A Message From Lucianne  







S-G1




























ST-GC



        
 

 
Home Page | Latest Posts | Links | Must Reads | Update Profile | RSS | Contribute | Register | Rules & FAQs
Privacy Policy | Search | Post | Contact | Logout | Forgot Password | Search Using Google


  Topic: Pa. Homeowner Sues Seller
Over Home´s Bloody Past
Change your user profile.
If you are having trouble posting, please take the time to register.
Your User Name :
Your Password
  I forgot my password
Your Reply  :
Preview Reply     Post Reply
Pa. Homeowner Sues Seller
Over Home´s Bloody Past

ABC News, by Susanna Kim

Original Article

Posted By:NorthernDog, 1/28/2013 7:16:14 PM

A Pennsylvania woman has appealed to the state Supreme Court in her suit against a home seller and real estate agent who failed to disclose that a murder-suicide had taken place in the home she purchased. When Janet Milliken, 59, moved from California after her husband died, she had hoped to start a new life with her two teenage children in Pennsylvania near her family. She bought a home in Thornton, Pa., for $610,000 in June 2007. She learned a few weeks after she moved in from a next-door neighbor that a murder-suicide had occurred the year before

Comments:
She could have claimed it was haunted a la The Amityville Horror.

      


Post Reply  

Reply 1 - Posted by: schnapps, 1/28/2013 7:23:00 PM     (No. 9145138)

When she sold her home in CA did she tell the buyer that her husband had died there?
Just askin´...

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 2 - Posted by: strike3, 1/28/2013 7:27:35 PM     (No. 9145149)

Sorry honey but I don´t think "Ghosts" is a line item on the defect disclosure list.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


   

 

R-G1
  
R-VAR_AD


 
Reply 3 - Posted by: 4Justice, 1/28/2013 7:31:22 PM     (No. 9145152)

#1, the story said the woman´s husband died--not that he died in the house.

I think a home seller should disclose if there was a murder and/or suicide in a house prior to selling it. I also think that it should be disclosed it the home used to be a meth lab!

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 4 - Posted by: Cor-vet, 1/28/2013 7:37:09 PM     (No. 9145162)

At this point, what difference does it make?

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 5 - Posted by: zoidberg, 1/28/2013 7:37:54 PM     (No. 9145163)

I agree that disclosure is needed if the house was used as a meth lab because of the possible presence of toxic chemicals. But murder or suicide, no.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 6 - Posted by: KTWO, 1/28/2013 7:41:14 PM     (No. 9145169)

Sounds like she got hit by declining RE values and wants a fix. But maybe that is too harsh.

Or maybe not. There are good reasons why RE transfers, such as sales, are done with signed and witnessed documents.

If you want the sellers knowledge about the house you can ask for it in writing. In some states the disclosure documents are detailed and thorough. In Pa. they apparently are not.

w/o evidence of deception I Have to go with the existing law and the defendants.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 7 - Posted by: crimea river, 1/28/2013 7:50:05 PM     (No. 9145181)

I think #6 has drilled down to the truth. Buyer´s remorse - and it´s less about the spooker than the lucre.


  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


   

 

  


 
Reply 8 - Posted by: earlybird, 1/28/2013 7:50:22 PM     (No. 9145183)

The seller is liable for disclosure. In California a death in the home within three years prior (with certain exceptions) must be disclosed. Apparently that is not the case in Pennsylvania.

She has lived in this rather lovely-looking home for six years, most of which has been spent in litigation. What a waste of six years.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 9 - Posted by: get er done, 1/28/2013 7:59:10 PM     (No. 9145199)

Will this case motivate home buyers to ask if anyone has died (or been murdered) in a home they intend to purchase? If a home is very old, it is more likely that a previous owner/resident died within the home, as people tended to die at home in their beds in the old days. Women also gave birth at home, and some died in childbirth. Newborns occasionally died in or soon after childbirth.





  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 10 - Posted by: Bad Dog, 1/28/2013 7:59:20 PM     (No. 9145200)

Mock me if you feel the need, but if I feel the bad juju, I ask. Why didn´t she just ask about it if she´s so sensitive to it?

