Post New Article

The Lost Submersible As an Analogy

Original Article

Posted By: DVC, 6/24/2023 4:05:04 PM

When the Titanic sank, G.K. Chesterton wrote an essay called “The Great Shipwreck As An Analogy.” Now that this same ship has unexpectedly become the site of another tragedy over a century later, I take the liberty of doing likewise. One must first, of course, say a prayer for the souls of our unfortunate fellow creatures inside the Titan and for their grieving loved ones. [snip] It is one of the marks of modernity that, having overcome various natural discomforts and challenges through feats of engineering, we tend to fancy ourselves as having conquered nature entirely.

Comments:

The author makes some great points. How many of us imagine that the Biblical 'four horsemen of the apocalypse' cannot happen now or here? How many imagine that pestilence, war, famine, and death no longer are major factors? How many believe that these are permanently pushed aside by tech?

Post Reply

Reply 1 - Posted by: swarfer 6/24/2023 4:33:39 PM (No. 1498814)
Breitenbeck throws out a great Chesterton quote, “man is not only governed by what he thinks but by what he chooses to think about.” If you don’t think about the reasonableness of what you’re doing, you probably shouldn’t be doing it.
15 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: JHHolliday 6/24/2023 4:50:06 PM (No. 1498828)
We should certainly be aware of the dangers of today's world but we tend to forget. I can remember being stunned by the Challenger disaster and that it happened "in this day and time" as the author wrote. Those type of things seem worse somehow because, like sitting on top of a massive rocket, you have no control over your fate. Much like those aboard the Titan submersible. At least a racing driver has control of his vehicle with a steering wheel, brake and throttle.
9 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: Cynical Backstory 6/24/2023 5:10:57 PM (No. 1498835)
Control. Humans don’t really control anything. We do the best we can and place our selves in the grace of the lord. We lost a beloved family member last week to a tornado. A freaking tornado. That only happens to strangers five states away until it happens to you. Sure puts you in your place.
19 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Bur Oak 6/24/2023 5:26:04 PM (No. 1498845)
The analogy applies also to companies offering sightseeing trips into space.
8 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: DVC 6/24/2023 6:03:30 PM (No. 1498868)
Reply #4, I get your point and don't entirely disagree, but the space rides are a whole hell of a lot more properly engineered and tested many times than that sub was. I see the comparison, but think that the space rides are probably 100X safer....but certainly not "safe". As #2 says.....in a racing car, you have a lot of control, as in an aerobatic aircraft, or mountain climbing. I will take some risks, but prefer ones where my skills, training and choices of safety equipment increase my chances to something I can accept. I've seen bungee jumping and zip lines.....not a chance I'd do that because I have NO idea what the quality of the materials, rigging, etc are in that situation. OOPS, sorry, won't matter at all.
4 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: JHHolliday 6/24/2023 6:58:08 PM (No. 1498895)
Apologies for the second post. I raced sports cars from Sebring to Daytona back in my invincible youth but I did know the risks. I also saw three drivers killed in what is and was an amateur sport (SCCA). Well, you buy you buy your ticket and accept the risk. It was worth the risk for me because I loved the sport. It's the same with any dangerous endeavor. You also weigh the pleasure versus the chance. We do the same going to the grocery store and assume some nutball is not going to blow past a red light and T-bone us. That said, this submersible seemed to be very poorly engineered and something of a death trap. Use your intelligence and avoid unnecessary risks..
7 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: bad-hair 6/24/2023 7:27:11 PM (No. 1498911)
Nature ... OMG !! The waves were 6 feet high. Nature / North Atlantic ... the waves were 60 (yes SIXTY) feet high. Been there repeatedly. Go to sea PREPARED or stay on shore.
2 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: DVC 6/25/2023 1:22:26 AM (No. 1499002)
Re #7, I am certain you are correct. Two data points: First, I was on a cruise ship in the middle of the Atlantic in 1966 and we were "slapped" by a huge wave that blew in a 2 ft square window about 60 ft above the waterline and broke the legs of one passenger. This seemed like a big deal, but when we reached NY, the much larger ocean liner SS Michaelangelo, on our same track, one day ahead, had been hit by a huge rogue wave, caving in the front of the superstructure, and killing three people, injuring 50 people. Second, a USN officer relative was on the bridge of an aircraft carrier in a North Atlantic storm, and reported seeing BLUE WATER out the bridge windows...not foam, not spray, not 'surf'....solid, blue water. Those windows are about 85 feet above the waterline, and about 500 feet aft of the bow. It is difficult to grasp what sort of a wave it took to do that.
