Post New Article

John Roberts Is Responsible for the High
Court's Self-Delegitimization

Original Article

Posted By: Moritz55, 3/21/2025 12:58:37 PM

At his 2005 Senate confirmation hearing to be chief justice of the United States Supreme Court, John Roberts famously invoked America's national pastime in describing his view of the judicial role in our constitutional order: "Judges are like umpires. Umpires don't make the rules, they apply them. The role of an umpire and a judge is critical. They make sure everybody plays by the rules, but it is a limited role. Nobody ever went to a ball game to see the umpire." If only! Unfortunately, Roberts' actual career on the high court has been one extensive repudiation of his lofty "umpire" proclamation. In exalting above all other concerns

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: mc squared 3/21/2025 1:52:25 PM (No. 1918792)
My mind goes to some pretty dark places here. What do the Dems have on Roberts?
15 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: jeffkinnh 3/21/2025 2:53:05 PM (No. 1918824)
The legitimacy of the court is based on following law, as written and determining if new law fits within the framework of the Constitution. It is NOT the courts responsibility to solve problems or placate political groups. It is especially not the job of the court to make up law (which is assigned to the Congress) to resolve problems. So turning a penalty into a tax, especially when the creators of the law decried that description, is wholly illegitimate. Roberts fails this test every time he is tried. Federal judges are not meant to be "nice guys or bad guys". They are to be impartial arbiters of proper legal structure, and when needed to clarify grey areas of the law, where the written language implies something but is not clear enough. In that case, the judges decide that "Yes, the supporting language in the law does imply that." or "It does NOT!". A sensible person should be able to read a court decision and follow the logic to the court's decision. If you cannot, the court is probably making it up as they go along. That's how Leftist judges operate. They don't care about the law. They care only about the outcome that they want. On a lot of big decisions, Roberts has leaned Left and faked it up. The results of not trusting the court system is all on people like him.
9 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: Jethro bo 3/21/2025 3:33:30 PM (No. 1918850)
If Trump gets to appoint another Jester to the Supreme Joke, he should nominate the NEW Chief Justice of the Supreme Joke and fire Roberts from the position. Roberts is clearly over his head and lacks the character to perform the job.
8 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: Toodles3956 3/21/2025 4:24:37 PM (No. 1918894)
Our new DOJ needs to look into illegal adoptions.
7 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: montwoodcliff 3/21/2025 6:20:14 PM (No. 1918945)
I’ll keep on saying, this guy has to be Breyered so Trump can appoint a real conservative to the court as Chief Justice.
2 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: Red Ghost 3/21/2025 7:20:05 PM (No. 1918972)
Yeah, there are a couple of issues with Roberts. The first being his shocking flip flop on Obamacare. Rumors were rife then that Obama and his democrat thugs had something on Roberts. There have been other Roberts inexplicable flip flops. Roberts never, EVER, appropriately or seriously investigated the leak of the Dobbs decision. Years later we still have no answers. Why would that be? Inquiring minds want to know, Johnny. The Dobbs criminal activity has been as closely guarded as the JFK files. And then we have the beautiful bromance between Boasberg and Roberts. Apparently, these dudes have a relationship or at least are just friends. So, there are lots of questions about the Chief Justice. Some enterprising "journalist" should do a deep dive on this guy. Just sayin'.
2 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: NYbob 3/22/2025 1:28:06 AM (No. 1919118)
It is the FBIs job to find internal threats to this country. They do it all the time with a wide range of people with power in all sort of positions. Supreme Court judges are NO different. In fact, they should be extra pure compared to the average citizen. So, get to work new FBI, or support the corrupt status quo like every other version of this unconstitutional organization.