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 11 - Posted by: 3XALADY, 1/28/2013 8:04:32 PM     (No. 9145207)

In the 80´s my daughter became friends with a kid who had just moved to our town from CA. We were discussing home values in Missouri vs. California and he said they were only paying $600 a month for an apartment before they moved because someone was murdered in the bathtub. I probably couldn´t do something like that. We had to give our little dog a tranquilizer pill so we could take her to the vet to be put down and when I came back home, I had to remove the rug she had layed on when she went to sleep because I kept seeing her there in my mind´s eye.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 12 - Posted by: Susannah, 1/28/2013 8:13:18 PM     (No. 9145218)

Some states require that the seller disclose if the house is alleged to be haunted. The first--and to date, only--house I ever bought was 125 years old at the time of purchase. (They don´t build them like that anymore.) I assume, given its age, that people died in the house, may have been laid out in what they would have called the parlor, and were born in the house. So? It´s life. It´s history.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


   

 

B-G1


 
Reply 13 - Posted by: pearlyjo, 1/28/2013 8:19:20 PM     (No. 9145224)

Several months after I bought my house in 1997 one of my neighbors informed me that the previous owner had shot himself in the house. I don´t remember even wondering about such a thing happening in the house when I was sealing the deal. It was an elderly couple who had lived there and I understand the husband was quite ill and could no longer garden and move about, so he took his life. Anyway, a realtor friend told me in our state it was up to me to ask and then the seller would have to reveal the information, otherwise, caveat emptor regined.
I never felt any bad juju until the day I began redoing the basement which had been this old man´s favorite place. As I was scraping paint off of the stairwell, a can of soup fell from a shelf in the pantry and made its way down the stairs toward me. Kinda wierd. No reason for the can Never felt anything after that. Was he pleased with the redo or not?

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 14 - Posted by: bcvegas, 1/28/2013 8:22:23 PM     (No. 9145227)

In California, it must be disclosed at the time of listing if someone has died in the house. But believe it or not, they have an exemption if someone died in the house due to AIDS. I´m not making it up.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 15 - Posted by: MisterDickens, 1/28/2013 8:23:45 PM     (No. 9145229)

Make it a part of the contract. "Seller confirms that no murders or suicides have occurred in the home and agrees to return buyer´s money if seller has lied". Or something like that.

I wouldn´t buy a house if I knew such a thing had occurred there and I´ll bet most of the posters criticizing the woman wouldn´t either. I´m not superstitious, it´s just a bit creepy.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 16 - Posted by: Lala, 1/28/2013 8:35:16 PM     (No. 9145235)

It might be required in California but I am pretty sure that it is not a required disclosure by a seller under Pennsylvania law. She could have engaged her own buyers´ agent and directed him to research the history of the house and perhaps discovered what happened there, if its something she was concerned about. But if she did not ask, I don´t think the seller is obligated to tell her. I wouldn´t want to live in a house with that history, but she could have done some due diligence.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 17 - Posted by: SoCalGal, 1/28/2013 8:40:09 PM     (No. 9145243)

Re #14, in California a death in the house must only be disclosed by the seller if the death occurred within the previous three years.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


   

 

R_DBL_B
  


 
Reply 18 - Posted by: chumley, 1/28/2013 8:51:31 PM     (No. 9145259)

If the objection is of a spiritual nature, I believe most faiths have a way of sending a bad mojo on its way. Usually it is a blessing of some kind on the house, combined with something spirits find distasteful (like burning sage). It can get very elaborate sometimes but usually works.
I bet if she found a local clergy type they would be willing to help her with that.


  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 19 - Posted by: ColonialAmerican1623, 1/28/2013 9:16:54 PM     (No. 9145284)

After reading the entire story, I am with her. The couple she bought it from had bought it six months after the event and flipped it making a good profit.

When I bought my house some things weren´t disclosed that cost me a lot of money. The quetions were on the form and the person lied.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 20 - Posted by: thelmalou, 1/28/2013 10:10:38 PM     (No. 9145348)

Under Georgia´s stimatized property law, the seller is not obligated to disclose such an event, UNLESS the buyer asks, and then they are required to tell the truth. Article states that Pennsylvania law does not demand disclosure. Why is she still fighting this after the appeals court ruled against her? At this point, her lawyer is the one making money here, not her.