1 person likes this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: DVC 6/25/2023 1:23:20 AM (No. 1499003)
RE #8, photos and details from 1966.
0 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: DVC 6/25/2023 1:23:41 AM (No. 1499004)
Sorry....the link https://www.michelangelo-raffaello.com/en/michelangelo-12-april-1966/
2 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: DrOstrow 6/25/2023 10:39:37 AM (No. 1499215)
Remember shortly after the Challenger disaster someone, referring to space travel, saying ( paraphrased ) - "We had forgotten just how damn dangerous this is". The same is true for many things in life today. Commercial flight is very safe, statistically, but it is because of decades of redesign, testing, backups to the backups, overbuilding, safety margins, redundancy, on and on. But the actual activity - strapping yourself into a multi ton, pressurized aluminum tube and going up to to the air several miles (!) to travel at several HUNDRED miles per hour, on the surface, sounds INSANE !!
1 person likes this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "DVC"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by DVC"
The Lost Submersible As an Analogy 11 replies
Posted by DVC 6/24/2023 4:05:04 PM Post Reply
When the Titanic sank, G.K. Chesterton wrote an essay called “The Great Shipwreck As An Analogy.” Now that this same ship has unexpectedly become the site of another tragedy over a century later, I take the liberty of doing likewise. One must first, of course, say a prayer for the souls of our unfortunate fellow creatures inside the Titan and for their grieving loved ones. [snip] It is one of the marks of modernity that, having overcome various natural discomforts and challenges through feats of engineering, we tend to fancy ourselves as having conquered nature entirely.
Dem Rep. Sherman: We Need Tariffs on China
‘Across the Board’
5 replies
Posted by DVC 6/24/2023 3:34:41 PM Post Reply
On Friday’s broadcast of C-SPAN’s “Washington Journal,” Rep. Brad Sherman (D-CA) stated that the United States’ “big mistake” on China was when we granted China most-favored nation trade status, because giving them that status led to a horribly lopsided trade relationship with China and argued that the way to bring needed change to our trade relationship with China is to impose “tariffs on Chinese goods across the board” that would be far stricter than the tariffs on China imposed under the Trump administration.
The Nuclear Theory You Never Knew Was Nonsense 15 replies
Posted by DVC 6/13/2023 8:12:59 PM Post Reply
Steve Milloy, long-time editor and founder of JunkScience.com, announced an explosive exposé this month in an extended article. Government and private scientists in radiation safety have been attempting to cover up a pattern of misconduct and hijack the Health Physics Society, a professional organization of radiation safety experts and officials, to take down the society's series of twenty-two videos featuring Dr. Ed Calabrese, which exposes a longtime scam in radiation safety matters. The issue is Linear No Threshold Toxicology — LNT for short, also called the "one hit" theory of toxic radiation genetic mutation. These bad actors have also conspired to censor and silence Calabrese
Trump did not violate the law because
he could not violate the law
9 replies
Posted by DVC 6/12/2023 5:07:23 PM Post Reply
Those conservatives rightly outraged at the Trump indictment keep comparing his treatment to that given to Hillary, Biden, and Pence, each of whom admitted to violating national security laws. That’s the wrong argument because Trump is not similarly situated to those lawbreakers. Instead, because he was president when he took possession of the documents, Trump cannot be guilty of the crimes with which he’s charged. It starts with the Constitution, which created three equal branches of government: The legislative branch (Art. I), the executive (presidential) branch (Art. II), and the judiciary (Art. III). As part of his authority as the nation’s chief executive
The fallacious claim that gas stoves cause
childhood asthma
11 replies
Posted by DVC 6/12/2023 3:56:57 PM Post Reply
Recently much has been said and written about gas stoves causing childhood asthma, justifying politicians moving to ban residential gas stoves. We reviewed the epidemiology studies used to support the ban in a recently published study. We demonstrated that the studies were unreliable and there is no basis for the claims made. This essay sums up our findings. NO2 and asthma [snip] Allergens are the basic issue in asthma. Allergens are carbon-based and are mostly protein substances. For example, pollen and plant parts; biological fragments shed from furry animals, rodents, cockroaches, dust mites; and fungal detritus can cause allergenic asthma reactions.
