A Message From Lucianne  



Now More Than Ever
Get Your Eagles Up!
Lucianne Tees - in
Black or White
Click to Buy


































        
 

 
Home Page | Latest Posts | Links | Must Reads | Update Profile | RSS | Contribute
Register | Rules & FAQs | Search | Post | Contact | Logout | Forgot Password


  Topic: When a Genealogy Hobby
Digs Up Unwanted Secrets
Change your user profile.
If you are having trouble posting, please take the time to register.
Your User Name :
Your Password
  I forgot my password
Your Reply  :
Preview Reply     Post Reply
When a Genealogy Hobby
Digs Up Unwanted Secrets

Wall Street Journal, by Sue Shellenbarger

Original Article

Posted By:Drive, 1/17/2013 7:29:42 AM

Amateur genealogists, beware. Researching your ancestry doesn´t always turn up heroes and royalty. It may turn up a felon, a bigamist or another unsavory character. New York filmmaker Heather Quinlan found more than a few skeletons when digging into her ancestors´ closet. Among them: Thomas Fagan, her grandmother´s great-grandfather, who had killed a man during a drunken bar fight in 1868 (reportedly hitting him over the head with a chair in self-defense).

  

Post Reply  

Reply 1 - Posted by: StormCnter, 1/17/2013 7:54:38 AM     (No. 9121668)

I´ve been doing genealogy research for twenty years and the stories I´ve turned up have included some juicy ones. That´s part of the fun, of course. And, yes, like the woman in this story, I´ve debunked some of my family legends. That´s almost always a disappointment.


Reply 2 - Posted by: Fosterdad, 1/17/2013 8:13:15 AM     (No. 9121698)

I know. I´ve been doing some genealogical research and found out that one of my wife´s ancestors owned slaves and another massacred Indians.

When I was a kid I was always told that one of my great-great grandmothers was part Native American. She wasn´t. She was white. Bummer.


   

 

  


 
Reply 3 - Posted by: thelmalou, 1/17/2013 8:13:28 AM     (No. 9121700)

Listen - we can´t help what happened before our time. So some of my ancestors were less than savory characters. I doubt anyone has s sterling family tree.


Reply 4 - Posted by: Proud American, 1/17/2013 9:15:43 AM     (No. 9121801)

Greetings fellow genealogists! I have been at it for nearly 40 years and I love doing it. With the advent of the web it has made the search so much easier. I can say without reservation that genealogists are the most generous and patient people you´ll meet.

I have been astonished at what I have found...and the thread is never ending. The people in my line range from Calvin Coolidge´s butcher, Alexander Graham Bell´s house keeper, a revolutionary war hero, native Americans, shepards and blacksmiths, a minister introduced to his congregation by Cotton Mather, to a bowman for Henry VIII, the exchequer of London, Eleanor of Aquitane, Charlegmane and on and on. Some were wonderous and some were rouges. Most of them lived ordinary lives such as my own but I feel I have a close up view of the history of the world once I find their
names, dates & locations...

In my family we love and honor them all and can´t wait to meet them one fine day!

Proud American in MA


Reply 5 - Posted by: Proud2bninfidel, 1/17/2013 9:28:58 AM     (No. 9121825)

yeah, just ask dirty harry reid about his horse thief ancestor. seems criminal minds run in the family.


Reply 6 - Posted by: gartenfrau, 1/17/2013 9:30:53 AM     (No. 9121826)

I´ve been fortunate in that much of my genealogy was handed to me in books done by other family members. The challenge has been verifying it as true. My mother´s family is fairly boring...germans who came settled in SE Ohio in the 1830´s. My great-grandmother got pregnant by someone in the Swedish royal family and was sent to the US. The baby was adopted by a canadian couple. My Dad´s family came over with the Puritans and I have 3 Rev. War vetrans. Through him I am descended from Magna Carta signers, minor and som major royalty and lots of Puritans. It´ a neat way to learn history.


Reply 7 - Posted by: StormCnter, 1/17/2013 9:31:47 AM     (No. 9121829)

Last post on this subject, although I could discuss it all day.

When you´ve got Texas roots, as half my lines do, there will be renegades. My g-g-g-grandfather, a drunkard and neer-do-well, invaded a central Texas small-town church service (with his gang) to shoot an enemy who was in attendance. The group fired sixteen shots and didn´t hit anyone in the building. The townspeople were so outraged, they lynched them anyway.


   

 

  


 
Reply 8 - Posted by: NorthernDog, 1/17/2013 9:33:47 AM     (No. 9121836)

What´s funny is that researching Obama´s genealogy brings howls of protest and heaps of scorn. It seems that He is the skeleton in the closet.


