1. Populism The Republicans have only won the popular vote since Ronald Reagan’s presidency on two occasions: 1988 and 2004. In both instances, even the patrician Bushes were able to paint their liberal opponents as out-of-touch Massachusetts magnificoes. Lee Atwater turned Michael Dukakis, the helmeted tank driver, into a bumbling Harvard Square naïf. Karl Rove reminded the country that John Kerry, the wind surfer, was a spandex-wearing, wetsuit-outfitted yuppie who lived in several of his rich wife’s mansions, as he jetted around in her plane and sailed on her boat. Otherwise, it was the Republicans
Great insights once again from VDH. He doesn´t mention fraud, but his assessments are solid, especially on the liberal elite voters who felt oh-so-cool voting for the exotic "black" golfer. I´m thinking Allen West-Tim Tebow the next time around. Both have time on their hands and have that underdog/wonderdog appeal.
This excellent article should be a Must Read. VDH lives in Realville and Republicans and Conservatives, hopefully, will listen to his good, common-sense analysis. We can begin work now for 2016 with VDH´s logic and reasoning.
#2 thank you for helping #1 to understand Karl Rove a little better. If the Heritage Foundation can host a dinner with Karl as the guest speaker, I wouldn´t be too critical. I went to such a dinner, and Karl generously gave of his time to meet all 698 of us. Believe me, he has a lot more "upstairs" than say a Jim Messina who looks like Howdy Doody (my apologies to Howdy Doody).
This is a brilliant analysis: penetrating, comprehensive and painful to absorb. Will the Republican leaders learn from it? Of course not; if they could learn they wouldn´t be R leaders. Just look at McCain...eager to suck up to a completely discredited minion of King Hussein. VDH should have mentioned the RNC bigwigs are self-important, suicidal idiots.
Those like #1 are doomed forever to live in a liberal country.
But first they should read this article. And all should read twice the part entitled "Beware the Cocoon".
Every once in a while it should dawn on us that we are the choir we are preaching to. There´s a big, far different world out there that gets its news from the MSM, NPR and the ABC networks. And Dr. Hanson knows which way that news is slanted. So should we.
We will always have Eeyores around us. We don´t have to be them.
Pardon a second post, but #8 gave excellent advice, which is to visit the link given by #12´s comment after the article: http://ayearningforpublius.wordpress.com/2012/11/08/preparing-for-dictatorship-questions-for-the-younger-generations/
I am Bookmarking the website and possibly using some of his article "Preparing for a Dictatorship" when I substitute teach in history, although I will have to be careful to not mention Obama. I often use Nazi Germany pre-WWII to show what can happen if we aren´t vigilant about our freedoms.
Parents need to go over "Preparing for a Dictatorship" with their teenage kids.
Excellent article from VDH, as always. His analysis of what happened and his prescriptions for changing the drift of the country will be, unfortunately ignored by the placemen miscalled Republican leaders.
His description of some of the savvier and more successful looters and freeloaders in California was interesting.
Yes #13! If I had not buried myself in the ´cocoon´ before the election, I would have been more prepared for the disastrous result instead of being devastated. And not listening to voices (like Karl Rove) who know American politics inside and out is burying ourselves even deeper in our cocoon.
When VDH speaks, I listen. This is an excellent analysis of what went wrong. Now I´d like him to concentrate on what we as individuals can do to make it right next time. As wonderful as it is, Number 13´s ´preaching to the choir´ here on Lucianne does not make for winning elections and turning the country around.
The frustration of losing our country, as we know it, is evident in this thread. But we have to adapt our fight. The Brits and French used to line up and walk toward each other shooting their guns and cannons, then came sharp shooters and ambushes, then came planes with bombs, then came jungle warfare, then came suicide bombers. We have to adapt in this current political war! We have these old fossils of "political advisers" telling our GOP candidates to move to the middle and be careful not to say anything offensive that they can use against you in a commercial.
While the left has had great success with combining all the single issue highly motivated voter groups in their common hatred of conservative principles, we try to appeal to the bored masses who sit home on election day. They lure the people who care more about their right to abort, their right to marry, their right to a government check than they do their country. We just have this milk toast approach that doesn´t motivate the masses to get off their asses and get in the fight.