0 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Moritz55"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Moritz55"
Trump is working overtime to restore the
rule of law
2 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/21/2025 9:09:41 PM Post Reply
In the matter of Donald Trump v. Leviathan, let me begin by stipulating that Sir Thomas More was right in A Man for All Seasons when he remonstrated with his future son-in-law William Roper. Roper was urging More to arrest the scheming Richard Rich, whose machinations would eventually lead to More’s execution. But, More points out, Rich had broken no law. William Roper: So, now you give the Devil the benefit of law! Sir Thomas More: Yes! What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil? William Roper: Yes, I’d cut down every law in England to do that!
AOC, Walz, Wu — these nuts are the future
of the Democrats?!
4 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/21/2025 1:03:15 PM Post Reply
This was the week I became convinced that Don Lemon is an undercover MAGA operative. The former CNN presenter was on Bill Maher’s podcast the other day and was asked about the dire outlook for the Democratic Party. Which way should it go? “People love AOC,” Lemon ventured. “People love Jasmine Crockett. People love Eric Swalwell and the like. I think the Democratic Party should put people out there who the people want — who they’re asking for.” Maher begged to differ. People do not want these people, he pointed out. But Lemon continued to insist otherwise.
John Roberts Is Responsible for the High
Court's Self-Delegitimization
7 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/21/2025 12:58:37 PM Post Reply
At his 2005 Senate confirmation hearing to be chief justice of the United States Supreme Court, John Roberts famously invoked America's national pastime in describing his view of the judicial role in our constitutional order: "Judges are like umpires. Umpires don't make the rules, they apply them. The role of an umpire and a judge is critical. They make sure everybody plays by the rules, but it is a limited role. Nobody ever went to a ball game to see the umpire." If only! Unfortunately, Roberts' actual career on the high court has been one extensive repudiation of his lofty "umpire" proclamation. In exalting above all other concerns
Trump is fighting a cartel of vile, corrupt
and far-left judges trying to kill his
campaign promises
1 reply
Posted by Moritz55 3/21/2025 12:54:26 PM Post Reply
If you ever doubted that Washington’s corrupt cartel of Democratic law firms, judges, NGOs, and deep-state bureaucrats is a machine designed to thwart the Trump administration, just watch as judge after judge blocks the president’s ability to keep his campaign promises. It may not be brown paper bags changing hands, but this lawfare that defies the people’s will is every bit as corrupt. It will be up to the Supreme Court to define the limits of presidential authority, but Chief Justice John Roberts’ preemptive scolding of Trump for musing about judicial impeachment doesn’t bode well for the president.
America’s colleges are hoarding billions
— and yet still cry poor as Trump targets
federal funding
6 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/20/2025 10:48:39 PM Post Reply
Twenty years ago, maybe even ten, I’d have found stories about the administration cutting grants to universities and detonating thousands of campus-related jobs horrifying. But the education sob stories now flying off the presses have a gigantic lie of omission. Take Johns Hopkins. NBC News was one of many to highlight the “grave consequences” the new administration’s policies have had on the famed institution, noting “the changes will also have an economic impact in Baltimore because the university is the largest private employer in Maryland.” NBC pointed out that “about half of Johns Hopkins’ funding last year came from federal research dollars, according to a letter
Molotov Cocktail Hour Is Over for Tesla
Bombers After DOJ Indictments
13 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/20/2025 10:42:51 PM Post Reply
All normal human beings can agree that if a crackpot doesn't like the car you drive, it's not okay for him to firebomb, shoot, key, or otherwise vandalize that vehicle. This should hold true whether you're one of the Jimmys on late-night TV, Rick Wilson, or Antifa. Sadly for three indicted men who are accused of going after Tesla cars for political reasons, they are learning this the hard way. On Thursday, Attorney General Pam Bondi announced the "severe charges" against the accused "Tesla arsonists." Bondi said, "The days of committing crimes without consequence have ended.”