Reply 9 - Posted by: bob913, 1/17/2013 9:35:51 AM     (No. 9121841)

My ancestor was a guard at the Swedish palace in the 1850´s but left for America suddenly when the King found out who was romancing the Queen... at least that is what I will pass down thru history.

BTW part of the story is true : )


Reply 10 - Posted by: Proud American, 1/17/2013 9:49:29 AM     (No. 9121861)

gartenfrau perhaps our ancestors knew each other during the war!

BTW I forgot to mention that I also found a slave in my lineage - Anna Christian - half native american and half african. I am also decended from Magna Charta signers...I have had a pro look at the work/lineage and it was given the nod of confirmation.

Blessedly I am also related to Dick Chenney! Can you imagine my pride?! Our common ancestor is the minister who was introduced to his flock by Cotton Mather in Massachusetts. The Rev. came from Aberdeen Scotland in the 1600´s.

Looking through my past I do wonder about genetic memory - have any of my fellow genealogists on this site heard of this?




Reply 11 - Posted by: AltaD, 1/17/2013 9:56:06 AM     (No. 9121870)

A few years before my aunt (Mom´s sister) passed away, she told me that one of her daughters paid a genealogist to research the family tree but the information is all wrong. Somewhere along the way the spelling of their last name was altered so the genealogist researched the wrong family.

My aunt said she didn´t have the heart to tell her daughter that she wasted her money and since it wasn´t my secret to tell, I´ve never told my cousins. Which means they´ve passed a stranger´s family tree on to their children and grandchildren.


Reply 12 - Posted by: MissMolly, 1/17/2013 10:17:23 AM     (No. 9121901)

#12, the error will be uncovered if anyone applies for DAR or SAR membership.


   

 



 
Reply 13 - Posted by: woodenleg, 1/17/2013 10:24:02 AM     (No. 9121914)

I´ve always gone on the assumption that my Irish relatives were horse thieves and bootleggers. Never bothered to find out though.


Reply 14 - Posted by: MisterDickens, 1/17/2013 10:24:55 AM     (No. 9121915)

Before my father died, he spent years doing research on our family. I am a nothing burger, descended from nothing burgers.


Reply 15 - Posted by: JHHolliday, 1/17/2013 10:29:05 AM     (No. 9121932)

I have been doing my family´s geneology for 20 years now and it´s always fascinating. One ancestor was the biggest slaveholder in Georgia before ´The War´. Not something to brag about but no guilt either since I wasn´t around then.

When you order a DNA test they also warn you about negative discoveries. There is something known as a ´non-parental event´.

That´s when your family has alway been Smiths and the DNA turns up that you are actually a Jones. Meaning somewhere back in your line there was either an adoption or an extramarital affair. Dig around far enough and you will always find surprises.


Reply 16 - Posted by: Clinger, 1/17/2013 10:31:51 AM     (No. 9121938)

#4, Hiya Cousin! I´m in line for my reparations as a slave decenedent. Bishop plantation in Barbados. You don´t suppose the fact he was Irish will hurt my case do you?


Reply 17 - Posted by: mitzi, 1/17/2013 10:36:28 AM     (No. 9121948)

I can´t imagine what I would consider an "unwanted secret." Everything is just so fascinating to learn about.

I´ve been researching since about 1990, having picked up from my mother´s prior 20 years of research. "We" settled in the U.S. between 1852 (earliest) and 1892 (last).

I have an ancestor who fought in the American Revolution ... as a Hessian. He returned to Germany after the war and died in 1802.

Two collateral ancestors were executed in the 17th century Germany - accused of being witches.

The Germans kept fabulous records (both secular and church records).

We´ve done DNA testing for ancient ancestry and my female line goes back to the Iberian caves during the last Ice Age - 13,000 years ago. When we got our results (2005), I told my mother that it explains why we all liked scribbling with crayons on the wallpaper when we were children!


   

 

  


 
Reply 18 - Posted by: O.S. Banker, 1/17/2013 10:53:14 AM     (No. 9121996)

I have worked extensively on my paternal side of the family. Our surname is from southern Scotland, the Borders commonly known as the Debateable Land. Claimed by both England and Scotland, taxed by both England and Scotland but protected by neither. I was effectively a DMZ so consequently alliances and loyalties extended no further than family and neighbors. We had our own cavalry capable of mounting 3,000 men in the saddle. We raided the English as necessary to survive. One time that the loyalty was extended to the King of Scotland, James V. When he ascended the English throne as James I, he repaid my ancestors by sending a letter of safe conduct inviting them to a hunt. Upon arrival at the Manor, they were siezed and subsequently hung. All 30 of them. At Carlenrig in July of 1530.