The GOP power brokers are incapable of adjusting their methods and as rooted in keeping their power as the Ted Kennedys and Strom Thurmans were in Congress. We need to abandon the GOP and go with a new and smarter fight. The fight for our constitutional rights!
Remember when Mitt Romney came after Rick Perry with the N-rock? When he came after Newt Gingrich with stories from the ex-wife? When he took out Herman Cain with stories about white women who were helped by him?
Where was that Mitt Romney in the general election? I maintain that the Republicans didn´t want to win. They had plenty of avenues of attack against the wannabe dictator Barack Hussein Obama. They settled for the weak argument that he was in over his head. After the election, the Republicans had plenty of evidence of vote fraud in all sorts of venues. Except for Allen West, the issue was not addressed at all. It has become as taboo as birtherism.
Yes, what did we learn????. We learned that Obama knows how to win - not even playing by the rules. We learned that he and his czars and mafia are a well oiled machine that knows how to take over this country. It is happening right before our eyes. There is NO going back......
1. Early voting only for those who can prove hardship. 2. Purge voter rolls of dead people. 3. Only voters with valid picture ID allowed. (If dims say it disenfranchises the poor then they can hold ID drives).
If I had a choice for a dinner partner and a long dinner chatting with someone, it would be Karl Rove. I absolutely love him and listening to him. People advocating a third party and dissing the Pubbies are beyond stupid.
VDH, as always, presents a great analysis of most of the key "lessons learned." But I still think that there is something else in play here that everyone seems to be missing. Namely, our national elections are becoming more and more like high school student body president elections. The Republicans keep nominating dweebs from the chess club while the Democrats have figured out that they´ll win almost every time if they go with the cool guy that the chicks dig and the stoners like to hang with.
Like-ability, whether we want to admit it or nor, is huge in these national elections. Reagan had it, Romney didn´t. Republicans need to pay more attention to that in selecting future candidates. It´s not trivial at all.
As always, another excellent article from VDH. He always seems to come up with a clear explanation of whatever situation he writes about.
As far as what WE can do in the future, given the changing atmosphere of the various ethnic groups in this country, and their proclivity of voting for those who will give them "stuff" without working for it, and the fact that old school Americans are becoming fewer and fewer(check out the rise of Lations, Black, Orientals, etc.) the only solution I can offer is that which I have stated many times here. Somehow, someway, we need to rise up and have ourselves another revolution and throw off the tyranny of what we have now. I know this seems to be extreme, but remember, Thomas Jefferson himself wrote in the Declaration of Independence that it is our DUTY to do just exactly that.
I´m ready at any time. And I´m 67yrs old. I can still use my weapons.
Nov 27, 2012 Victor Davis Hanson’s smashing article declares the main press as just plain insidious. It´s all Party Line. It´s built in by generations of cultural Marxism in all of our schools. Communism is quietly at the base of all our troubles. STEALTH communism (never discussed). Proof? Just one way to talk: The Party Line. TRULY insidious Rush, Drudge, Breitbart, Hannity, Napolitano, all on our side, as good as they all are, are still no bigger than a small start-up operation that preaches mostly to the choir. We will win only by observing, criticizing, taking back the supposed main stream words being used against us every day. As Hanson states, WATCH them and their strategy, refute relentlessly. Do not call Hitler or Obama a liberal, call them all the collectivist words as you prefer to use on them. We must constantly pitch freedom and relentlessly argue down non freedom, We must ID The Party Line, its endless, stupid cliches. Identify and expose these stupid cliches for all its massive open fraud. Hanson reminds us, “slanted liberal (he really means statist, collectivist etc) news is still passed off as Walter Cronkite mainstream apolitical news”, like their normal. We need tons of new pro free market language given out to new millions. And we must clean up this semantic war they are winning. Politically correct speech does not stand up is not honest. Truth replaces PC the Party Line and most of the TV traitors to the truth.
VDH is firing on all cylinders here. Especially gratifying was his exploding of the myth of the "conservative Latino" that has blinded the GOP for a decade or more. Open borders and amnesty will only enable more of the Democrat voters and public service parasites, both legal and illegal, who have been instrumental in the destruction of California.
LESSON #11...What the GOP needs to do, between now and January 6, 2013, is obtain court orders, in all those critical swing state voting jurisdictions, to have the electronic voter machines: (A) Impounded and (B) Examined by court appointed, certified, impartial computer experts!