Zelensky’s Popularity Plunges 4 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/20/2025 10:39:34 PM Post Reply
Politics is a fickle business, and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has lost the favor of sensible Americans, who demand that our focus and resources be devoted to the US homeland, not far away, intractable wars. This Zelensky fall from grace stands in stark contrast to the constant adoration he enjoys from the legacy media platforms of Washington and New York. After all, even before the war in Ukraine, he was fawned over by the US corporate media for his indirect role in spurring the first sham impeachment of President Trump.
Civics Should Be the Cause of Our Generation 4 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/20/2025 6:41:09 PM Post Reply
Now more than ever, it seems, politics demands our attention. It is difficult to predict what developments await us in the coming week, much less the coming years of the Trump presidency. What will the geopolitical order look like by 2028? What will the federal government look like? What will the Democratic or Republican Parties look like? But, intriguing as these questions may be, it is another set of “pre-political” questions that matter most. By pre-political I mean the ethical and civic principles that shape our engagement in matters of politics and policy. What are the constitutional values we must uphold as a free society? What is the purpose of government,
Democrats’ silence is damning as leftist
violence explodes
5 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/20/2025 2:01:47 PM Post Reply
Another Donald Trump presidential term, another spate of violence going largely ignored — or even smirked at — by Democrats and their media friends. Tesla dealerships are being firebombed and shot at, while Tesla vehicles are vandalized and their owners assaulted. Trump-supporting influencers are getting “swatted,” set up for dangerous police encounters by opponents who phone in hoax distress calls. Relatives of Trump-aligned public figures — including the sister of US Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett and Elon Musk’s brother — are receiving bomb threats. This cannot go on.
A Secure Border and Aggressive Tariffs
Go Together
0 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/19/2025 3:21:23 PM Post Reply
My first job in high school was washing dishes at a local restaurant. It wasn’t glamorous, but it paid well. Some of my other friends spent that summer picking tobacco in the Connecticut River Valley. Both jobs were hard work, but at $8 an hour – real money for a teenager in 1985 – we were happy to do either. Fast-forward to today, and you’ll find American teenagers and adults working at places like In-N-Out Burger, flipping burgers for $25 an hour. Why? Because when wages make sense, Americans show up for the job. Yet coastal elites, from their high-rise offices and gated communities, scoff, “If we don’t allow illegal immigrants
FBI’s Kash Patel must make good on promise
to reform the bureau — or it will be
just another hollow sound bite
11 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/18/2025 4:16:02 PM Post Reply
New FBI Director Kash Patel promised “a complete and total annihilation of the weaponization of justice and the politicization of intelligence” when he spoke at a law-and-order event at the Department of Justice on Friday. “We have a new FBI, and I’m humbled to be its leader,” he said. A lot rests on Patel being able to make good on his promise to reform the bureau, and as a former public defender, national security prosecutor and counterterrorism official in the first Trump administration, there is nobody more qualified and clear-eyed about the challenge.
