Less than 24 hours after meeting with German Chancellor Angela Merkel, President Donald Trump took to Twitter to criticize Germany for not keeping up with its defense payments to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and the United States. “Despite what you have heard from the FAKE NEWS, I had a GREAT meeting with German Chancellor Angela Merkel,” Trump wrote in a tweet March 18. “Nevertheless, Germany owes vast sums of money to NATO & the United States must be paid more for the powerful, and very expensive, defense it provides to Germany!” Trump has repeatedly called on NATO member countries to contribute
Why I wish that Trump would stop tweeting. The article is correct that Germany is not spending the required amount on defense and thus shirking responsibilities but they do not pay directly for US forces. They do pay indirectly in letting us have bases in Germany and in various other ways. The United States military is not a mercenary force. As to how much Germany is paying to NATO and how much they are supposed to be paying (not their defense budget but the Nato budget) I don´t know.
If someone wants to really make an account, we are still owed money for saving Europe a SECOND time, and and then helping to pay for the damage done in rebuilding Europe after WW II.
IF we enter into an agreement like NATO, everyone has to help pay the bill.
When something like the United Nations is formed and we end up paying more than our part while others nations don´t do their part, it ends up being something where we spend a lot of money to help others and it becomes expected.
Whenever there this a crisis or disaster somewhere in the world, we are there to help. We still have a military presence in Germany, but it is shrinking.
Germany became an economic power because she was rebuilt. Merkel is sowing the seeds of destruction by allowing an invasion of people who do not want to be German citizens. They need us more than they know.
Germany agreed to spend 2% of its GDP on defense. It actually spends 1.19%. Most other European nations are similarly way below target, and have been for two decades. The is no legally binding contract enforcing 2%, but there is undoubtedly an agreed political statement of intent.
The base question is why should the US pay for the military defense of nations who don´t maintain their own forces? We are shielding them from aggression, while they are raking in the cash.
President Trump is of course right. And it´s far from just Germany that freeloads off (and profits from) American military protection and the American nuclear umbrella. Add to that the grudging unwillingness of much of Europe to side with the US on the War on Terror (shouts to convict W as a "war criminal" were loudest from Europe), and I´d say "vast sums" is pretty much accurate.
Trump´s tweets seem to be a constant problem. Many understand that he´s a businessman who just wants to get the bottom line out there and figures his people will straighten out his words for him, later if necessary...BUT... some wish that this very smart negotiator would learn that his words matter and he´d have a lot less resistance if his people did some tweet-tweaking prior to hitting submit.
I was stationed in Germany in the mid-90´s. As the US began to "draw down" after the Wall came down I remember a German asking me, "If the Americans leave who will protect us?" Most of the Western European countries didn´t have to pay for their own national defense b/c the US military was in Europe. They could spend all that extra money on socialist programs and lecture us on how great Socialism is.
Trump´s "constant tweeting" is only a problem to those who take everything he says literally. He is a grandiose NYC street brawler who frequently indulges in hyperbole. It´s his style, and I, personally, get a kick out of it. I always understand the point he is trying to communicate. It´s a new day, people. Get with the program, or you are going to be miserable for the next four years.
I like Mr. Trump´s tweets especially as I watch the hysterical blow back from the msm as they go scattering like roaches from the beam of a flashlight.
And for all of you doubters, consider the alternative. Can you imagine how disheartened and disgusted all of us would be had the "inevitable" HRC been elected? Think about the exponential govt. corruption and progressive/federal govt. expansion. OMG
Why is it so many people know better than the man in charge.
This play by play is not necessary to our existence and just muddies the water.
WAIT TIL THE END RESULT. listening to the MSM, and reacting to every detail is a fool´s errand. WE may have a right to know how the sausage is made, but we really don´t have a need to know the process inside and out.
This is really simple and NEVER addressed; and the reason why so many nations can be socialist yet continue to afford their free handouts in spite of their extend and pretend debts; WE provide the free world´s national security, period. The EU, Canada, Japan, India, Australia pay almost nothing in comparison to us and WE provide for their defense, PERIOD (Total dollars spent per nation is more realistic and accurate than spending percentage of GDP, btw). Free health care in Canada and most EU nations and it´s supposedly great? They have NO defense bills relative to the USA because WE defend them and we have been doing so since WW2, PERIOD. It´s something our Marxists ignore when they compare us to the "great socialist nations of the EU" where the government provides everything for "free" and therefore so should we. Need proof?
Germany and the fact-checkers are once again splitting hairs over President Trump’s rhetoric. The truth is that they, like the other members, are not paying their share, a share that was set forth and agreed to by all of them.
Here is an article just posted that they and everyone else need to read carefully.
