like this.

Reply 19 - Posted by: kono 9/5/2024 12:40:04 PM (No. 1790854)
VDH is usually insightful and clear. That's why I tend to consider him a worthwhile read. In this post, though, we have Cooper analyzing conventional history of WWII, Carlson analyzing Cooper's work, and VDH analyzing the whole thing (with focus on analyzing Carlson's work). With several layers of analysis, it's so necessary to be clear about who made what claim and what claim is true or false. Or the potential for double / triple negatives leave my head a little dizzy. I feel like I won't understand what VDH has said here, until I study more WWII history, then study Cooper's critique of that, and then watch Carlson's evaluation of that. Case in point from the start: "It is simply not true, as Cooper alleges, that Hitler’s Wehrmacht was completely surprised" Did Cooper allege the Wehrmacht was surprised? Or that the surprise claim is simply not true? I'll have to come back to this when I have more time.
4 people like this.

Reply 20 - Posted by: homefry 9/6/2024 7:43:32 AM (No. 1791160)
I have always believed that fdr goaded japan into attacking us, so he could get us into the war and end the depression that he had not been able to with his leftwing lunatic policies.
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Mercedes44"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Mercedes44"
AP Deletes JD Vance Tweet After Fact Checkers
Call Them Out
3 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/6/2024 11:46:44 AM Post Reply
The Associated Press deleted a tweet Thursday aimed at Ohio Republican Sen. J.D. Vance after fact checkers called them out for misrepresenting his comment on school shootings. The tweet linked to an article about Vance, implying that he’d called school shootings a “fact of life” shortly after a deadly shooting at Apalachee High School in Georgia on Wednesday. The AP replaced the story roughly 90 minutes with correct context, that Vance said he “laments that school shootings are a ‘fact of life’ and says the U.S. needs to harden security to prevent more carnage” like the attack in Georgia.
U.S. Campuses: The 'Taboo' Ignored Pandemic
of Muslim Jew-Hate
1 reply
Posted by Mercedes44 9/6/2024 11:44:46 AM Post Reply
ADL further recorded a total of 400 antisemitic incidents on college and university campuses, compared to only 33 incidents during the same period in 2022. Ugly incidents of U.S. campus antisemitism persisted throughout the spring 2024 semester year. Routine empirical, if taboo, observation clearly indicates that often, the most vociferous and violent U.S. student campus antisemites share a common Islamic/Muslim religio-ethnic identity. A courageous, expansive Brandeis University study was just published addressing the potential validity of this anecdotal observation by analyzing U.S. undergraduate college student religious affiliation as a critical, independent factor animating their Jew-hatred.
Harris Campaign Reportedly Said It Doesn’t
Take Lobbyist Money — But Public Records
Tell Different Story
2 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/6/2024 11:42:28 AM Post Reply
Vice President Kamala Harris’ campaign has reportedly said it rejects money from lobbyists, but a Daily Caller News Foundation review of campaign finance records casts doubt on this claim. Dozens of lobbyists have contributed to Harris’ campaign since the vice president took over President Joe Biden’s reelection operation on July 21, an analysis of Federal Election Commission (FEC) records shows. The deluge of lobbyist cash came after The New York Times and Politico reported that Harris was continuing Biden’s policy of not accepting direct contributions from individual lobbyists.
Breaking the Power of the LGBTQ Mafia 4 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/6/2024 11:40:52 AM Post Reply
While transgender orthodoxy seems rooted ever deeper in American education, entertainment, and society, the LGBTQ lobby’s stranglehold over big business is finally loosening. A key organization that uses mafia-like tactics to pressure companies to toe the line on gender ideology has faced setbacks. Molson Coors Beverage Co., the company that produces Coors Light beer, announced to employees Tuesday that it will no longer participate in the Human Rights Campaign’s corporate equality index. Robby Starbuck, a former music video director who exposes and combats the Left’s diversity, equity, and inclusion programs, revealed Molson Coors’ announcement on X.
Telegram founder Pavel Durov makes first
public comments since French authorities
targeted him and his app
0 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/6/2024 11:38:59 AM Post Reply
Telegram founder and CEO Pavel Durov is promising stepped-up efforts to fight criminality on the messaging app, his first public comments since French authorities handed him preliminary charges for allegedly allowing the platform’s use for criminal activity. In a Telegram post, Durov defended himself against the French judicial investigation, suggesting that he personally shouldn’t have been targeted. “Using laws from the pre-smartphone era to charge a CEO with crimes committed by third parties on the platform he manages is a misguided approach,” the post said. “Building technology is hard enough as it is.