  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 21 - Posted by: GardenGal, 1/28/2013 10:14:34 PM     (No. 9145356)

Look, the woman did not do any research. She could have found out on the internet that the home had only been owned for a very short time and that would have led to her questioning why the price rose so much. At least then she wouldn´t have overpaid. But that was on her. PA doesn´t require such disclosures and a court shouldn´t add requirements to the law that aren´t there.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 22 - Posted by: coldoc, 1/28/2013 10:17:20 PM     (No. 9145360)

I was raised in an old NY house that had a history of one spouse shooting the other. The patched bullet holes were judged "really neat" by my high school buddies. Get a life, lady. You should have stayed in Kalifornia.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


   

 



 
Reply 23 - Posted by: manitouman, 1/28/2013 10:18:02 PM     (No. 9145363)

Just imagine if the house had been owned by a republican?! Surely a reportable condition in every state.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 24 - Posted by: anonymous, 1/28/2013 10:20:19 PM     (No. 9145365)

People die in houses all the time from natural causes. However, when it´s not a natural cause, I think the buyer is entitled to know what went on there. It should be disclosed by the seller or his agent. Therefore, I´m on the side of Janet here.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 25 - Posted by: shalimar, 1/28/2013 11:44:28 PM     (No. 9145447)

Government is increasingly involved in every nook and cranny of our lives. Real estate transactions are already ridiculously complicated, the last thing we need is more mandates.

If someone wants to know about an address, how about running it [and previous owners names] through a search engine.



  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 26 - Posted by: Chuzzles, 1/29/2013 12:18:04 AM     (No. 9145478)

When hubby and I were househunting last year, while we were looking at a possible home, a neighbor chatted with my hubby. Based on what neighbor said, hubby then checked the police records in that community for the past 10 years. Turns out that not only had a murder-suicide happened there, but the house was also a drug house. Needless to say, we did not buy. I can understand this lady. Based on my own experiences, I would not want to live in a house where recent incidents like that happened.

When money is involved, sellers and agents both have agendas that aren´t in the buyers best interest. Always Always Always do your research. You might get a big surprise if you don´t.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 27 - Posted by: darthmuaddib, 1/29/2013 4:42:41 AM     (No. 9145568)

To poster #4, I got it. Brilliant!

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 28 - Posted by: zeldafitzg, 1/29/2013 5:58:21 AM     (No. 9145612)

In Texas, the seller must disclose. It is not up to the buyer to ask.

She is not complaining because the house might be "haunted," but rather because the perception of the house by others is affected, and this damages her property value.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment


Reply 29 - Posted by: Dixie, 1/29/2013 10:53:12 AM     (No. 9146261)

How sissyfied is this country going to get before people find enough courage to cope with the ups and downs of Real Life?

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 30 - Posted by: 4poster, 1/29/2013 12:31:51 PM     (No. 9146505)

Janet is from California. My experience with Californians is they sue. A chance to win the lottery.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.



Post Reply   Close thread 721017




Below, you will find ...

Most Recent Articles posted by "NorthernDog"

and

Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)




Most Recent Articles posted by "NorthernDog"



IRS fining business on
taxes that were never due
WKMG-TV [Orlando, FL], by Lauren Sweeney    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 4/15/2014 6:22:19 PM     Post Reply
ALTAMONTE SPRINGS, Fla. - Innovative Title Services, Inc., a real estate title services company established in 2003, faces a tax penalty that could virtually shut down the small business. According to the company´s President, Michael Day, the nearly $20,000 late fee is being assessed on taxes that were never due in the first place. Day and his accountant have been appealing the penalty for nearly a year which is due on April 15. (Snip) "I´m hiring people, wanting to hire people paying unemployment taxes paying payroll taxes and I really don´t understand why they would like to impose such a

What I learned as a liberal
talking head on Fox News
Christian Science Monitor, by Sally Kohn    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 4/15/2014 2:28:47 PM     Post Reply
New York - In the fall of 2013, I gave a TED talk on what I learned as a progressive, on-air talking head at Fox News, where I worked for two years before leaving and joining my current home, CNN. After all, one of the most frequent questions I was asked during my time at Fox was how I did it, how I was a fox in the henhouse – or a hen in the Fox house, if you will. (Snip) For a radical progressive who once harbored negative stereotypes about folks on the right, it was a turning point

