Post New Article

No, America Wasn’t ‘Founded’ By Immigrants

Original Article

Posted By: Harlowe, 1/29/2025 12:16:27 AM

Sunday, CBS News’ Margaret Brennan tried to get one over on Vice President J.D. Vance, badgering him about immigration and claiming “this is a country founded by immigrants.” But this narrative isn’t just inaccurate, it’s a calculated lie... Vance held his own, refuting the baseless claim by noting the country was founded “by some immigrants and some settlers”... [Snip] Britain began establishing the 13 original colonies in the early 1600’s. Over the next century or so, hundreds of thousands of Brits moved to the British colonies that were established by settlers--not immigrants. There was no “nation” being immigrated to by the first settlers.

Comments:

Precisely, there was no pre-existing country when the Brits came here—it was just land. “They were entrepreneurs building this nation from scratch, not immigrants joining a pre-existing nation.” The Native Americans were clans—peoples, not nations and “believed to have come from Asia before crossing the Bering land bridge and making their way to the present-day United States.” Anglo Protestants founded this country. “These settlers forged a new nation, instituted customs, traditions, and a national identity.”

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: DVC 1/29/2025 12:47:35 AM (No. 1884303)
Actually, most of our Founding Fathers were born here. IIRC, Hamilton was an exception.
38 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: sunset 1/29/2025 1:00:37 AM (No. 1884306)
They were called settlers
50 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: anniebc 1/29/2025 4:31:06 AM (No. 1884326)
Even if it were founded by immigrants; they couldn't have been illegal, right? Leftists are more stupid than the definition of stupid. My sister calls it super stupid.
47 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: mifla 1/29/2025 5:30:49 AM (No. 1884341)
Even if true, things change after a few hundred years. It is not an immortal concept.
19 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: chumley 1/29/2025 6:27:24 AM (No. 1884389)
It starts out as settlers or immigrants. If the numbers are small enough and the newcomers disperse into the culture, they assimilate and all is good. If they stay in their own cultural enclaves, they never assimilate and eventually become conquerors. Short of military action, thats how you take over a country.
22 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: JrSample 1/29/2025 7:37:12 AM (No. 1884467)
Australia was founded by convicts sent from England. They currently have a points-based immigration system that is strictly enforced. Funny how we don't hear our pointy-headed elites badgering the Canadian or Australian governments about the enforcement of their immigration statutes.
23 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: felixcat 1/29/2025 7:39:02 AM (No. 1884470)
When America was receiving a lot of European immigrants, it was with the understanding that we needed their strong backs, work ethic and that they would become Americans. We welcome you but no freebies, no accommodation of your languages, etc. Become American and contribute to its success and what you speak at home is your business.
31 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: RussZilla 1/29/2025 7:50:19 AM (No. 1884483)
Only one other country allows birth citizenship, and that is Canada. Europe doesn’t allow it in any of their countries.
11 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: bpl40 1/29/2025 8:54:56 AM (No. 1884522)
Willingness to assimilate is a mandatory requirement for any immigrant coming to our shores. It is part of our culture and heritage. It must be included and practiced as part of our laws.
20 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: Ida Lou Pino 1/29/2025 9:58:09 AM (No. 1884596)
I've never understood why immigrants from Siberia had more claim to American land than immigrants from elsewhere. No more special concessions for Siberian-Americans. We're all on an equal footing.
13 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Encore 1/29/2025 10:18:59 AM (No. 1884616)
The left would have us resort back to a land of ‘clans’. No national unity or identity. What a great weakness that would result in. A lawless land of warlords, a ‘Mad Max’ atmosphere. The left can’t see past their money grubbing hands.
8 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: cor-vet 1/29/2025 10:45:19 AM (No. 1884644)
Brennan proves once again, that a degree in journalism is as worthless as a degree in gender studies or community organizing!
7 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: Zigrid 1/29/2025 10:45:57 AM (No. 1884646)
JDVance has to be on his toes every news conference with the drive by media...they know he will run in 2028 and they are starting to work on him now....the Sunday shows are a great classroom for him...and let's remember...he was a scholar.....and the DEI dingbats that are put up against his expertise... leave a lot to be desired when it comes to our National history....so bring it on ABC and NBC and CNN....JD is ready for ya!!
