Post New Article

No, America Wasn’t ‘Founded’ By Immigrants

Original Article

Posted By: Harlowe, 1/29/2025 12:16:27 AM

Sunday, CBS News’ Margaret Brennan tried to get one over on Vice President J.D. Vance, badgering him about immigration and claiming “this is a country founded by immigrants.” But this narrative isn’t just inaccurate, it’s a calculated lie... Vance held his own, refuting the baseless claim by noting the country was founded “by some immigrants and some settlers”... [Snip] Britain began establishing the 13 original colonies in the early 1600’s. Over the next century or so, hundreds of thousands of Brits moved to the British colonies that were established by settlers--not immigrants. There was no “nation” being immigrated to by the first settlers.

Comments:

Precisely, there was no pre-existing country when the Brits came here—it was just land. “They were entrepreneurs building this nation from scratch, not immigrants joining a pre-existing nation.” The Native Americans were clans—peoples, not nations and “believed to have come from Asia before crossing the Bering land bridge and making their way to the present-day United States.” Anglo Protestants founded this country. “These settlers forged a new nation, instituted customs, traditions, and a national identity.”

Post Reply

Reminder: “WE ARE A SALON AND NOT A SALOON”

Your thoughts, comments, and ideas are always welcome here. But we ask you to please be mindful and respectful. Threatening or crude language doesn't persuade anybody and makes the conversation less enjoyable for fellow L.Dotters.


Reply 1 - Posted by: DVC 1/29/2025 12:47:35 AM (No. 1884303)
Actually, most of our Founding Fathers were born here. IIRC, Hamilton was an exception.
38 people like this.

Reply 2 - Posted by: sunset 1/29/2025 1:00:37 AM (No. 1884306)
They were called settlers
50 people like this.

Reply 3 - Posted by: anniebc 1/29/2025 4:31:06 AM (No. 1884326)
Even if it were founded by immigrants; they couldn't have been illegal, right? Leftists are more stupid than the definition of stupid. My sister calls it super stupid.
47 people like this.

Reply 4 - Posted by: mifla 1/29/2025 5:30:49 AM (No. 1884341)
Even if true, things change after a few hundred years. It is not an immortal concept.
19 people like this.

Reply 5 - Posted by: chumley 1/29/2025 6:27:24 AM (No. 1884389)
It starts out as settlers or immigrants. If the numbers are small enough and the newcomers disperse into the culture, they assimilate and all is good. If they stay in their own cultural enclaves, they never assimilate and eventually become conquerors. Short of military action, thats how you take over a country.
22 people like this.

Reply 6 - Posted by: JrSample 1/29/2025 7:37:12 AM (No. 1884467)
Australia was founded by convicts sent from England. They currently have a points-based immigration system that is strictly enforced. Funny how we don't hear our pointy-headed elites badgering the Canadian or Australian governments about the enforcement of their immigration statutes.
23 people like this.

Reply 7 - Posted by: felixcat 1/29/2025 7:39:02 AM (No. 1884470)
When America was receiving a lot of European immigrants, it was with the understanding that we needed their strong backs, work ethic and that they would become Americans. We welcome you but no freebies, no accommodation of your languages, etc. Become American and contribute to its success and what you speak at home is your business.
31 people like this.

Reply 8 - Posted by: RussZilla 1/29/2025 7:50:19 AM (No. 1884483)
Only one other country allows birth citizenship, and that is Canada. Europe doesn’t allow it in any of their countries.
11 people like this.

Reply 9 - Posted by: bpl40 1/29/2025 8:54:56 AM (No. 1884522)
Willingness to assimilate is a mandatory requirement for any immigrant coming to our shores. It is part of our culture and heritage. It must be included and practiced as part of our laws.
20 people like this.

Reply 10 - Posted by: Ida Lou Pino 1/29/2025 9:58:09 AM (No. 1884596)
I've never understood why immigrants from Siberia had more claim to American land than immigrants from elsewhere. No more special concessions for Siberian-Americans. We're all on an equal footing.
13 people like this.