The GOP/Romney Campaign failed to label Obama accurately, while the Dem summer smear campaign against Romney went largely unanswered. We were assured that after the convention the war chest would open up a big can of whoopa$$ on Obama. When concerns were expressed about expected Dem voter fraud we were assured that the Romney team had lawyers ready in all the key districts. All that I saw was warmed-over whoopa$$ and a dearth of lawyers the rest of our lives should be blessed with, just standard operating procedure for the “stupid” party who after decades of the same myopia must now be considered collaborators.
I can understand those who, bless their hearts, still believe they can find a political solution through the Republican Party or that people will be so sick of socialism by the next election we’re sure to win. Our culture has changed and we have to address the fundamental reality that this new “American” culture elected Obama. The system is already broken as evidenced by the blatant and accepted voter fraud, and the non-existent resistance by the GOP leadership. Traditional politics is a waste of time. We need to identify new tactics in the culture war that are the equivalent to guerilla tactics in a hot war. What those are, I’m not sure yet. Its time for necessity to give birth to a whole lot of invention, or we will go the way of the Old South…Gone With The Wind.
Karl Rove made a perfect fool of himself on election night, he sure looked like part of the problem to me, not the solution with his RINO ways. The Romney campaign didn´t just lose, they were apparently wrong internally about - EVERYTHING, and so was Rove.
This is a pretty good VDH, but I think he´s wrong about "the cocoon" business, it was the Romney campaign and Rove that supplied "the cocoon", and THEY WERE DEAD WRONG ABOUT EVERYTHING. Even Rasmussen, and I have to believe he was mislead by the Romney camp - or possibly vice-versa.
Agree with above posts--excellent article! I think he is absolutely right on the Latino vote issue. I don´t think immigration is the real issue--new immigrant groups typically tend to vote as a bloc, usually for the Democrats. But once they move up the economic ladder, they no longer identify as much based on ethnicity. The Democrats have a vested interest in keeping Hispanics a poor, but solid minority. I predict that Hispanics in the next several generations are going to inter-marry and many will be only be identified by that group if they have a Hispanic-sounding last name.
Get over the whining about voter fraud. That´s not why we lost. Yes, there was fraud but not enough to lose 300 electoral votes.
Also get over the nonsense about a 3rd party. You know how silly that makes you sound? We made a great start in 2010, knocking out many RINOs with tea partiers...and not accepting people like Mike Castle and that 80 yr old dolt from Indiana. It will take more than one election cycle to come back.
Lastly, re-read VDH´s comments about BO being a one-of-a-kind phenom. You and I don´t get the appeal but obviously others do. We only win by offering a grand vision, not by having 95-point econ plans. But we also can´t accept that we can never win again. I don´t see any more Obamas out there for 2016.
To borrow from a brilliant ad agency, "Here, Wego...."
Goethe was right: "He who does not have 3,000 years at his fingertips is living hand-to-mouth." So tell me, who better meets that test than VDH? Who?
But I am still Canute, and still Cassandra, as well as "veritas." I still hope to teach [to at least some] Canute´s lesson of the tide; and I am well-familiar with a disbelieving audience. But still I will serve Truth. Always.
Further, a rational mind will get past "loving the taste of his own tears;" will not use "the best as the enemy of the good;" and will work to get what can be had. Two important principles come to mind [though they have escaped the notice of many posters lately]: a. "Lead, follow, or get out of the way."; and b. "If you´re not part of the solution, you´re part of the problem." Well?
VDH´s Item 5 on Hispanics is the best I´ve read on the matter.
#1, #2: "Follow the principle, not the man, for the man will always disappoint." That´s wisdom, and it reminds why our Founding Principles matter like the blood in our veins. Re that quote, let´s evaluate what VDH offers, and not brickbat because a column´s not book-length-comprehensive.
Last, forget starting a 3rd party. Too expensive, wastes time we don´t have; but most importantly, it overlooks the fact that a 3rd party has been taking root with state-level Republicans. Look at what the guvs are doing now. ´K?
Ensign O´Toole, please don´t apologize for a second post - I look for your postings for a dose of common sense (that´s not so common these days!)
As far as learning from the election, it´s hard to spot a ray of hope when the majority of our country prefers to live in Idiocracy.