N. Korea officials ´target
London salon over Kim haircut ad´
Agence France-Presse, by Staff    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 4/15/2014 1:16:08 PM     Post Reply
London - British police said Tuesday they had intervened after North Korean embassy officials reportedly told a London hairdresser to take down a discount haircuts advert featuring leader Kim Jong-Un. Mo Nabbach said two officials identifying themselves as being from the Stalinist state´s mission took pictures of his M&M Hair Academy in Ealing, west London. They then demanded to know his name and ordered him to remove the "disrespectful" poster from the salon window, he told the Evening Standard newspaper. The poster featured a large picture of Kim´s distinctive short-back-and-sides hairdo with the slogan: "Bad hair day? 15 percent off

Fur flies as US gets
to grips with feral cats
Agence France-Presse, by Robert Macpherson    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 4/14/2014 1:47:09 PM     Post Reply
Washington - It´s Friday night in Eckington, a quiet residential corner of Washington, and the back alley is crawling with feral cats -- rich pickings for seasoned cat-trapper Marty King. "Here, kitty kitty kitty kitty," said King after setting four metal traps baited with flaked shrimp and fish cat food and lined with fresh newspapers. (Snip) Coast to coast, the Humane Society of the United States estimates there are as many as 50 million feral cats, or "community cats" as their advocates prefer to call them. That compares to 95.6 million cats kept as pets. For decades, standard procedure has

Melissa Harris-Perry: Eric Holder Is
the ‘Obama We Had Been Hoping For’
Mediaite, by Matt Wilstein    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 4/12/2014 3:45:41 PM     Post Reply
After remarks he made at the National Action Network conference this week and various actions on voting rights and equality he’s taken over the past several months, MSNBC’s Melissa Harris-Perry is starting to wonder if Attorney General Eric Holder is “the Obama we had been hoping for.” Even though she admitted it’s not entirely fair to “separate” Holder from President Barack Obama, that’s the question the host posed to her panel Saturday morning. “I think he may be the greatest addition to the entire Obama Administration,” Fordham University’s Christina Greer told Harris-Perry, saying the “foundational work”

Ukraine prepares armed response
as city seized by pro-Russia forces
Reuters, by Pavel Polityuk and Thomas Grove    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 4/12/2014 3:29:19 PM     Post Reply
KIEV/MOSCOW - Armed separatists took virtual control of a city in eastern Ukraine on Saturday and Kiev prepared troops to deal with what it called an "act of aggression by Russia". Pro-Russian activists carrying automatic weapons seized government buildings in Slaviansk and set up barricades on the outskirts of the city. Official buildings in several neighboring towns were also attacked. The developments have increased concerns of a possible "gas war" that could disrupt energy supplies across the continent. "The Ukrainian authorities consider the events of the day as a display of external aggression from Russia,"

Women´s clothing retailer
Coldwater Creek to close its doors
Star Tribune [Minneapolis, MN], by Jackie Crosby    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 4/12/2014 9:53:07 AM     Post Reply
Women’s specialty clothing chain Coldwater Creek filed for bankruptcy on Friday and said it will close all of its stores around the country, including 11 in Minnesota. The Sandpoint, Idaho-based company plans to time its liquidation sales to coincide with the traditionally busy Mother’s Day weekend. Coldwater Creek is the latest retailer to seek protection from creditors as consumers continue to manage their household budgets tightly and hold back on discretionary spending. Others to file for bankruptcy include discount chain Loehmann’s, trendy retailer Dots and the plus-sized Ashley Stewart Holdings. Coldwater Creek announced plans to seek strategic alternatives in October,



Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)



Ben Carson: White House wanted
apology for ‘offending’ Obama

54 replie(s)
Daily Caller, by Alex Pappas    Original Article
Posted By: StormCnter- 4/15/2014 5:22:51 AM     Post Reply
Neurosurgeon Ben Carson says the White House wanted him to apologize for “offending” President Obama after he famously delivered a conservative message at the National Prayer Breakfast last year. Carson, the former director of pediatric neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins Hospital, recalls the events surrounding his 2013 speech in his new book, One Nation: What We Can All Do To Save America’s Future. The Daily Caller obtained an advance copy of the book, which is set for release May 20. “He did not appear to be hostile or angry,” Carson writes of Obama, “but within a matter of minutes after the conclusion of