Reply 11 - Posted by: Encore 1/29/2025 10:18:59 AM (No. 1884616)
The left would have us resort back to a land of ‘clans’. No national unity or identity. What a great weakness that would result in. A lawless land of warlords, a ‘Mad Max’ atmosphere. The left can’t see past their money grubbing hands.
8 people like this.

Reply 12 - Posted by: cor-vet 1/29/2025 10:45:19 AM (No. 1884644)
Brennan proves once again, that a degree in journalism is as worthless as a degree in gender studies or community organizing!
7 people like this.

Reply 13 - Posted by: Zigrid 1/29/2025 10:45:57 AM (No. 1884646)
JDVance has to be on his toes every news conference with the drive by media...they know he will run in 2028 and they are starting to work on him now....the Sunday shows are a great classroom for him...and let's remember...he was a scholar.....and the DEI dingbats that are put up against his expertise... leave a lot to be desired when it comes to our National history....so bring it on ABC and NBC and CNN....JD is ready for ya!!
5 people like this.

Reply 14 - Posted by: rikkitikki 1/29/2025 10:49:04 AM (No. 1884651)
To #10: To your point, the Siberian-Americans are simply immigrants/settlers who got here sooner than the European competition. The Siberian-Americans' claims to have 'owned' N. America has pros and cons: In favor, their own, verbally-transmitted myths of creation and ancestry claim they've always been here. They really believe them...but no one else does. Against: no archeological evidence of human occupation pre-dates the last Ice Age....no one was here. In fact, the recent extinction of most large mammals in N.America (mammoths, saber-tooths, sloths, etc) corroborates the timing of their arrival.
4 people like this.

Reply 15 - Posted by: Geoman 1/29/2025 11:38:04 AM (No. 1884691)
Re: #10: Many of my ancestors, who had settled in the Virginia/N. Carolina mountains before the U.S. was established are alleged by certain academics and politicians with an agenda, to have walked to North America from or through Siberia via the Siberian Land Bridge, Bering, although the evidence for this migration is not conclusive or even convincing when the fossil records of early hominids are examined. DNA research has proven equally inconclusive. As far as "special concessions," the only beneficiaries of such, which I am aware, are of white people claiming to be of indigenous stock. It was settlers and immigrants who, when critical mass was achieved, used the laws to prevent Native Americans, specifically the Cherokee, many of whom had adopted Christianity and a written alphabet, lived in houses, and were becoming capitalist traders, from actually owning the land on which they had lived and had created their own communities and settlements. Nomads, they were not. Newcomers could push those already established off of the land by force of law, so many kept moving West, into American lands claimed by the French and Spanish but later sold to or taken by U.S. citizens. That is rather like the Tren de Aragua gang removing you from your house by gunpoint or democrat political decree, because they do not honor your claim to property which you may have legally acquired, deeds and titles notwithstanding. My extended family was only able to "own" property through inter-marriage and as a reward for service in the U.S. military from revolutionary times through WWII.
5 people like this.

Reply 16 - Posted by: PrayerWarrior 1/29/2025 12:52:51 PM (No. 1884744)
Margaret Brennan and CBS don't care whether it was immigrants or settlers who came here, they just wanted to embarrass and win an argument with JD Vance. Both CBS an Margaret Brennan are enemies of all that is good and decent.
9 people like this.