After the election, my students begged me to let them know who I voted for. I did and briefly told them that I´ve always voted Republican since I voted in my first election (former President Reagan) - whew, the hailstorm from that comment, one of my students told her parent, who complained to administration & nearly got me fired because I expressed my political views (she voted for BO, by the way).
Please forgive a second post. This is for those who admire Karl Rove. I have had lunch with the man. And I realized that he is a liar.
Afterward, I began to watch him on FOX with a new perspective. The face looks bland and innocent, but the words are weasel words. They can be taken more than one way, and they should be. The next time you hear him on Hannity, notice how he phrases things. He is not what he appears to be.
Reagan did best when he waded in and confronted those who did not like him.
Reagan understood the true meaning of turning the other cheek. When an aggressor throws the first punch it is with his strongest side. By turning the cheek the target places himself in a position to counter the follow up blow from the weaker side with his own strengths. When done in the best martial arts tradition the target can make a hulking aggressor look like a fool.
The left talks endlessly of compassion but the urban enclaves they have controlled for decades not only house the worst of the underclass but are spiraling into bankruptcy. Using that against them takes more than one speech before the NAACP.
#44, I believe you because I have a pal who is (actually was) assisting with W´s library at SMU. She has known Karl and his ex-wife casually for years. She told me this before W´s first term was over and I found it hard to believe. I believe it now. He does lie.
HOT SPRINGS, Ark.—On a recent late-fall Saturday, Barbara Deuschle, a local restaurant owner, was recounting her first impression of her congressman, Tom Cotton, who is now running for the Senate. It was back in August 2011, just before the young Republican lawmaker formally announced his first campaign for the House, and Cotton and his dad came to a party meeting to get to know the faithful. Cotton was a 34-year-old political unknown who had recently lived in Washington. "When he just parachuted down into this district, nobody ever heard of him," she recalls. "I said, ´Who are you? We´d never
WASHINGTON — Taxpayers can expect to get stuck with a more than $1 billion bill for the creation and repair of the federal ObamaCare Web site, a top House Republican warned. “The fact is, eventually they’ll get this Web site working at the cost of probably over a billion dollars,” House Oversight and Government Reform Committee Chairman Darrell Issa (Calif.) said on Fox News Channel. The Obama administration did not respond to The Post’s questions Thursday about the tab for the round-the-clock “tech surge” deployed in mid-October to repair HealthCare.gov. The cost of building the bug-ridden site, which launched Oct.
On the list of scandals that plagued the Obama administration this past year, Benghazi has been the one the White House, Democrats, and their cheerleaders in the mainstream media dismissed with the greatest of ease. Unlike the IRS scandal, which though it has faded from the news had obvious constitutional and political implications, or the various spying scandals involving news organizations and the National Security Agency, which outraged large numbers of ordinary Americans, Benghazi was put down as a manufactured story that had little traction. Part of it was due to the obsessive, though understandable, focus of Republicans on the
No disrespect to Macaulay Culkin (#ALLDISRESPECTTOTHEPIGEONLADY), but we prefer The Pet Collective´s retelling of Home Alone to the original movie. Mostly because Kevin McCallister is now played by an adorable pug puppy. And if a pug puppy setting booby traps for teddy bear burglars isn´t adorable enough for you, the video also narrated by a small child. So forget Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer. Forget Elf. This is the only Christmas movie you need to watch this year. (Snip for video)As you might suspect, the pug, named Jackson Rosa, could not be more over it...