5 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: rikkitikki 1/29/2025 10:49:04 AM (No. 1884651)
To #10: To your point, the Siberian-Americans are simply immigrants/settlers who got here sooner than the European competition. The Siberian-Americans' claims to have 'owned' N. America has pros and cons: In favor, their own, verbally-transmitted myths of creation and ancestry claim they've always been here. They really believe them...but no one else does. Against: no archeological evidence of human occupation pre-dates the last Ice Age....no one was here. In fact, the recent extinction of most large mammals in N.America (mammoths, saber-tooths, sloths, etc) corroborates the timing of their arrival.
4 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: Geoman 1/29/2025 11:38:04 AM (No. 1884691)
Re: #10: Many of my ancestors, who had settled in the Virginia/N. Carolina mountains before the U.S. was established are alleged by certain academics and politicians with an agenda, to have walked to North America from or through Siberia via the Siberian Land Bridge, Bering, although the evidence for this migration is not conclusive or even convincing when the fossil records of early hominids are examined. DNA research has proven equally inconclusive. As far as "special concessions," the only beneficiaries of such, which I am aware, are of white people claiming to be of indigenous stock. It was settlers and immigrants who, when critical mass was achieved, used the laws to prevent Native Americans, specifically the Cherokee, many of whom had adopted Christianity and a written alphabet, lived in houses, and were becoming capitalist traders, from actually owning the land on which they had lived and had created their own communities and settlements. Nomads, they were not. Newcomers could push those already established off of the land by force of law, so many kept moving West, into American lands claimed by the French and Spanish but later sold to or taken by U.S. citizens. That is rather like the Tren de Aragua gang removing you from your house by gunpoint or democrat political decree, because they do not honor your claim to property which you may have legally acquired, deeds and titles notwithstanding. My extended family was only able to "own" property through inter-marriage and as a reward for service in the U.S. military from revolutionary times through WWII.
5 people like this.

Reply 16 - Posted by: PrayerWarrior 1/29/2025 12:52:51 PM (No. 1884744)
Margaret Brennan and CBS don't care whether it was immigrants or settlers who came here, they just wanted to embarrass and win an argument with JD Vance. Both CBS an Margaret Brennan are enemies of all that is good and decent.
9 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Harlowe"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Harlowe"
Sherrod Brown to run for U.S. Senate against
Jon Husted in 2026, reports say
8 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/12/2025 3:36:36 PM
Democrat Sherrod Brown is mounting a return to the U.S. Senate after he was ousted by Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno last year. ... Brown’s decision follows his loss ...which was one of the most expensive races in the nation in 2024. [Snip] Brown was first elected to the U.S. Senate in 2006 and survived two reelection campaigns before falling to Moreno. [Snip] He announced in March the creation of the Dignity of Work Institute, his first major project since leaving Capitol Hill. ...he said both Republicans and Democrats have ignored workers for years and failed to address issues like low wages, overtime and home ownership.
The next big tax threat is coming from
your state capital
6 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/12/2025 11:50:51 AM
If you are one of the millions of people celebrating the trimming of federal fat, you’ll want to know that a new taxpayer threat of stunning proportions is rising, fast. [Snip] A $1.3 trillion pension crisis is barreling toward American taxpayers,.. [Snip] According to a new report by the nonpartisan Equable Institute, the State Teachers Retirement System of Ohio (STRS) is between $20 and $30 billion in debt and will be unable to fully pay back the teachers who funded it... [Snip] How could this happen? How could a $90+ billion fund be so poorly managed as to be at a loss? ...bureaucratic hubris and a sense of entitlement.
Trump considers reclassifying marijuana
as less dangerous drug: report
17 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/10/2025 12:26:11 PM
President Donald Trump is weighing whether to reclassify marijuana as a less dangerous drug, according to a report. [Snip] This comes after cannabis companies have committed millions of dollars to the president's political groups, according to the report. [Snip] The potential move to remove marijuana from the list of Schedule I controlled substances and make it a Schedule III drug would make it significantly easier to buy and sell cannabis and make the industry more profitable.
Zelenskyy Rejects President Trump Meeting
With Russian President Putin to Formulate
Ceasefire Terms
33 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/9/2025 4:33:04 PM
Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is once again rejecting any consideration for President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin to discuss terms for a ceasefire without his involvement. [Snip] Zelenskyy reacted, carrying the message from the global intelligence community who support the ongoing conflict,... Zelenskyy has banned opposition parties in Ukraine, taken control of media, targeted religious groups who he claims are subversive to his interests and cancelled elections in order to remain in power. Now Zelenskyy hides behind the claim of a constitution his regime modified in order to ensure he alone controls the pathways to peace.