The Truth About World
War II
20 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/5/2024 6:31:22 AM Post Reply
In a recent and now widely seen Tucker Carlson interview, a guest historian named Darryl Cooper casually presented a surprising number of flawed theories about World War II. He focused his misstatements on the respective roles of Winston Churchill’s Britain and Adolf Hitler’s Germany—especially in matters of the treatment and fate of Russian prisoners, the Holocaust, the systematic slaughtering of Jews, strategic bombing, and the nature of Winston Churchill. Because of the size of the audience Carlson introduced him to, and because of the gravity of Cooper’s falsehoods, his assertions deserve a response.
Trump to skip federal court hearing Thursday,
plead not guilty to charges in Jack Smith's election
7 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/5/2024 6:28:05 AM Post Reply
Lawyers are expected to enter a not guilty plea on behalf of former President Trump in federal court in Washington, D.C., Thursday related to charges from special counsel Jack Smith’s new indictment after the Supreme Court ruled a president is immune from prosecution for official acts in office. Trump will not appear in court Thursday, but his lawyers are expected to enter a not guilty plea during the status hearing before U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan. According to a court filing obtained by Fox News, Trump signed an entry of not guilty plea. In the document, filed on Tuesday, Trump also waived his right to be present at his arraignment.
Kamala Harris accepts muted mic rule in
upcoming debate with Donald Trump after
initial pushback
11 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/5/2024 6:26:03 AM Post Reply
Vice President Kamala Harris’ campaign has backed off from its demand that microphones be unmuted for the duration of Democratic nominee’s upcoming debate against former President Donald Trump. “Candidates’ microphones will be live only for the candidate whose turn it is to speak and muted when the time belongs to another candidate,” read the debate rules released by ABC News on Wednesday. The Sep. 10 showdown in Philadelphia had been agreed to by both campaigns in early August, but the Harris team launched a last-minute bid to change the debate rules over fears that having microphones muted for parts of the 90-minute event would be favorable for Trump.
The First Ten Minutes - "The Illusion
of Choice"
4 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/5/2024 6:24:16 AM Post Reply
Economist Eric Weinstein says he doesn’t know if Trump “will be allowed” to become president, says the goal of the World Order is to have two candidates who are both acceptable to them. “Democracy was the illusion of choice…” “You had two candidates that were both acceptable to the international order… We called that democracy. And so, democracy was the illusion of choice. That’s called magician’s choice.” “Magician’s choice in the primaries, and then you’d have the duopoly field, two candidates, either of which was acceptable, and you could actually afford to hold an election and the populace would vote.” “Donald Trump broke through the primary structure.”
More Than Anything, Survival of the Constitution
Is on the Ballot in 2024
5 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/4/2024 11:56:05 AM Post Reply
The dividing lines between Republicans and Democrats are now more like ever-widening chasms. We can barely see each other from our entrenched positions. There is a lot of talk in mainstream media and among Democrats about a fundamental shift in the Republican party because of Donald Trump's influence. The only thing that's changing in the GOP is the way the party goes about the business of politics. Trump has energized the people who long ago grew tired of losing to Democrats because the Bush Republicans were more interested in angling for Fox News jobs than in winning elections.
Funny how many Democrats are getting arrested
for Chinese spying - feds pick up a new
one from Kathy Hochul's office
18 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/4/2024 11:54:20 AM Post Reply
For all their pious claims to being the standard-bearers and guardians of national security since President Trump was elected in 2016, Democrats sure do have a lot of operatives getting picked up as spies for China. The latest came out of the woodwork from New York Gov. Kathy Hochul's office. According to the Associated Press: A former New York state government official who worked for former Gov. Andrew Cuomo and current Gov. Kathy Hochul was charged Tuesday with acting as an undisclosed agent of the Chinese government, federal prosecutors revealed in a sprawling indictment.