Democrats amp up infighting and 'unhinged
petulance' as approval rating plummets
3 replies
Posted by Moritz55 3/18/2025 4:13:11 PM Post Reply
Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman recently observed the following about the state of his Democratic Party: “A sad cavalcade of self owns and unhinged petulance. It only makes Trump look more presidential and restrained. We’re becoming the metaphorical car alarms that nobody pays attention to − and it may not be the winning message.” Ouch. Fetterman posted that message on social media after Democrats’ embarrassing show of “resistance” during President Donald Trump’s joint address to Congress this month.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Kamala Harris Picked as Democrats’ Runaway
2028 Favorite in New Poll
39 replies
Posted by NorthernDog 3/21/2025 7:52:13 PM Post Reply
Democrats overwhelmingly selected former Vice President Kamala Harris as their preferred candidate in a Morning Consult poll released on Friday. Four months after losing the 2024 election to President Donald Trump, Harris led the competition in the survey in a mock 2028 Democratic primary and the results were not close. Harris, who has not announced any intention to seek another presidential nomination, led a pack of 19 candidates with the support of 36%. Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg came in second with 10% support. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), Democratic California Governor Gavin Newsom, and Democratic Minnesota Governor Tim Walz all
Michelle’s new look? Straight out of
a Nairobi used car lot—and there’s
a reason for it…
39 replies
Posted by earlybird 3/21/2025 6:29:27 PM Post Reply
Have you seen Michelle Obama’s new look? Well, if you haven’t, take a seat…because it’s a doozy. She is basically unrecognizable these days. Michelle has ditched the sleek, polished look of her White House years and embraced something… uh, very different. This was Michelle thenāasnip) Her latest transformation includes a massive, boxy suit coat and a wrinkled men’s dress shirt—both oversized to the point of absolute absurdity. She’s paired the rumpled manly look with three towering braided buns stacked on her head like a wacky faux hawk crown. (snip) more like a Nairobi used car salesman
Hostin: ‘We’re at an Existential Crisis,’
Dems Need to Stop Playing by the Rules
30 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 3/21/2025 10:56:11 PM Post Reply
Sunny Hostin told her co-hosts Friday on ABC’s “The View” that President Donald Trump’s second term was an “existential crisis.” According to Hostin, Democrats need to stop playing by the rules. When asked about politicians skipping town halls, Hostin said, “It’s very un-American, and it’s cowardly. If you are just, you know, stepping in line the way Republicans generally do behind a candidate that is harming the economy, I mean, you need to listen to the people that put you in office. Instead of being so concerned about maintaining power, why not be more concerned with helping people? That’s the thing that I’m so much more concerned about.”
Chuck Schumer Says the Quiet Part Out
Loud: ‘We Did Put 235 Progressive Judges
– on the Bench and They Are Ruling Against
Trump Time After Time After Time’
26 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 3/21/2025 1:49:58 PM Post Reply
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer admitted on PBS this week that Democrats intentionally stacked the courts with 235 “progressive judges” in order to stop President Donald Trump “time after time after time.” Since President Trump triumphantly returned to the White House on January 20, 2025, his administration has faced an all-out legal assault — not from Congress or the will of the American people — but from a weaponized judicial branch hijacked by radical leftists. In just under two months, President Trump has been hit with 132 legal challenges, with only two resolved. And now, Chuck Schumer has admitted it all on national television.
Florida Police: Teen Students Arrested
for Beating Teacher in ‘Synchronized
Physical Attack’
24 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 3/21/2025 3:29:59 PM Post Reply
Two students in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, were arrested this week for allegedly beating a high school teacher in what police described as a “synchronized physical attack.” The incident allegedly occurred at Dillard High School last Thursday when 19-year-olds Jayvis McClover and Roddrick McQueen approached a teacher and began “verbally threatening to attack him,” according to the Fort Lauderdale Police Department. “The two, who are both enrolled at Dillard High School, then ‘intentionally launched a synchronized physical attack’ on the teacher,” per CBS News. “McClover and McQueen ‘repeatedly punched the teacher in the face and head with closed fists,’ causing the educator to fall to the ground, police said.”
Joy Reid Says Canada Can Beat the U.S.
In a War: ‘Like Their Chances!’
23 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 3/21/2025 12:41:55 PM Post Reply
Joy Reid argued on Thursday that Canada will never become an American state as President Donald Trump wants because they could beat their southern neighbors in a war. Reid joined Don Lemon on The Don Lemon Show this week and balked at Trump’s continued push for America to absorb Canada. Canadian officials have pushed back on this being an option, but Trump has remained steadfast in his desire. According to Reid, Canada would only become a new American state if the two countries went to war. She made clear her money is on Canada in that showdown. “Grampy Trump, let’s talk. Let’s talk. First of all, you can’t
Trump Revokes Security Clearance of Hillary
Clinton, Kamala Harris, and the Radical
Leftist Cabal
18 replies
Posted by Imright 3/22/2025 7:57:31 AM Post Reply
President Donald Trump dropped a political bombshell on Friday, signing an executive order that yanks security clearances from some of the most notorious figures of the radical left. The list reads like a who’s who of Trump-hating elitists and Deep State operatives like Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris. Trump once more listed Antony Blinken, Jacob Sullivan, Letitia James, Alvin Bragg, and even Joe Biden, along with his entire corrupt family. Trump’s order declares that these individuals no longer have any business sniffing around classified information.