Thank the army, not the jungle, for the
rescue of four Colombian children
7 replies
Posted by DVC 6/11/2023 9:40:49 PM Post Reply
Following the news of a dramatic rescue of four children lost in the Amazon jungle, Colombia's far-left president, Gustavo Petro, praised the children who survived in that fearsome wilderness for 40 days as "children of the jungle." "The jungle saved them" Petro said. "They are children of the jungle, and now they are also children of Colombia. "Children of the jungle"? That's like calling children who survived a nuclear meltdown "children of the reactor" or kids who survived under earthquake rubble "children of the temblor." Does anyone call champion surfer Bethany Hamilton, who was injured in a shark attack as a young girl a "child of the shark"?
The Social Security dilemma 22 replies
Posted by DVC 6/8/2023 3:43:16 PM Post Reply
The experts at the Tax Foundation fret that the current debate about extending the debt ceiling has lost track of the fact that Social Security is a major contributor to our growing deficit and debt crisis. They may be right about the fiscal ADHD on Capitol Hill, however, let’s make sure we are keeping track of the right discussion. It is true that both the growing deficit and long-term stability of Social Security are valid concerns that should draw the attention of Americans. These issues deserve the attention of all voters -- just not in the same sentence.
Target’s stock loses $13.8B, sinks to
lowest level since 2020 over boycotts
29 replies
Posted by DVC 6/1/2023 4:00:27 PM Post Reply
Target’s stock has lost a whopping $13.8 billion over the past two weeks, hitting its lowest levels in nearly three years as the “cheap chic” discount retailer continues to face backlash over LGBTQ-friendly kids clothing. Shares of the embattled chain sank 2.2% at $130.93 on Wednesday after dropping for eight straight sessions — the stock’s longest losing streak since November 2018 — giving the company a market capitalization of $60.4 billion. That’s off 19% from two weeks earlier on May 18, when the stock was trading at $160.96 on the eve of the crisis.
Arrest of Chicago ‘Peacekeeper’ police
substitute demonstrates the folly of ‘defund
the police’
18 replies
Posted by DVC 5/29/2023 1:35:44 PM Post Reply
A man wearing the vest of the new “Peacekeeper” corps deployed over the Memorial Day weekend to stem the mayhem on a holiday weekend that has become an opportunity for murder tallies to soar, was arrested for a violent attack. [snip] A man in a neon “peacekeepers” vest beat up and robbed a man in Little Village on Friday night, police said, as dozens of violence prevention workers fanned out across Chicago over the Memorial Day weekend. Oscar Montes, 31, was in a group of seven or eight people that pulled a man from a car and punched and kicked him
The Nanny State Stains a Deck 8 replies
Posted by DVC 5/29/2023 1:30:11 PM Post Reply
When candidates run for public office — local, state, or federal — they campaign on some careful blend of their résumés, their personalities, and their political issues. Thus it has always been, and thus it will always be, in a republic. "Vote for me because I have the experience to do it well," or "Vote for me because I'm so much like you, I'll represent your interests," or "Vote for me because we agree on these twenty or thirty specific issues." [snip] it's become blatant only for the past decade or so, and that's the growth of a regulatory state
‘Earth’s Holocaust,’ a Global Bonfire
to Reckon With
5 replies
Posted by DVC 5/28/2023 12:53:38 PM Post Reply
“Earth’s Holocaust” is a short story by Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804-1864) that delivers enough déjà vu to make one say loudly “what else is new”? This is not another “I told you so” tale but a deep look into the heart of human life. [snip] Russell Kirk’s The Conservative Mind contains a synopsis of “Earth’s Holocaust” that beats anything I may offer here, but I thought it would be a good idea to “dust off” this revealing story and summarize it
Target shows the blueprint to beat the left 22 replies
Posted by DVC 5/28/2023 11:59:28 AM Post Reply
Something is happening right now that is scaring the Obama out of the fascist far left. Their power has always been an illusion, perpetuated by pop culture and the national socialist media, but now that is being shown to be nothing more than smoke and mirrors. Normal people in the pro-freedom majority are figuring that out. And now that it's being shown to be a cultural chimera, the anti-liberty authoritarianism of the fascist far left is finished. That is what truly scares leftists about the Bud Light and Target situations. [snip] But this time it's different. The resistance is widespread, persistent, and intensifying.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Elton John Singles Out Anti-Grooming Laws
as Why He’s Done Performing in the US
36 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/25/2023 11:41:06 AM Post Reply
As his farewell tour wraps up, pop singer Elton John said he has no plans to perform again in the United States due to the country’s “growing swell of anger and homophobia.” That’s according to what the “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” musician said in an interview he gave Radio Times, where he noted what he described as a growing number of anti-grooming laws being passed in states, including Florida, Texas, Georgia, Tennessee, North Dakota, and South Dakota. He specifically singled out Florida’s laws, calling them “disgraceful.”