I’m not sure what Chris Matthews was doing with President Obama yesterday, but it wasn’t hardball. It wasn’t even softball. It was more like wiffle ball. Everyone knew going in that the MSNBC host would be a sympathetic interviewer. But he knew he would be graded on his aggressiveness, so I expected at least a few fastballs. Uh uh. Instead, in a half-hour sitdown, there was one challenging question. Just one. It was as though Matthews was channeling Jay Carney. Matthews is a likable guy with a passion for politics, but he left his interviewing chops at the door. The
WASHINGTON — Sen. Ted Cruz, elected 13 months ago by actual voters, said Thursday he’d prefer to see state legislators pick U.S. senators – as they were until a century ago, when the 17th Amendment came along. Direct election of senators has eroded states’ rights, Cruz argued, speaking to a ballroom filled with conservative state lawmakers from around the country. “If you have the ability to hire and fire me,” he said, “I’m a lot less likely to break into your house and steal your television. So there’s no doubt that was a major step toward the explosion of federal power and
I´m sitting at my desk, looking at a photograph of a gangrenous foot. It is a bloated thing in hues of phlegmatic gray rot, sanguine inflammation, melancholic black bile, and choleric open sores — exhibiting all the humors of a meeting of the United Nations Human Rights Council. Above the photograph, in bold white capitals on a dull, matte background are the words “smoking causes peripheral vascular disease.” The photograph is helpfully labeled “gangrene.” Below the photograph, in a bland sans-serif typeface with letters an eighth of an inch high, is “Marlboro Red.” This is a pack of Australian cigarettes,
Come January, when some number of Americans have bought insurance on the new health exchanges and are starting to use the services, you can expect another controversy to arise when many of them find out just how few doctors and hospitals they have access to. Call it “doc shock,” though the biggest outcry will not come when people try to schedule an appointment with their physician, but when someone gets sick and they learn they cannot go to whatever top-notch hospital they want, only to the hospital that is included in their plan. The problem varies across the country. In Washington,
Last month in San Francisco, President Obama called on Congress to enact comprehensive immigration reform. His speech was novel in many respects: The president used the backdrop of a community center in Chinatown to remind voters that immigrants are racially diverse. Also, for the first time in prepared remarks, the president signaled that he would consider a piecemeal approach to immigration reform long favored by Republican leaders in the House of Representatives. What got the most attention, however, was an unscripted exchange between Obama and Ju Hong, an undocumented UC Berkeley graduate who interrupted the president, calling on him to use
No matter how you spell it, ice is a four letter word Friday. Just ask folks living anywhere from Texas to Tennessee. Those areas are in the bulls eye of a treacherous ice storm, threatening to coat everything in its path with up to an inch of frozen water. Ice is slippery, but also heavy. It tends to bring down tree limbs and power lines when accumulations get thick. In Tennessee, Memphis Light, Gas and Water has 426,000 customers and is ready for the worst. "MLGW employees have been monitoring this winter storm situation and we have all of our
U.S. authorities have charged 49 Russian diplomats and their spouses with conspiracy to commit healthcare fraud, alleging that they stole $1.5 million from the American government via a years-long Medicaid scam. According to a criminal complaint made public today, the former and current diplomats lied about their income and citizenship status in order to qualify for the health benefits, which they used towards pregnancy care, births, and post-natal medical needs. They were also charged with conspiracy to steal government funds and make false statements relating to health care matters, reports the Associated Press. The complaint notes that medical costs associated with
Seduced and then disappointed by a hipster who turned out just to be another solipsistic boomer, now chastened yet still hopeful for change (if no longer swept away by the promise of Hope and Change), young Americans are ready to ditch Barack Obama. Things had been getting rocky for a while, but seeing the dawning of the Age of Obamacare in its full glory seems to have been the final indignity. The young will of course never acknowledge that maybe their old-fogey parents were right all along, but they do understand that what they thought was going to be a
I have never been much of a conspiracy theorist. For me it was always Oswald by himself from the Texas School Book Depository and nothing in the intervening fifty years has disabused me of this notion. For the most part, I’m an Occam’s Razor kind of guy — the most obvious explanation is likely to be true. (Snip) To put it bluntly, Occam’s Razor has moved. Things that were once possibilities now seem almost certainties to me. Principal among those is that Obama’s academic records are perpetually unavailable for a reason — and that reason is most likely that they reveal
One of President Obama´s chief political assets has been his ability to excite young people like almost no politician in history. But the days of America´s youth fawning over the president are over. A new Harvard University Institute of Politics poll released Wednesday confirms what other surveys have shown in recent months: Millennials have soured on Obama so much this year that their opinion of him largely mirrors the American public´s. Even though Obama does not ever have to face another election, he should be worried about the findings for a couple of reasons, which we will dive into momentarily.
Last summer on his $100 million family tour of Africa, Barack Obama hoped for a priceless photo op with Nelson Mandela, the ailing freedom pioneer who went from prison cell to the presidency of South Africa. Mandela´s family suggested that wouldn’t happen. So, the Obamas did a photo op in Mandela´s former prison cell. Which Obama’s White House quickly tweeted upon word of the icon´s passing at 95. [Skip] But Obama was also caught staring at television coverage of Mandela’s passing, which became Obama’s Photo of the Day.