Make Vaccine Injury Compensation Fair Again 8 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/8/2025 11:06:05 AM
We’ve known for years that the Covid-19 vaccines left many Americans seriously injured. Yet despite this common knowledge, the federal government’s surveillance to ensure vaccine safety has been substandard, to put it charitably. Worse, its performance in compensating those injured by the vaccine has been pathetic. Now, Congress is finally paying attention to America’s vaccine woes. [Snip] The sheer number of reported adverse events from the Covid-19 vaccine (over 1.8 million) dwarfs all previously reported vaccine injuries. But because it is a “passive” reporting system, largely based on patient self-reporting, VAERS is unable to show a causal relationship between a specific vaccine injection and a particular adverse reaction.
White House launches federal security
blitz as president vows to end DC 'crime plague'
11 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/7/2025 9:13:08 PM
In an effort to crack down on crime in the nation’s capital, President Donald Trump is ramping up federal enforcement in Washington, D.C., and deploying additional federal law enforcement agents this week. [Snip] D.C. residents can expect an increase in federal enforcement starting as early as Friday,... [Snip] Trump on Monday threatened to federalize Washington, D.C., calling for local minors and gang members over the age of 14 to be prosecuted as adults... [Snip] Federal officials will monitor D.C.’s sanctuary city status to ensure compliance with federal immigration law and support the full accreditation of the district’s forensic crime laboratory to aid local investigations.
Entitled Virginia Superintendent Wants
Security Guard To Protect Her From Criticism
16 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/7/2025 1:26:44 PM
T.S. Eliot claimed that “April is the cruelest month,” but in this homeschooling dad’s opinion, that dubious honor belongs to August. [Snip] Take Dr. Michelle Reid, the superintendent of Fairfax County Public Schools (FCPS). Not only does her new contract give her a salary higher than that of the president of the United States,,,, [Snip] It would be comforting to see Reid as an outlier, but her approach is standard operating procedure for the educational establishment. Concerned citizens need only look at the National Educational Association (NEA) to understand this.
Ohio senator introduces 'Holly's Act'
for woman brutally beaten in viral Cincinnati attack
11 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/6/2025 9:47:45 PM
Sen. Bernie Moreno, R-Ohio, is introducing "Holly’s Act" after a woman was violently attacked by a mob in Cincinnati late last month--a move aimed at ending what he calls the justice system’s revolving door for repeat offenders. The attack happened around 3 a.m. on July 26...in Cincinnati’s central business district. [Snip] We’re going to end the revolving door of injustice,"... "Our judges can no longer hide behind their cloak, and they have to be held accountable for not upholding law and order,"... [Snip] But Moreno also stressed how critically important it is for civilians to call authorities so that aid can be brought in as soon as possible.
Trump goes where no other president has
dared to tread as he yells out from the
White House roof
10 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/5/2025 4:10:21 PM
President Donald Trump appeared in an unusual spot on Tuesday--the West Wing roof--as he hinted there could be more White House renovations up his sleeve. [Snip] 'Mr. President, what are you doing up there?' Fox News White House correspondent Peter Doocy reporter yelled. In response, Trump gave his trademark fist pump and replied: 'Taking a little walk.' [Snip] He also hinted that he could add something on top of where he was standing, making a domed gesture with his hands. [Snip] 'Something beautiful. More ways to spend my money. We'll show you. It's just another way to spend my money for the country.'
Think the George Floyd ‘Racial Injustice’
Protests Were Insane? What If Obama Gets Indicted?
26 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/5/2025 11:20:36 AM
Former President Barack Obama will not face charges for treason, sedition or any other crime in the wake of newly disclosed intel. Whether Obama’s actions, if true, meet the elements of a crime is, of course, one thing. But this is not the primary reason Obama has little to worry about. [Snip] Why does Obama need not fear charges? The race card. Consider the protests after the death of George Floyd. [Snip] ...Floyd’s death triggered the largest “racial injustice” protests in American history. ...estimated 10,000 protests,...5% to 7% involving violence. Approximately 26 million people protested, 25 people...killed, 2,000 police officers...injured, and billions of dollars...
Getting MAGA To Go Left on Israel 10 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/4/2025 1:12:30 PM
The media has taken to claiming that there’s a “civil war” within MAGA over Israel. ... The “civil war” was manufactured by media hacks, hoping conservatives will adopt their support for Islamic terrorists, and social media influencers who are in the pay of Islamic interests. [Snip] There’s no ‘civil war’ within MAGA over Israel. There’s only leftist infiltration of the movement. [Snip] If we’re going to take our morality from fake media human rights outrages, America First is going to survive for approximately 5 minutes before bowing to the bleeding hearts.