Below, you will find ...
Most Recent Articles posted by "Harlowe"
and
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Most Recent Articles posted by Harlowe"
Trump won’t block immigration arrests
in houses of worship. Now these 27 religious
groups are suing
12 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/12/2025 7:10:10 PM Post Reply
More than two-dozen Christian and Jewish groups representing millions of Americans--ranging from the Episcopal Church and the Union for Reform Judaism to the Mennonites and Unitarian Universalists--filed a federal court lawsuit Tuesday challenging a Trump administration move giving immigration agents more leeway to make arrests at houses of worship. [Snip] ...The DHS assistant secretary for public affairs, Tricia McLaughlin, offered this response via email: “We are protecting our schools, places of worship, and Americans who attend, by preventing criminal aliens and gang members from exploiting these locations and take safe haven there because these criminals knew that under the previous Administration that law enforcement couldn’t go inside.”
Harry and Meghan's latest act was nauseating
- I can't recall anything more miscalculated
20 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/12/2025 12:41:20 AM Post Reply
Who is Harry to lecture anyone on ‘weak moral character’? [Snip] He made the thinly-veiled criticism about ‘weak moral character’ in front of an audience of 40,000 at the opening of the Invictus Games, [Snip] Insiders at the Games were reportedly angry and upset, complaining the Duke and Duchess of Sussex ‘continuously insert themselves into the spotlight’ at the Games. [Snip] We had a fawning Meghan making doe eyes while looking up at him, clutching his arm and grabbing his face for a very public kiss. No photo-op went unmissed. Megs was determined that she and their love affair would take centre-stage,...
Seeking Sanctuary: Church leaders see
duty to protect immigrants -- even against ICE
25 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/8/2025 7:25:24 PM Post Reply
Daylight broke through the stained glass windows behind the Rev. Patrick Nicolino as he sat in the quiet sanctuary of the First Congregational United Church of Christ of Elyria. [Snip] It was there in that sanctuary nearly a week before that...the pastor..spoke to his congregants about the fears and concerns spiking throughout the community of threats of deportation and xenophobia. “Historically, churches have always been places of safety and security,” ... “The place in which, no matter what the individual has done, if they come into the church space, on to the church property, they are protected.
The long shadows of petty tyrants 13 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/8/2025 5:30:27 PM Post Reply
It’s been about three weeks, America. We’ve had plane crashes, more mass shootings, and one sure-seems-like-a-coup-to-me by an unelected billionaire and a handful of frat boys that I’d report to the cops for breaking into my bank information if they were down at my at my shady neighbors’ house doing this over pizza rolls and Pabst Blue Ribbons. [Snip] I forgot about that gorgeous new resort President Donald Trump suggested building by ordering a foreign country to get out ‘cuz we’re taking over. [Snip] “When small men cast long shadows, you can be sure the sun is about to set.”
Top federal agency with history of wasteful
spending could be next DOGE target
17 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/8/2025 12:24:08 AM Post Reply
Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) chief Elon Musk’s efforts to clean up waste and fraud in the federal government will soon shift its focus to the Social Security Administration (SSA) in a move likely to create a firestorm with Democrats. [Snip] Just Facts, a nonprofit research institute, previously reported that the agency disbursed roughly $2 billion in fraudulent or improper payments in 2022,... [Snip] "Social Security will not be touched, it will only be strengthened," President Donald Trump said during a press conference on Friday. "We have illegal immigrants on Social Security and we're going to find out who they are and take them out."
President Trump Says He Will Fire Kennedy
Center Board Members and Name Himself Chairman
7 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/7/2025 10:51:55 PM Post Reply
President Trump has declared his intention to take over the leadership of the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington. D.C. [Snip] I have decided to immediately terminate multiple individuals from the Board of Trustees, including the Chairman, who do not share our Vision for a Golden Age in Arts and Culture.” [Snip] Trump went on to attack drag programming mounted at the performing arts center, adding, “Just last year, the Kennedy Center featured Drag Shows specifically targeting our youth--THIS WILL STOP. The Kennedy Center is an American Jewel, and must reflect the brightest STARS on its stage from all across our Nation.