Watch: Defiant LGBTQ Marchers Chant: 'We're
Here, We're Queer, We're Coming for Your Children'
30 replies
Posted by Imright 6/25/2023 9:02:46 AM Post Reply
Despite the insincere blather about “diversity, equity, and inclusion” (DEI), the left wants nothing of the kind, and it never did. What leftists do want — including LGBTQ activists and Joe Biden’s Democrat Party — is to shove their radical ideology down the throats of the rest of us. The more we resist, the harder they push.If there was ever any doubt that they also want your children, that notion was blown to pieces in New York City on Friday as in-your-face LGBTQ activists marched and defiantly chanted: We’re here, we’re queer, we’re coming for your children
Miami Mayor Explains Why He Voted for
Andrew Gillum Over Ron DeSantis
26 replies
Posted by DW626 6/24/2023 3:30:07 PM Post Reply
Miami Mayor Francis Suarez (R) was asked by Fox News host Kayleigh McEnany on Thursday why he decided to vote for Democrat Andrew Gillum over Ron DeSantis during the gubernatorial race in 2018. Suarez, who has joined the 2024 presidential race, explained he only voted for Gillum, not endorse him. Suarez added he donated to money to DeSantis during the primary but he did not get a phone call back from the future governor. "Well, I voted for him. I didn’t support him. I didn’t endorse him. I actually supported and gave money to Ron DeSantis
Trump faces new trial date in Mar-a-Lago
classified documents case as Special Counsel
Jack Smith calls for four month delay
so former president's lawyers can get
'the requisite security clearances'
26 replies
Posted by Imright 6/24/2023 8:01:34 AM Post Reply
Prosecutors have asked for a December trial for Donald Trump over the Mar-a-Lago classified documents, saying the new date would give the former president's legal team time to obtain the necessary security clearance to view the documents. The judge overseeing the case, Aileen Cannon, on Tuesday provisionally set an August date for the trial. She said at the time that she was open to requests for it to change.On Friday, the office of Jack Smith, the special counsel leading the investigation, requested a December 11 start. They said it would allow Trump's legal team sufficient time to obtain the necessary security clearances to view the classified documents.
Former Divider in Chief Obama Tries to
Politicize Sub Tragedy, Calls out 'Obscene
Inequality' of News Coverage
23 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 6/24/2023 12:21:44 AM Post Reply
Barack Obama never came across an event that he couldn’t politicize; the recent implosion of the submersible Titan on a dive to explore the wreck of the Titanic—which left five people presumed dead—is no exception. As my colleague Mike Miller reported, the former president appeared on a CNN special titled “Obama & Amanpour” Thursday to blame “right-wing” media for making Americans “fearful of each other.” But he wasn’t done; he also decided to blame the media for excessive coverage of the sub accident while not devoting equal time to another tragedy, the story of a “migrant boat” that sank off the coast of Greece last week. An unknown
NHL Teams Will No Longer Wear LGBTQ Pride-Themed Jerseys 22 replies
Posted by Beardo 6/24/2023 4:02:19 PM Post Reply
National Hockey League (NHL) teams will no longer wear rainbow-colored LGBTQ-themed jerseys during pregame warmups for Pride nights. NHL Pride Nights became a hot topic of conversation earlier this year when Philadelphia Flyers defenseman Ivan Provorov refused to participate in his team’s Pride Night due to his orthodox Christian faith, sparking outrage from leftists who proceeded to accuse him of bigotry and homophobia. However, the Philadelphia Flyers kept him in the lineup, and the team even went on to win the game against the Anaheim Ducks.
