Transgender archery champion banned from
Texas women's tournaments
ADN America,
by
Joshua Shin
Original Article
Posted By: MDConservative,
4/16/2022 4:49:36 PM
A transgender archer who won a state championship has been barred from women’s competitions after complaints.
KellyJeanne Pyne, who identifies as a female, was one of three competitors in the senior women’s freestyle event at the Texas Field Archery Association’s Indoor State Tournament on Feb. 26 near Fort Worth. She finished only one point ahead of the runner-up. “It felt good,” Pyne told KXAN. “It felt like I had achieved something, and then that was rapidly taken away.”
However, three female archers submitted official protests to the results, saying that Pyne, who is transgender, should not be competing in women’s events.
Reply 1 - Posted by:
Quigley 4/16/2022 5:04:09 PM (No. 1130423)
Perhaps there is no need for segregated archery competition. I would think arm and chest strength would be a factor, but I don’t know.
5 people like this.
Reply 2 - Posted by:
DVC 4/16/2022 5:04:54 PM (No. 1130426)
Good. No men in women's sports.
As to the OP question - archery takes substantial physical strength to pull back the bow and hold it while aiming. More strength, less straining while aiming.
In firearms, the sexes are much more closely matched, but still, the weight of the gun and the strength need to hold this heavy thing very precisely still, then recover from recoil very quickly back to the target is at least a small difference.
The very best women shooters are VERY good. I have taught many women shooters and they can be skilled, no doubt. But - AFAIK, no major firearms shooting sport which has both men and women competing (always in their own classes) has had a woman win the top spot. IIRC, the highest woman in one handgun sport is third place, VERY impressive. Look up Randi Rogers back in 2013. Recently, a woman finished in 13th overall at the Bianchi Cup, a very challenging invitational handgun match that I have competed in many years ago.
15 people like this.
Reply 3 - Posted by:
earlybird 4/16/2022 5:09:30 PM (No. 1130432)
Re #1, the only photo I could find of his body showed a husky barrel-chested guy (age 53) with big muscular arms. Except for long grey hair, not at all feminine-looking…
He is now playing the disability card without saying what it is. This isn’t the paralympics...
9 people like this.
Reply 4 - Posted by:
Hazymac 4/16/2022 5:14:50 PM (No. 1130435)
If an archer is shooting a traditional longbow (or a recurve), upper body strength and stamina in a major competition would affect the results. So, yes, psychologically ill men playing around at being female should be banned not only from women's archery competitions, but from all women's sports. There should be zero tolerance. It's cheating.
18 people like this.
Reply 5 - Posted by:
earlybird 4/16/2022 5:41:09 PM (No. 1130454)
This may be him. Other photo I saw was younger person. Look at that arm and left wrist…
He plans to enter male competitions as well.
https://i0.wp.com/www.bigcountryhomepage.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/56/2022/04/KellyJeanne-Pyne.jpg?w=2000&ssl=1
2 people like this.
Reply 6 - Posted by:
red1066 4/16/2022 5:45:26 PM (No. 1130461)
There are a few sports where men and women could compete on an equal level. Archery could be one, playing pool, the shooting sports, maybe even bowling.
1 person likes this.
Reply 7 - Posted by:
Rich323 4/16/2022 5:51:33 PM (No. 1130467)
The International Archery Federation (FITA) outlines the following rules for Olympic Recurve Bow weight ranges:
1. For women, a bow weighing at least 15 kg and not more than 19 kilograms before any permitted attachments are made.
2. For men, a bow weighing at least 18 kg and not more than 22 kilograms before any permitted attachments are made.
Men usually have to use a heavier bow than women, so their would an advantage for a male using a woman’s bow.
8 people like this.
Reply 8 - Posted by:
Ashley Brenton 4/16/2022 5:59:23 PM (No. 1130470)
Reminds me of a time when I was stationed at Fort Riley. Every year there was a post-wide "Commander's Cup" event where all the battalions would compete in sporting events for a big trophy. Our battalion commander literally turned into Patton for that week.
One of the events was "women's archery", which we took first place in.
Another commander confronted ours, asking, "How in the Hell can you win Woman's Archery? You are Field Artillery." FA units were all male, supposedly.
To which our commander smiled and replied, "I have one female. Our head medic."
And she was like this awesome 4-H deer-stalking archery madwoman. We won the Cup that year. I was in charge of bowling.
7 people like this.
Reply 9 - Posted by:
udanja99 4/16/2022 6:18:55 PM (No. 1130489)
Good!
“She” did manage to achieve something but it’s not what “she” thinks it is. “Her” achievement was to cheat “her” way to a “win”. Nobody likes a cheater.
9 people like this.
Reply 10 - Posted by:
TXknitter 4/16/2022 7:18:03 PM (No. 1130527)
I have seen a few other articles where women’s sport competitions did the exact same thing! I say hooray. Now every women’s competition can be well-prepared beforehand and be absolutely ready!!!
6 people like this.
Reply 11 - Posted by:
Texpub 4/16/2022 8:18:15 PM (No. 1130562)
There should be 2 categories for any competition: XX and XY. It doesn't matter how you identify, what you wear, or anything else. You can dress however you want. You will be placed in the category that matches your genes. You will be XX or XY. Nor more problems. Wear a dress....who cares. Wear pants....who cares.
XX or XY. Had surgery to remove your wedding tackle....doesn't matter....XX or XY.
8 people like this.
Reply 12 - Posted by:
john56 4/16/2022 10:15:59 PM (No. 1130621)
I'd sure like to hear of a former-female-now-transgender-male competiting in men's sports.
5 people like this.
Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "MDConservative"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Comments:
I'm not an archer. Perhaps someone could explain why there is an inherent difference in skills between male and female archers making this "unfair." Pyne says there is none. (S)he is a veteran, and also a rifle competitor.