US ally cautions world against
doubting Trump's 'shockingly innovative'
Gaza proposal
2 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/5/2025 6:59:15 PM Post Reply
UNITED NATIONS - President Donald Trump’s suggestion that the U.S. "take over" the Gaza Strip has garnered negative reactions across the globe and even from within his own party. [Snip] Hungarian Foreign Minister Peter Szijjártó, however, doesn’t think the world should be so quick to dismiss President Trump’s proposal. Szijjártó compared the Gaza proposal... [Snip] "I would like to remind everyone that when President Trump announced his plan regarding the Abraham Accords, there was hardly anyone in the world who would have believed in the success....those agreements,...brought a totally new dimension to the life of the Middle East,"
Trump won't pay for Gaza reconstruction,
WH says
3 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/5/2025 3:17:30 PM Post Reply
US President Donald Trump didn’t commit to sending troops to Gaza--but he also did not rule anything out--because, according to White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt, the president is “very good” when negotiating and wants to preserve that leverage. [Snip] “His administration is going to work with our partners in the region to reconstruct this region. [Snip] Leavitt reiterated that it’s been made clear to Trump that the US needs to be involved in the rebuilding effort to ensure stability for all people. [Snip] “The president made this decision with a humanitarian heart for all people in the region.”
Defunding USAID Isn’t About Reducing
The Deficit, It’s About Shutting Down
Left-Wing Propaganda
25 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/5/2025 1:29:56 PM Post Reply
The most common argument you’ll hear from those defending the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) is that the grant dollars in question are just a fraction of the federal budget--less than one percent! [Snip] The point is to expose USAID for the left-wing propaganda and regime change operation that it has become, and to shut it down. In the six decades since it was established, USAID has gone from fighting poverty, spreading American ideals, and undercutting Soviet propaganda, to becoming a woke propaganda operation of its own that actively undermines the pillars of western civilization. It’s gone from exporting democracy to exporting deviancy,
'Level it': Trump says US will 'take over'
Gaza Strip, rebuild it to stabilize Middle East
12 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/4/2025 11:49:39 PM Post Reply
The U.S. will "take over the Gaza Strip," level it and rebuild the area, President Donald Trump said during a press conference Tuesday evening after meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House. [Snip] "And everybody I've spoken to--this was not a decision made lightly--everybody I've spoken to loves the idea of the United States owning that piece of land. Developing and creating thousands of jobs with something that will be magnificent in a really magnificent area that nobody would know. Nobody can look because all they see is death and destruction and rubble."
Homeless Elites Like Vivek Ramaswamy Will
Never Represent The Interests Of Fellow
Cincinnatians Like Me
29 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/4/2025 3:37:58 PM Post Reply
On a small hill just north of the Cincinnati city limits sits a sprawling academic campus that, at first glance, you could be forgiven for mistaking for a small college. [Snip] The all-boys school...attracting...sons of Cincinnatians for more than 150 years. [Snip] ...at an elite place like St. X, Vivek stood out... [Snip] ...Vivek Ramaswamy never made this place his home. He’s...someone whose wealth led him to see the globe as his residence. We don’t want the best, smartest technocrat in charge; we want the man who would abhor our city’s exploitation...preserve it for those who have lived, worked, bled, and died to make it what it is.
If Presidents Can’t Control Executive
Agencies, Elections Are Fake
6 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/3/2025 5:46:09 PM Post Reply