The Biden family’s long history of skirting
the law, sweetheart deals
19 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/24/2023 6:00:37 PM Post Reply
Hunter Biden’s slap-on-the-wrist plea deal after failing to pay taxes on millions of dollars in income, and a felony gun charge he won’t be prosecuted for, follows a long history of Biden family members running afoul of the law — and skating.“The Biden family are beginning to make the Medicis look like small-time operators,” said George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley. “That fact that it took over five years to even secure a plea on a couple of small misdemeanors is a testament to a family that has leveraged Joe Biden public positions into a fortune of foreign influence peddling.”
Whistleblower: FBI Tipped Off ‘People
Very Close’ To Joe And Hunter Before
IRS Investigative Team’s ‘Day Of Action’
19 replies
Posted by earlybird 6/24/2023 5:48:00 PM Post Reply
The night before an Internal Revenue Service (IRS) criminal investigation team began looking into Hunter Biden’s tax crimes was set to conduct key interviews and approach Hunter for a consented search of his home, FBI headquarters allegedly tipped off “people very close to President Biden and Hunter Biden,” thwarting the investigation, according to a whistleblower testimony to the House Ways and Means Committee released Thursday. Starting in January 2020, IRS criminal supervisory special agent and whistleblower Gary Shapley and his team of agents began investigating Hunter Biden for tax evasion after incriminating material was found on Hunter’s infamous laptop. “I am alleging, with evidence, that DOJ provided preferential treatment, slow-walked the
Russia mutiny: Rebel Wagner leader 'to
move to Belarus' after halting mercenary
convoy to avoid 'bloodshed'
19 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 6/24/2023 4:24:31 PM Post Reply
Russian mercenary group leader Yevgeny Prigozhin will move to Belarus and have criminal charges against him dropped, the Kremlin has said, after he pulled his fighters back from advancing on Moscow. Prigozhin had earlier told his troops heading towards the Russian capital to turn back, saying he wants to avoid shedding Russian blood. In an audio message, Prigozhin said his fighters - part of the private mercenary Wagner Group - would return to their bases. He said that while his men were just 120 miles from Moscow, he decided to turn them back to avoid "shedding Russian blood".
Donald Trump’s 2020 election loss was
an inside job
18 replies
Posted by Moritz55 6/25/2023 12:31:29 PM Post Reply
Score half a point for Donald Trump. It turns out he was on to something with his claim the 2020 election was rigged, though not in the way he thinks. The dirty deed didn’t happen in offices in Arizona or Georgia, where Republicans supposedly were banished while Democrats counted duffel bags full of late-arriving votes. Nor did Trump lose because computers were wired to rob him of victory. Instead, the cheating that likely denied Trump a second term was very close to home. In fact, it was an inside job.
When a German Lutheran Pastor Preaches
that ‘God Is Queer’
18 replies
Posted by FlyRight 6/25/2023 7:05:46 AM Post Reply
“Now is the time to say . . . ‘God is queer.’” Who spoke these blasphemous words, and what was the context of the statement? The words were spoken by Quinton Caesar, a Lutheran pastor in Germany, at the conclusion of the annual gathering of the nation’s Protestant (meaning Lutheran) pastors. The conference theme was “Now it the time,” and this was the immediate context of Casear’s words (who himself is black, originally from South Africa): “Now is the time to say: ‘Black lives always matter.’ Now is the time to say: ‘God is queer.’Now is the time to say: ‘We leave no one to die.’
Garland: Questioning the Integrity of
the Justice Department Is an Attack on
— You Guessed It
17 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 6/24/2023 10:25:54 PM Post Reply
With the sweetheart deal that Hunter Biden just got from federal prosecutors, Attorney General Merrick Garland has once again confirmed that he has taken the Justice Department, which was once the envy of the world for its indefatigable commitment to equal justice for all, and turned it into a squad of legal hit men for foes of the Biden regime and a legal laundromat for the regime’s members and cronies, most notably for the alleged president’s crackhead influence-peddling son. Garland himself, however, bristles if you believe your lying eyes on this matter. On Friday he complained that charges that his Justice Department was doling out frame jobs for dissidents
Post New Article