From the article, "NATO, formally the North Atlantic Treaty Organization…" Formally? Currently. While not all the countries in it are North Atlantic nations, the name has never been officially changed. Based on that egregious gaffe, I don´t think I will be taking this reporter´s word for it.
#2 If you look at the entire expense that Germany benefits, they do owe us a lot of money. We don´t necessarily need the bases in Germany. They could be elsewhere at an tremendous savings to the US. Trump knows what he´s saying. He hasn´t been wrong yet.
It is very, very simple math. Germany has been paying less than their agreed 2%, only a bit more than half, actually, so they are shirking and they owe NATO billions. Perhaps not actually to the USA, but to NATO - via their own military.
Germany is a highly developed and rich country that would be nowhere near where it is today in economic terms if it were not for the USA, the Marshal Plan, and the large numbers of American troops who have been stationed in Germany since the after the Second World War to defend Germany. There is no question that Germany should ante up their annual 2% of GNP for defense, and also pay the freight for all American troops stationed in Germany to defend that country.
The image of NATO as some sort of shared wall surrounding the membership is fallacious, as there is no tangible structure defending against their shared threats. So there isn´t some sort of thing that is provided and needs to be paid for, for which a member´s share can be quantified and billed. The missile defense shield that is often proposed and debated would be one, if it were ever actually implemented.
But members keeping up their own defenses IS that "wall", and a weak country represents a weak spot in that "wall", which compromises the security of that country and makes her neighbors more vulnerable to flank attacks. Itemizing what is missing due to that shortfall seems like it would require a much larger shared bureaucracy than is present or desired. That´s where other members of NATO have shirked; but that doesn´t really seem quantifiable for the purpose of monetary compensation.
Excuse me but Germany was supposed to spend $77 billion a year helping NATO (by spending that amount on its military) but Germany only spends $48 billion a year. That´s $29 BILLION less --- PER YEAR! Work that out since 9/11 and you get a $464 billion shortfall.
Every bullet fired by NATO, every gallon of gas, every gun, every uniform and every gallon of paint is supposed to be shared on a pro rata basis. Germany has been coming up short for decades and enjoying the free ride and protection from Uncle Sap.
Pay up, Angela, instead of giving welfare to people trying to slit your people´s throats!
I read the entire Daily Beast article. And when I got down to the end, I agreed, Germany does owe money. If they are supposed to pay 2 percent of their GDP to NATO and Merkel pays less than that, whether it´s 1.5 percent or less, and for how long have they been shorting the fund, then guess what folks as usual Trump is 100 percent correct. Germany needs to pay up, now.
Just to put a finer point on this discussion, I would remind you all that "The Government" has NO money of its´ own. Those billions are monies the citizens of America earn by working for it, for the most part. The US citizens are paying unholy tons of money to "defend" the freedom of other countries while piling up trillions!!! of debt here.
Speaking to workers and business people in Italy’s port city of Genoa Saturday, Pope Francis surprised his hearers by praising entrepreneurship and touting the importance of healthy businesses for the economy. “There can’t be a good economy without good businessmen, without their capacity to create and to produce,” he said, shattering his reputation as an enemy of the free market economy. The Pope met with “representatives of the world of work,” including businessmen, workers and unemployed persons at the Ilva steel plant in Genoa Saturday, fielding their questions and reflecting with them on a Christian view of the economy. The
Washington-Then-FBI Director James Comey knew that a critical piece of information relating to the investigation into Hillary Clinton´s email was fake -- created by Russian intelligence -- but he feared that if it became public it would undermine the probe and the Justice Department itself, according to multiple officials with knowledge of the process. As a result, Comey acted unilaterally last summer to publicly declare the investigation over -- without consulting then-Attorney General Loretta Lynch -- while at the same time stating that Clinton had been "extremely careless" in her handling of classified information. His press conference caused a firestorm of
A shocking report from Circa.com revealed on Friday that the FBI under director James Comey “illegally shared raw intelligence about Americans with unauthorized third parties and violated other constitutional privacy protections, according to newly declassified government documents.” That’s a bombshell charge — Comey told Congress earlier this month that the FBI only used warrantless data that was “lawfully collected, carefully overseen and checked” — but the specifics are even more damning.
There´s a glaring political divide in the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals decision to stop President Trump´s revised executive order limiting entry into the U.S. for some people from a few terror-plagued Muslim-majority nations. The court ruled against the president by a solid 10 to 3 vote. All ten on the winning side were appointed by Presidents Barack Obama or Bill Clinton. All three on the losing side were appointed by Presidents George W. Bush or George H.W. Bush. If anything, the decision shows the value of a two-term presidency in shaping the courts. The4th Circuit, once solidly conservative, is conservative
Jared Kushner, the president´s son-in-law and one of his senior advisers, has come under FBI scrutiny in the Russia investigation, multiple U.S. officials told NBC News. Investigators believe Kushner has significant information relevant to their inquiry, officials said. That does not mean they suspect him of a crime or intend to charge him.