Amid the hundreds of substantive executive actions President Donald Trump has taken in his first two weeks back in the White House, perhaps none matter more than his efforts at bureaucracy-busting. [Snip] Democrats claiming Trump will “politicize” agencies by installing “loyalists” are only expressing rage that Republicans are attempting to take the keys to the unconstitutional power structure Democrats have controlled for more than a century. [Snip] ...Trump isn’t “weaponizing” or “politicizing” these agencies. He’s fighting their inherent weaponization. Firing and investigating people who abuse public power, and ending the theft of American labor to fund evil international patronage schemes--that isn’t retribution, it’s justice.
Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)
Kamala Harris is Democratic front-runner
for California governor in 2026: Poll
37 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 2/13/2025 12:21:15 PM Post Reply
Former Vice President Kamala Harris would be the Democratic front-runner for governor of California if she jumped into the Golden State’s 2026 race to replace term-limited Gov. Gavin Newsom (D), polling shows. Harris snagged support for a hypothetical gubernatorial bid from nearly 6 in 10 Democratic primary voters in California, 57 percent, according to a survey from Emerson College Polling/Inside California Politics/The Hill. Former Rep. Katie Porter (D-Calif.), who left the House to mount an unsuccessful Senate bid last year, followed at 9 percent support. Ex-Speaker of the California State Assembly Antonio Villaraigosa (D) and sitting Lt. Gov. Eleni Kounalaki (D) brought in 4 percent each, and another 17
Rep. Jan Schakowsky Suggests Women Might
Not Pursue Jobs in Manufacturing Because
“Man” is in the Name (Video)
32 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 2/13/2025 4:00:48 PM Post Reply
Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) pushed a bizarre explanation for why women might not pursue jobs in manufacturing. Schakowsky made her remarks on Wednesday during a Commerce, Manufacturing and Trade subcommittee hearing entitled “AI in Manufacturing: Securing American Leadership in Manufacturing and the Next Generation of Technologies.” Schakowsky suggested that perhaps the reason fewer women choose a career in manufacturing is that the term has the word “man” in it. Schakowsky stated, “Yesterday, I met with a manufacturing company, but they also are engaged in getting young people more engaged in manufacturing. I asked them, ‘How many of those students that are signing up and want to do this, how many are women?'”
Senate Democrat: McConnell’s vote against
Gabbard indicates ‘Trump cult’ can
be ‘broken’
31 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 2/13/2025 12:37:41 PM Post Reply
Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) said during an interview that Sen. Mitch McConnell’s (R-Ky.) final vote against Tulsi Gabbard, the newly sworn-in director of national intelligence, indicates that President Trump’s “cult” can be “broken.” “Mitch McConnell breaking yesterday with his Republican colleagues telling the truth to power, indicates that maybe the Trump cult, the intimidation and threats can be broken,” Blumenthal said during his Thursday morning appearance on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe.” “Our tools are limited. We’re in the minority. They control obviously both houses of Congress and the White House and indirectly the United States Supreme Court,” he added.
SecDef Hegseth Gets a Rude and Disrespectful
Welcome by US Military Command in Germany
30 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 2/13/2025 4:40:39 AM Post Reply
Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth began a tour of Europe Tuesday, starting at the headquarters of US European Command at Patch Barracks in Stuttgart, Germany. The newly minted SecDef has a heavy schedule in front of him, inspecting US forces in Europe and dealing with his first meeting with NATO. He is obviously trying to move beyond the controversies associated with his confirmation. He is also trying to lead by example and reverse the cultural rot in the US military by force of will.
McConnell Goes Off on Tulsi Gabbard After
Voting Against Her For DNI
28 replies
Posted by Imright 2/12/2025 2:06:28 PM Post Reply
Toxic RINO Senator Mitch McConnell on Wednesday voted ‘no’ on Tulsi Gabbard’s confirmation vote. The Senate voted 52-48 to confirm Tulsi Gabbard as the next Director of National Intelligence. McConnell was the lone RINO who voted against President Trump’s nominee. Recall that McConnell was also one of the three Senators to vote against Pete Hegseth’s confirmation as Defense Secretary. Shortly after the confirmation vote on Wednesday, McConnell went off on Tulsi Gabbard.
Scientist warns it might be too late to
deflect ‘city-killer’ asteroid heading
toward Earth
25 replies
Posted by Ida Lou Pino 2/12/2025 10:54:19 AM Post Reply