Feckless Biden and Kamala have thrown
Israel to the wolves with their ignorance
and betrayal
4 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 9/4/2024 9:11:42 AM Post Reply
As fate would have it, the 79th anniversary of the formal Japanese surrender in World War II came on the same day that Joe Biden all but encouraged Hamas to keep fighting and holding hostages in Gaza. The contrast suggests that had Biden been president back then instead of Harry Truman, America would have lost the Second World War. Truman boldly led the free world to total victory, while Biden is an appeaser from head to toe. He is a modern incarnation of Neville Chamberlain, the British prime minister so desperate for peace that he convinced himself Adolf Hitler wanted the same thing.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Lifelong Republican and former Vice President
Dick Cheney breaks with GOP to back Kamala
Harris, daughter says
64 replies
Posted by Beardo 9/6/2024 4:51:51 PM Post Reply
Former Vice President Dick Cheney, a lifelong Republican, will vote for Kamala Harris for president, his daughter Liz Cheney said Friday. (snip) In a campaign ad for Liz Cheney as she sought a fourth term as Wyoming’s lone congressperson, Dick Cheney called Trump a “coward” for trying to “steal the last election using lies and violence to keep himself in power after the voters had rejected him.” The ad did little good for his daughter in a deep-red state that once held the Cheney family dear but is now thoroughly in Trump’s corner. By a 2-to-1 margin, Liz Cheney lost her Republican primary to Trump-endorsed attorney Harriet Hageman.
Who Really Is Barack Obama? A Counterintelligence Inquiry 22 replies
Posted by earlybird 9/6/2024 3:20:18 PM Post Reply
Donald J. Trump is back in the news regarding intelligence. The former president who’s again the GOP’s nominee for the office announced that he won’t be receiving classified intelligence briefings as our Nov. 5 election approaches. Although major party nominees for the White House have received such briefings from the Intelligence Community in recent decades, to prepare them for the national security demands of the Oval Office if elected, Trump is refusing such briefings on the grounds that he doesn’t want to be accused of leaking any classified information
I'm Outta Here! 'Disgusted' Alan Dershowitz
Announces He's Ditching the Democratic Party
21 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 9/6/2024 10:51:30 PM Post Reply
Harvard Professor of Law Emeritus Alan Dershowitz has proven to be a wealth of (often but not always) solid commentary and analysis in recent years, as he is one of the few on the left side of the political aisle who’s been willing to point out that much of the endless Democrat lawfare against Donald Trump has been a banana republic style of justice and runs counter to our Constitution. He’s also been a lifelong Democrat, which has been head-scratching to me. I sometimes wish I could ask, “How can you be a lifelong Democrat—did you hear what you yourself just said?”
Joe’s pardoning of Hunter will seal
historians’ judgment on Joe
21 replies
Posted by Big Bopper 9/6/2024 7:02:57 PM Post Reply
Hunter, it seems, just can’t get a break. First, he gets convicted of all three counts on an illegal gun purchase. That doesn’t sound like much but it carries a potential 25-year sentence. Bad luck, that conviction. This week, his trial for tax evasion was to begin. At the last minute, he trotted out a scheme where he pleads guilty without admitting guilt. (It’s a lawyer thing.) The prosecutors were having none of it, and the judge was skeptical. So then, Hunter just entered a straight guilty plea on all nine counts. They carry a potential 17-year sentence. If he were sentenced to the maximum on both the gun and the tax charges,
Guess Who Showed Up as Cops Were Arresting
Fani Willis' Daughter
20 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 9/6/2024 12:24:52 PM Post Reply
Just when you thought you were safe from headlines about Fani Willis, she somehow manages to make news. This time, Fani is in the news not for something she did but because she inserted herself into her daughter’s legal issues. This week, we’ve learned that police arrested Fani’s daughter Kinaya Willis on Aug. 24 for driving with a suspended license in Tyrone, Ga., a suburban area south of Atlanta. Atlanta News First has the details: Around 7 p.m. on Aug. 24, a Tyrone police officer saw a Nissan Altima with “a female driver holding a cellphone to her ear” on Highway 74
Chicago columnist says he'd rather get
rid of Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu than Hamas
20 replies
Posted by FlyRight 9/6/2024 12:01:03 PM Post Reply
Chicago Sun-Times columnist Neil Steinberg wrote this week that he’d sooner see the world rid of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu than the terror group Hamas. In a recent column decrying the horrors of Israel’s war in Gaza – which he stated are being unleashed by both sides – Steinberg mentioned his belief that Netanyahu is a more destructive force than the terror group that killed or kidnapped nearly 1500 people in Israel on Oct. 7, 2023. "If I had a choice between getting rid of Hamas and getting rid of Netanyahu, I’d choose Netanyahu," Steinberg said,