Obama Generation Losing
Interest in Obama

46 replie(s)
Wall Street Journal, by James Freeman    Original Article
Posted By: Desert Fox- 4/14/2014 4:23:09 PM     Post Reply
President Obama inspired a generation of young people to support his historic election in 2008. And in 2012, despite the struggles of his first term, Mr. Obama still managed to win the support of a full 60% of voters age 18-29. But the man who once dreamed of being a transformative leader in the Reagan mold is inspiring few of those young people to follow his lead. "For all the talk about the movement that elected Mr. Obama, the more notable movement of Obama supporters has been away from politics. It appears that few of the young people who voted

Why You Should Be Sympathetic
Toward Cliven Bundy

44 replie(s)
Powerline, by John Hinderaker    Original Article
Posted By: Toledo- 4/15/2014 8:40:58 AM     Post Reply
On Saturday, I wrote about the standoff at Bundy Ranch. That post drew a remarkable amount of traffic, even though, as I wrote then, I had not quite decided what to make of the story. Since then, I have continued to study the facts and have drawn some conclusions. Here they are. First, it must be admitted that legally, Bundy doesn’t have a leg to stand on. The Bureau of Land Management has been charging him grazing fees since the early 1990s, which he has refused to pay. Further, BLM has issued orders limiting the area on which Bundy’s cows can

Megyn Kelly and the
Sandberg Head Shaker

38 replie(s)
American Thinker, by Richard F. Miniter    Original Article
Posted By: magnante- 4/15/2014 9:16:05 AM     Post Reply
Megyn Kelly’s "Kelly File" is a great news show. She’s incisive, informed and customarily handles the toughest guest with aplomb. But her lengthy interview of Facebook C.O.O. Sheryl Sandberg about her second book in the Lean In series Lean In: For Graduates was a head shaker. Amazing that she of all people allowed Sandberg to restring the same old, same old, shamed, and shopworn feminist myths about women and girls and then jangle it in front of her viewing audience like something new out of the box. Indeed Kelly all but genuflected in front of this woman. Kept her on thru

Chelsea Clinton no longer
ruling out politics

35 replie(s)
The Hill (Washington DC), by Judy Katz    Original Article
Posted By: JoniTx- 4/14/2014 11:57:36 AM     Post Reply
Chelsea Clinton says when people ask her these days whether she wants to go into politics, her answer isn’t an automatic “no.” The 34-year-old former first daughter told Fast Company in an interview published Monday, “for so long the answer was just a visceral no. Not because I had made any conscientious, deliberate decision, but since people had been asking for as long as literally I could remember, it was no." Now, the only child of former President Clinton and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton explains, "I live in a city and a state and a country where I

Glaring limits of the Civil Rights
Act: We need to redistribute wealth

34 replie(s)
Salon Magazine, by Matt Bruenig    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 4/14/2014 7:20:41 PM     Post Reply
Although the Civil Rights Act, the landmark legislation which just reached its 50th anniversary, made great strides in desegregating the economy, economic discrimination is still widespread, and anti-discrimination legislation alone can never rectify the economic damage inflicted upon blacks by slavery and our Jim Crow apartheid regime. The Civil Rights Act was a mild reform, all things considered, but one conservatives fought with vigor and one many conservatives are still bitter about to this day. When the Civil Rights Act passed in 1964, the primary purpose was to root out discrimination in public accommodations (like hotels and movie theaters)

White is not right: Campus admins ask
for help weeding out white people

31 replie(s)
Daily Caller, by Robby Soave    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 4/15/2014 7:47:18 PM     Post Reply
Western Washington University sent a questionnaire to students asking them for advice on how the administration could succeed at making sure that in future years, “we are not as white as we are today.” The question notes that WWU’s racial make up does not perfectly reflect the nation at large, and asks students to consider strategies that other universities have used to focus on skin color as the paramount indicator of a student-applicant’s worth. The president of WWU has stated that his explicit goal is to reduce the white population on campus, according to Campus Reform. “I’ve said before and I’ll say it


Post Reply   Close thread 721017





Home Page | Latest Posts | Links | Must Reads | Update Profile | RSS | Contribute | Register | Rules & FAQs
Privacy Policy | Search | Post | Contact | Logout | Forgot Password | Search Using Google


© 2014 Lucianne.com Media Inc.

~~~c~~~