After the Manchester bombing, can President Trump keep saying America has “no role” to play in Libya? Libya keeps popping up in the investigation into the attack by British suicide bomber Salman Abedi, who killed at least 22 people and injured 59 at an Ariana Grande concert Monday night. Abedi spent the last three weeks of his life in Libya, his father’s birthplace, before returning to his native Manchester. As Britain’s security forces dig deeper into Abedi’s ISIS connections, making additional arrests in England and Libya, one thing is clear: The country we helped rid of dictator Moammar Khadafy is a mess
There is already enough evidence in the Seth Rich murder case to warrant a special government investigation. Now this – T. A. Frank is a relatively unknown liberal nutjob contributor to Vanity Fair magazine until now. He wrote a piece in January of 2016 published in Vanity Fair that appears more than sinister to many following the Seth Rich murder investigation. Frank begins his article as follows: For the second time in eight years, Hillary Clinton sees the Democratic nomination being pawed by a charming interloper, like a priceless vase grabbed by a panda. She’d prefer to shoot the panda,
A free-thinking group of eighth grades refused to pose with House Speaker Paul Ryan during a field trip to Washington DC on Thursday. Half of the students from South Orange Middle School in New Jersey stood on the other side of the street as their classmates had their photo taken with Ryan outside the United States Capitol. When he uploaded the image to Instagram, the ones who had refused to be in it flooded the comments section with insults and complaints. ´Half of us stood across the street including me because we hate you,´ said one. Another spoke to DailyMail.com
Earth is likely to reach more dangerous levels of warming even sooner if the U.S. retreats from its pledge to cut carbon dioxide pollution, scientists said. That’s because America contributes so much to rising temperatures. President Donald Trump, who once proclaimed global warming a Chinese hoax, said in a tweet Saturday that he would make his “final decision” this coming week on whether the United States stays in or leaves the 2015 Paris climate change accord in which nearly every nation agreed to curb its greenhouse gas emissions. Leaders of seven wealthy democracies, at a summit in Sicily, urged Trump
After entering the White House in 2009, President Barack Obama went on his famous “apology” tour. Now, Hillary Clinton, having failed to win the White House in 2016, is currently on an “I’m owed an apology” tour. In an interview for an article by New York Magazine published Friday, Clinton has apparently moved past “gracious Hillary” and “relaxed in the woods Hillary” and has now moved into “angry Hillary” mode. (Snip) In the New York Magazine article, called “Hillary Clinton Is Furious. And Resigned. And Funny. And Worried,” the predominant mood is the fury — not the resignation, worry, or her
Angela Merkel has stunningly claimed Europe can no longer rely on the US, just one day Donald Trump frustrated world leaders at the G7 meeting in Italy. The German Chancellor urged the European Union to stick together in the face of new uncertainty stemming from the US and other challenges. Merkel said Sunday at a campaign event in Bavaria: ´The times in which we can fully count on others are somewhat over, as I have experienced in the past few days.´ The comments came after the G7 countries were unable to agree to a deal that would see the 2015
(Video) Sunday on MSNBC’s “AM Joy,” Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA) said the public was “getting weary” that Democrats have not done enough to begin the process of impeaching President Donald Trump. Partial transcript as follows: REID: Congresswoman, on the subject of being more aggressive, you have openly talked about the fact that this president has put himself in a position where impeachment is on the table but your party, the Democratic party is very reluctant, The New York Times has an article out last week about how hesitant Democratic leadership, in particular, are to call for Donald Trump’s impeachment. In
Tiger Woods was arrested and charged with DUI in Jupiter, Fla., records show. The professional golfer, 41, was nabbed around 3 a.m. Monday on Military Trail just south of Indian Creek Parkway, according to WPBF 25 News. He was released under his own recognizance at 10:50 a.m., Palm Beach County Sheriff´s Office records show.
Hillary Clinton’s inner circle is concerned that the “resistance” that cropped up in the wake of President Donald Trump’s electoral win isn’t embracing the failed Democratic Presidential candidate as their de facto leader. As of late, Hillary has taken to marketing herself as the leader of the anti-Trump resistance, Tweeting about her defeat, haranguing Trump in public appearances and “persisting” despite her loss. It’s clear from Clinton’s Twitter feed, paid speeches, and comments that she wants to lead the mostly female opposition to Trump’s policy agenda. But according to sources close to Clinton’s inner circle, she’s yet again failing in