Hardly a week goes by without Hillary Clinton receiving another award. Last month she was named a “Global Champion” by the International Medical Corps, received the American Patriot Award at the National Defense University Foundation and the Hermandad Award from the Mexican American Leadership Initiative. [Snip] At this rate, if a bunch of elderly left-wing Swedes toss her the Nobel Peace Prize early on, the way they did to Obama, it will barely rate mention among all the other glittering trophies that have been bestowed on a woman whose only actual accomplishment was being married to a crooked governor with
A stunning new study unveiled on Fox News´ Hannity finds that President Barack Obama’s White House calendar records just one face-to-face meeting between Obama and his Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Kathleen Sebelius in the more than three-and-a-half years leading up to the disastrous Obamacare launch. The startling statistic comes from a new Government Accountability Institute (GAI) analysis of Obama’s own official White House calendar, as well as the Politico presidential calendar, and raises new questions about Obama’s executive leadership and management throughout the implementation of his singular legislative achievement. More alarming still, the president’s schedule lists 277 private
Speaker John Boehner said his party should support gay Republican congressional candidates and urged his colleagues to “be a little more sensitive” when running against women. “Some of our members just aren’t as sensitive as they ought to be,” Boehner said. When asked if he thinks his party should support gay candidates, Boehner simply said: “I do.”
In February, the Bush family’s personal emails were hacked by Guccifer, a hacker who uncovered photographs of former President George H. W. Bush in a hospital bed and George W. Bush’s oil paintings in the process. It seems Guccifer has struck again, this time targeting former President Bill Clinton and the Clinton Library. The hacker has reportedly uncovered doodles of Clinton drawing on what were, at the time, classified documents. Among the doodles is apparently a picture of a penis. The document uncovered is a briefing of the strategic measures the United States could take prior Clinton’s decision to intervene in
Amid an array of “knock-out” attacks against a number of Jews in Brooklyn’s Crown Heights neighborhood, a city councilwoman pointed to the success of the Jewish community as triggering the aggression. Councilwoman-elect Laurie Cumbo emphasized that while she “admire[s] the Jewish community immensely” for its work ethic, black teens may see it differently. “While I personally regard this level of tenacity, I also recognize that for others, the accomplishments of the Jewish community triggers feelings of resentment, and a sense that Jewish success is not also their success,” Cumbo, who was recently elected, wrote in a letter. Chief among the issues
On Tuesday, The Boston Globe reported that Onyango “Omar” Obama, uncle to President Obama, says that his famous nephew stayed with him while a student at Harvard Law School in the 80s, in contradiction to The White House’s contention that the two had never met. At Thursday’s White House daily briefing, Press Secretary Jay Carney confirmed that the President had, in fact, briefly stayed with “his father’s half-brother,” as Carney described Omar Obama, and that no one had actually asked the President about it when the White House initially commented. The 69 year-old Omar Obama has been facing deportation back
The world premiere of the “Ballad for Trayvon Martin for Orchestra and Jazz Quartet” is set for tonight. Princeton University’s director of its jazz-studies program composed the work in honor of the Florida teen. Anthony D. J. Branker told the Star-Ledger that the piece is intended to “be a form of healing” after Martin’s death and the controversial court case that followed it. The ballad, which will be performed by the university’s official orchestra and jazz ensemble, is intended to be a tribute to victims of racial violence, Branker explained. He hopes that the performance will be “one that speaks to
WASHINGTON – A fourth straight month of solid hiring cut the U.S. unemployment rate to a five-year low of 7 percent in November, an encouraging sign for the economy. The Labor Department says employers added 203,000 jobs, nearly matching October´s revised gain of 200,000. The job gains helped lower the unemployment rate from 7.3 percent in October. The strengthening job market is likely to fuel speculation that the Federal Reserve may start to scale back its bond purchases when it meets later this month. The economy has now generated an average of 204,000 jobs from August through November. That´s up
WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama has high praise for potential 2016 contenders Vice President Joe Biden and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. “I think Joe Biden will go down in history as one of the best vice presidents ever, and he has been with me, at my side, in every tough decision that I’ve made,” Obama told MSNBC in an interview Thursday held at American University. “Hillary, I think, will go down in history as one of the finest secretaries of state we’ve ever had, and helped to transition us away from a deep hole that we were in,