Illinois Bill Would Let Failing School
System Send Homeschooling Parents To Jail
18 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 3/21/2025 10:46:44 PM Post Reply
Homeschool parents would face fines, misdemeanor charges and even jail time if they do not report themselves to local public school officials, under a new proposal from Illinois Democrats.  Parents also would be required to provide public school officials with a “portfolio” of their children’s work at any time, at any interval and frequency, until that portfolio meets the public school’s satisfaction. The bill, dubbed the“HomeschoolAct,” requires  parents to report themselves in writing to local school officials starting in 2026. Parents who do not will be considered truant.
MSNBC Guest Really Concerned That Student
Loans Can’t Be Forgiven If Education
Department Closes
17 replies
Posted by snakeoil 3/22/2025 10:15:07 AM Post Reply
A panelist on MSNBC fretted Friday that the Trump administration’s decision to begin abolishing the Department of Education (ED) would make it impossible to forgive student loans. President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing Secretary of Education Linda McMahon to start shutting down the agency she heads Thursday, fulfilling a campaign promise, while announcing Friday that student loans would be handled by the Small Business Administration (SBA). MSNBC analyst Susan del Percio told MSNBC host Alex Witt that Trump was trying to “privatize” student loans.
Trump Effect: German Auto Giant Audi Looks
to Move Production to U.S. to Avoid Tariffs
17 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 3/21/2025 3:19:43 PM Post Reply
German luxury auto manufacturer Audi said it is considering moving car production to the United States to avoid tariffs from the Trump administration. Volkswagen’s subsidiary Audi brand said this week that it is examining various long-term strategies, including potentially shifting production to America, to deal with President Donald Trump’s restrictions on foreign imports. Audi CEO Gernot Döllner said that the company is “currently assessing various scenarios for additional localization in North America – among other things, to be closer to the needs of local customers and to make ourselves more resilient to global economic uncertainties.” Although no firm decision was made this week,
DOGE USAID budget cuts hit UN in 'worst
liquidity crisis since its establishment'
16 replies
Posted by Harlowe 3/22/2025 2:58:54 PM Post Reply
FIRST ON FOX: President Donald Trump's administration’s use of Elon Musk's DOGE to cut USAID spending is having a deep impact on the United Nations Department of Safety and Security (UNDSS), according to internal U.N. emails shared with Fox News Digital. ...president of the U.N. Field Staff Union, Milan Victor Dawoh wrote that the USAID funding cut resulted in "approximately $30 million" having been "removed from the extra-budgetary (XB) resources, resulting in a significant reduction in staffing." [Snip] A U.N. source speaking on condition of anonymity said that in the midst of financial uncertainty, U.N. staff " are very fearful of their immediate future."
Trump suggests US could be ‘associate
member’ of British Commonwealth: ‘I
love King Charles’
16 replies
Posted by Imright 3/21/2025 1:51:05 PM Post Reply
WASHINGTON — President Trump reacted warmly Friday to a report that the US could be offered “associate membership” in the British Commonwealth. “I Love King Charles. Sounds good to me!” the president wrote on Truth Social, linking to a report by the Sun that a proposal could be made by the monarch when Trump makes a state visit to the UK later this year. The Commonwealth of Nations, established in 1926, has 56 member states, the vast majority of which are former colonies of the British Empire. (Photo) Among its members are Australia, Canada, India, Kenya, Malaysia, New Zealand, Pakistan and South Africa.
Post New Article