Florida Doctor Allegedly Removed Patient's
Liver Instead of Spleen, Killing Him
20 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 9/6/2024 8:29:38 AM Post Reply
An Alabama man entered a Florida hospital for a procedure to remove his spleen. On Aug. 21, medical records provided to USA Today by Zarzaur Law show that "Dr. Thomas Shaknovsky performed a hand-assisted laparoscopic splenectomy procedure on William “Bill” Bryan, 70, from Muscle Shoals, Alabama." Bryan's widow claims that Shaknovsky mistakenly removed his liver instead of his spleen. “Dr. Shaknovsky removed Mr. Bryan’s liver and, in so doing, transected the major vasculature supplying the liver, causing immediate and catastrophic blood loss resulting in death,” the statement from the law firm said. “The surgeon proceeded with labeling the removed liver specimen as a 'spleen,' and it wasn’t until following the death
Jonathan Turley Says He Thinks ‘Merchan
Was Aware’ Sentencing Trump Before Election
Would Help Him Win
18 replies
Posted by Beardo 9/6/2024 5:02:59 PM Post Reply
George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley on Friday said that Judge Juan Merchan’s decision to delay former President Donald Trump’s sentencing could be an effort to avoid boosting his campaign. Merchan had scheduled Trump’s sentencing for Sept. 18, but on Friday, he postponed the date to Nov. 26 “if necessary,” according to his order. Turley, on “America Reports,” claimed that Merchan’s rulings against Trump during his case were advantageous to his reelection bid, suggesting that maintaining the September sentencing date would have further intensified support for the former president.
Alarm grows over possible RFK Jr. role
at HHS if Trump wins
18 replies
Posted by FlyRight 9/6/2024 12:07:54 PM Post Reply
The possibility of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. becoming Health and Human Services (HHS) secretary if former President Trump wins has rankled Democrats and the public health community as he gains influence within the former president’s transition team. Speculation about Kennedy’s future role has grown after Nicole Shanahan, who was Kennedy’s running mate before he suspended his campaign last month, said recently that he would do “an incredible job” at HHS should Trump win in November.
Scientific ‘Experts’ Are Upset That
COVID Vaccine Propaganda is No Longer Working
17 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 9/6/2024 12:14:53 PM Post Reply
Infectious disease experts are upset that four years on from the coronavirus pandemic, members of the public are no longer listening to their “recommendations” regarding vaccines and other supposed prevention methods against COVID-19. According to a report from the leftist The Guardian newspaper, infectious disease experts are complaining that COVID-19 is still a massive threat to the public and people need to continue taking booster vaccines at every opportunity. The report states: Infectious disease experts say many people are not taking the latest Covid-19 wave in the US seriously enough and are not getting vaccinated
Local News 1 teen shot, another arrested
after shooting inside Joppatowne High
School in Maryland
15 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 9/6/2024 3:39:34 PM Post Reply
BALTIMORE -- One student is hospitalized and another is in police custody after a shooting Friday inside Joppatowne High School. According to Harford County Sheriff Jeffrey Gahler, a 16-year-old student allegedly shot a 15-year-old during a fight inside a men's bathroom just after 12:30 p.m. That victim was flown by medical helicopter to the hospital, where he is in serious condition. The alleged teenage gunman ran from the school, but was captured a short time later. "Our hearts are breaking for the victim and the victim's family," said Harford County Schools Superintendent Dr. Sean Bulson. "This should not be happening in schools." "Sadly we stand here today to discuss another school shooting,
YIKES: Tim Walz's Remarks About Gaza Just
Revealed Why They Don't Want Him Answering Questions
15 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 9/6/2024 8:53:18 AM Post Reply
I wrote earlier about Joe Biden's cluelessness when it comes to what's going on with Gaza, Hamas, and making deals with terrorists. Biden keeps leaning on Israel, and that keeps emboldening Hamas. Hamas is now demanding even more to make a deal and even threatening the hostages. That's what bending over and being weak like Biden gets you. But I guess the Harris-Walz team didn't want Biden to have a corner on stupid. They doubled down on the bad takes with what Tim Walz said to WCMU on Thursday. WCMU Public Radio covers Central and Northern Michigan. No wonder there's a reluctance to let him talk. It was awful.
Post New Article