CEO’s Salary At Defunded Corporation
For Public Broadcasting Could Fund A Radio
Station For Years
10 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/4/2025 12:33:56 PM
Still flabbergasted over being defunded by Congress, board members of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB) cried, lied, and quoted Shakespeare during their melodramatic July 24 board meeting. On August 1, the board announced it is starting an “orderly wind-down of its operations,” and most of the CPB staff positions “will conclude with the close of the fiscal year on September 30, 2025.” You would cry too, if you were losing a compensation package bigger than the salary of the president of the United States. In 2022, CPB CEO Patricia Harrison’s compensation was $524,000, according to the CPB’ most recently available 990 tax exempt form.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Yep, Mamdani Will Be NYC’s Next Mayor 24 replies
Posted by Hazymac8/12/2025 8:23:11 AM
"Nice city you have here — it would be a shame if something were to happen to it." Something bad is about to happen to New York City. Maybe I'm wrong. I hope I'm wrong. The greatest city in the world deserves something better than a commie-racist/nepo-red-diaper-baby like Zohran Mamdani as its mayor. But recent news has me convinced that the commie-racist/nepo-red-diaper-baby will be the city's next mayor. President Donald Trump called Mamdani a "communist lunatic" back in June, and he isn't wrong. Every time some old social media post of the Democrat mayoral nominee resurfaces, he's boasting that "the end goal is seizing the means of production," complaining that capitalism is theft,
Getting Jimmy Kimmel to Self-Deport Might
Be Trump’s Greatest Victory
23 replies
Posted by Dreadnought8/12/2025 5:31:51 PM
Can you imagine what a victory it would be for all Americans if, merely through his successful leadership, President Trump were able to get the basement-rated Jimmy Kimmel to self-deport? We already have a partial victory based solely on the fact that the Late Night elitist is putting the pieces in place to make it happen. Former comedian Jimmy Kimmel was a guest on former comedienne Sarah Silverman’s podcast on Friday, and the two of them discussed fleeing the country due to Trump. “A lot of people I know are thinking about where are they going to get citizenship?” Silverman said. Kimmel then broke this glorious news: “I did get Italian citizenship.”
Ex-first daughter Ashley Biden files for
divorce from husband, Dr. Howard Krein
— alongside snarky Instagram message
22 replies
Posted by NorthernDog8/12/2025 1:48:52 PM
Former President Joe Biden’s daughter, Ashley Biden, has filed for divorce from her plastic surgeon husband, Dr. Howard Krein, after more than 13 years of marriage, court records show. The 44-year-old ex-first daughter filed the papers in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas on Monday, The Post confirmed. Biden’s Instagram Story on the same day featured a photo of her walking through a park and flashing a thumbs-up, and was set to the song “Freedom” by Beyoncé, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer, which first reported the divorce filings. She also posted a quote that read: “New life, new beginnings means
More than importing the Muslim third-world,
the Islamic takeover of the West comes
down to birthrates By Olivia Murray
19 replies
Posted by 4250Luis8/13/2025 2:41:45 AM
New figures out of Austria are positively horrifying.but it would be less of a problem if real Europeans were having babies at equal or greater rates than the third world welfare louses hunkered down in. Brooke writes that “the country’s demographic composition is changing rapidly,” From a new report by Thomas Brooke at Remix News yesterday: New figures show that women from Syria, Afghanistan, and Iraq living in Austria have an average birth rate almost three times higher than that of Austrian-born women, according to data from the country’s Statistical Yearbook on Migration and Integration. Yes, progressive politicians inviting an invasion is absolutely a serious and unacceptable problem (it’s also treasonous),
Bill Clinton ‘prime suspect’
in Epstein investigation
17 replies
Posted by earlybird8/12/2025 9:48:19 PM
House Oversight and Government Reform Committee Chair James Comer (R-Ky.) on Monday said former President Clinton’s alleged ties to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein should be uncovered during his testimony before members of Congress. “Everybody in America wants to know what went on in Epstein Island, and we’ve all heard reports that Bill Clinton was a frequent visitor there, so he’s a prime suspect to be deposed by the House Oversight Committee,” Comer said Monday during an interview on Newsmax. “So, hopefully we’ll win that court battle with that subpoena and see President Clinton in October,” he added.
Jeanine Pirro Shreds Reporter Who Claims
DC Crime Is Down – 'Down from What?'