What a rock-block. An award-winning UK scientist warns that it might be too late to deflect the “city killer” asteroid that’s headed toward Earth. Deflection efforts “might not be able to stop 2024 YR4,” cautioned Dr. Robin George Andrews, a London-based volcanologist and author, in a chilling X post blowing up online. Discovered hurtling through our galaxy in December 2024, the building-sized space rock is reportedly at the top of NASA’s watch list when it comes to deep space dangers, boasting a 1-in-43 chance of striking Earth in 2032.
Senate confirms RFK Jr. as Health secretary;
McConnell lone GOP dissenter
23 replies
Posted by ConservativeYankee 2/13/2025 11:52:38 AM Post Reply
Longtime vaccine critic Robert F. Kennedy is now the nation’s top health official, after the Senate Thursday voted almost entirely on party lines to confirm him atop a department of nearly 100,000 employees that run 13 agencies. The 52-48 confirmation vote brings to a close a contentious three-month confirmation fight that served as a significant test of the Republican Party’s loyalty to President Trump. Only Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) cast a GOP vote against Kennedy’s confirmation, after previously bucking his party on Trump’s defense secretary and national intelligence director.
Shonda Rhimes Resigns From Kennedy Center
After Donald Trump’s Takeover Of Performing
Arts Institution
23 replies
Posted by Dreadnought 2/12/2025 4:54:40 PM Post Reply
Shonda Rhimes, who had been treasurer of the Kennedy Center, has resigned from the board following Donald Trump’s takeover of the arts institution. “Please be advised that as of today, Shonda Rhimes has resigned from the board of the Kennedy Center,” a spokesperson for the writer producer said. Rhimes had been appointed to the board by President Barack Obama and was serving as one of the officers. More to come.
TIME TO NAME NAMES: Trump to Reveal the
Biggest Fraudsters and Beneficiaries of
Gov't Waste
21 replies
Posted by Mercedes44 2/13/2025 4:35:55 AM Post Reply
We’ve been reading so much about all the rampant waste in the federal government, from USAID to the Education Department to FEMA, that Elon Musk and DOGE continue to uncover at a staggering pace. But sometimes you wonder, who are the beneficiaries of all this fraud and waste—where’s the money going? I mean, besides to terrorists, social justice warriors and the like. Your questions may soon be answered. Grab the popcorn and fluff the couch pillows because Donald Trump told reporters at a briefing in the Oval Office Wednesday afternoon that he plans to name names at a press conference scheduled for Thursday. Responding to a reporter's question, he charged:
Bolton: ‘Trump Has Effectively Surrendered
to Putin’
21 replies
Posted by ladydawgfan 2/12/2025 11:48:25 PM Post Reply
Former National Security Advisor John Bolton said Wednesday on CNN’s “The Source” that President Donald Trump “has effectively surrendered” to Russian President Vladimir Putin. Host Kaitlan Collins said, “You’ve previously said that that you believe Putin sees Trump as what you described as an easy mark. You were there for their first meeting in Helsinki. What are your expectations for this one?” Bolton said, “Well, I don’t have any expectations anymore. I think we know exactly what’s gonna happen. President Trump has effectively surrendered to Putin before the negotiations have even begun. The positions that Defense Secretary Hegseth announced in Brussels –
HUGE: New House Task Force on Federal
Secrets (Including Epstein List, UFOs,
JFK) Teases Shocking Info
21 replies
Posted by JoElla Bee 2/12/2025 3:50:23 AM Post Reply
We've been seeing a pretty amazing move to make over the government over the last three weeks since President Donald Trump has taken office.[Snip] Now, there's a follow-up action in Congress with the House Oversight Committee naming Rep. Anna Paulina Luna (R-FL) to head the new "Task Force on Declassification of Federal Secrets." Luna announced that they would be looking into UFOs, the Jeffrey Epstein client list, JFK, RFK, and MLK, as well as the origins of COVID-19 and the 9/11 files.
Harry and Meghan's latest act was nauseating
- I can't recall anything more miscalculated
20 replies
Posted by Harlowe 2/12/2025 12:41:20 AM Post Reply
Who is Harry to lecture anyone on ‘weak moral character’? [Snip] He made the thinly-veiled criticism about ‘weak moral character’ in front of an audience of 40,000 at the opening of the Invictus Games, [Snip] Insiders at the Games were reportedly angry and upset, complaining the Duke and Duchess of Sussex ‘continuously insert themselves into the spotlight’ at the Games. [Snip] We had a fawning Meghan making doe eyes while looking up at him, clutching his arm and grabbing his face for a very public kiss. No photo-op went unmissed. Megs was determined that she and their love affair would take centre-stage,...
Post New Article