13 replies
Posted by NorthernDog8/12/2025 1:04:35 PM
U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia Jeanine Pirro on Monday briefly morphed into the Fox News host whose rapier-like response sent liberals quivering. Pirro spoke with the media to add her endorsement to President Donald Trump’s plan to reduce crime in the District of Columbia by calling out the National Guard and putting the Metropolitan Police Department under federal control. (Snip) “If we had the fourth-highest homicide rate in the country two years ago, all of the sudden it goes down, and people want to pat themselves on the back. No way. Talk to any of the crime victims,”
New: Texas Democrats Who Fled to Stop
Redistricting Just Folded Like a Bad Poker Hand
12 replies
Posted by Dreadnought8/12/2025 7:50:47 PM
As predicted, the Texas Democrat legislators who fled to blue states to deny a quorum for redistricting have folded. Still, I'm not sure anyone expected them to fold this soon. According to ABC News, the runaways who claimed to be saving "democracy" are heading back to their home state early, claiming to have accomplished their goal of raising "awareness" about gerrymandering. That's a very polite way of saying they failed miserably. ABC13 has confirmed with multiple sources that House Democrats will return to Texas. Eyewitness News has not confirmed the date, but we do know that Democrats believe they've accomplished their mission by killing
Comey’s Last Moves: Spying on a President,
Setting the Trap, Lying About It
10 replies
Posted by 4250Luis8/13/2025 2:39:17 AM
Thus far, James Comey’s activities have been largely confined to his duties, however corrupt, within the FBI, or inward-looking. From January 2017 onward, his activities become dramatically darker, arguably illegal, and more forward-looking. On January 5, 2017, a bit more than two weeks before Inauguration, Obama met with Biden, James Comey, John Brennan, James Clapper, Susan Rice, and Assistant Attorney General Sally Yates in the Oval Office. Comey did not disclose this meeting to Congress when asked about how many times he met with Obama. "Twice," he said, under oath. It was actually three times.
Texas Senate approves new congressional
lines as House Democrats remain out of state
10 replies
Posted by Pinkpanther8/12/2025 5:27:27 PM
The Texas Senate approved new congressional lines on Tuesday in a rare mid-decade redistricting effort that could aid Republicans in their effort to keep control of the U.S. House of Representatives after the 2026 election. The vote was 19-2, with nine Democrats absent after exiting the Senate floor moments after the maps were taken up, a show of protest against what they framed as a "corrupt process." "This mid-decade redistricting isn’t about fair representation—it’s about politicians picking their voters instead of voters choosing their leaders," the Senate Democratic Caucus said in a statement. "And it doesn’t stop here. If they can gerrymander now, they can
ICE swamped with 100,000 applications
in two weeks since announcing hiring blitz
10 replies
Posted by sunset8/12/2025 4:10:48 PM
Immigration and Customs Enforcement has been inundated with applications in the two weeks since it launched a major recruitment campaign. The Department of Homeland Security announced Tuesday morning that ICE has received 100,000 applications in less than 15 days from “patriotic Americans who want to help remove murderers, gang members, pedophiles, and terrorists” from the United States. In order to attract more recruits, ICE lifted age restrictions on hiring. Previously, applicants were limited to a minimum age of 21 and could be no older than 40. New hires will be eligible for a one-time bonus of up to $50,000, up to $60,000 in student loan repayment, and other incentives
CNN’s effort to ridicule Trump as Washington’s
Batman backfires as social media hails
'cool' comparison
10 replies
Posted by Moritz558/12/2025 4:08:09 PM
CNN host Abby Phillip compared President Donald Trump to Batman on Monday night while criticizing his efforts to clean up crime in Washington, D.C. However, social media users thought the comparison made Trump look "cool." During the intro to CNN's "NewsNight," Phillip mocked Trump as the "crime-fighter-in-chief" of the nation's capital and compared him to the comic book character after the president's announcement earlier in the day that the federal government would be cleaning up crime in the city.
Sherrod Brown to run for U.S. Senate against
Jon Husted in 2026, reports say
9 replies
Posted by Harlowe8/12/2025 3:36:36 PM
Democrat Sherrod Brown is mounting a return to the U.S. Senate after he was ousted by Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno last year. ... Brown’s decision follows his loss ...which was one of the most expensive races in the nation in 2024. [Snip] Brown was first elected to the U.S. Senate in 2006 and survived two reelection campaigns before falling to Moreno. [Snip] He announced in March the creation of the Dignity of Work Institute, his first major project since leaving Capitol Hill. ...he said both Republicans and Democrats have ignored workers for years and failed to address issues like low wages, overtime and home ownership.
Post New Article