For some reason, there is not a whole lot of trust in my family for centralized authority. Hmm?


Reply 19 - Posted by: Proud American, 1/17/2013 11:04:58 AM     (No. 9122020)

Cousin Clinger #17...Who knows? My Irish great grandfather was born May 4, 1844 in Rathgormack County Waterford... reperations? Bah!

I count my blessings and thank God each and every day that in all the thousands of years and generations they were smart enough to get their fannies over here by golly!

I spoke to a licenced genealogist that told me she knows people who have traced....right back to Adam! Now that is commitment. Yes, we all go back to Adam & Eve but these folks track the names & tribes - ya gotta love it!

Nice to meet you cousin!


Reply 20 - Posted by: annie xango, 1/17/2013 11:05:43 AM     (No. 9122024)

I love this thread..fascinating to hear your stories.a cousin has done extensive research ,published a big leather bound book for all of us..he traced that part of the family back to the 11th century..I find that mind boggling.Ancestral village is over 700 years old.


Reply 21 - Posted by: realrep, 1/17/2013 11:30:37 AM     (No. 9122071)

#4 We are also related. Charlemagne is my g(x37)grandfather.
My g-grandparents in England were drunks so my grandfather came to the USA in 1896. He worked in a woolen mill. The fed gov´t sued the woolen mill and the mill closed. The woolen mill buildings are now part of Mystic Seaport Museum.


Reply 22 - Posted by: Proud American, 1/17/2013 11:59:05 AM     (No. 9122161)

Greetings Cousin RealRep #22 have you met our cousin Clinger #17?

What a delight and to think after centuries, thousands of miles, war, famine & disease our family has come together again on the best website in the most delightful salon hosted by the incomparable Miss Lucianne Goldberg!

So this means that we have ancestors in common who were Knights Templar (some buried in Jerusalem) picts and Vikings!

Say, I am in MA just so ya know. Good to know all of us on this thread are keeping the stories & legends of our people alive and well for the next generation to learn from.


   

 



 
Reply 23 - Posted by: comstock, 1/17/2013 12:15:49 PM     (No. 9122210)

A cousin discovered our Great Grandfather was a Catholic Priest when he fathered our paternal grandfather. As was common in the day, our grandfather carried the mother´s name. So our family name is bogus... Oh, well.


Reply 24 - Posted by: columba, 1/17/2013 1:35:52 PM     (No. 9122381)

In Obama´s AD 2013 No one will be able to identify a person´s father or other male ancestors


Reply 25 - Posted by: southernstorm, 1/17/2013 1:46:05 PM     (No. 9122405)

I´ve been researching as a hobby for many years. Recently found my 5th great aunt was Mary Surratt who was found guilty and hung by the Federal Government for conspiracy and assistance to those that killed President Lincoln. If my grandfather knew this information, he would be humiliated. To me, this information is just history.


Reply 26 - Posted by: gillyo, 1/17/2013 2:27:53 PM     (No. 9122495)

My grandmother was a Reading from New Jersey, descended from the Ryersons of New Amsterdam, and a Mayflower descendant. She took great pride in her family background, sometimes to the point of snobbishness.

Anyway, she was especially proud to be a descendant of Mayflower passenger Edward Doty.

My mother´s family wasn´t as prestigious so she tended to lord it over them a little. So, you can imagine my surprise when I discovered that my mother is a descendant of Stephen Hopkins. Hopkins is an interesting character, who is said to have been Shakespeare´s inspiration for the character of Stefano in "The Tempest." He was shipwrecked in Bermuda, then managed to get to Jamestown, returned to England, and then sailed with the Pilgrims on the Mayflower.

The kicker is that Edward Doty was Stephen Hopkins´ servant.

My grandmother passed away years ago but I would have given anything to see her reaction to that bit of news!


Reply 27 - Posted by: anotherctyankee, 1/17/2013 7:50:07 PM     (No. 9123083)

I tried to research, but I was a babe in the woods. My daughter did as much as she had the interest in doing. My family has been in America for a long time, going back to Georgia, Louisiana and Texas. I have no idea of the original countries. My husbands family is newer to the U.S. and came from Ireland and Spain. What my daughter found was boring and nothing like the stories my grandma passed down. Like, my great grandfather was the inspiration of the book ´Trail of the Lonesome Pine´. My mother said grandma was more interested in telling us what we wanted to hear. It´s easy to get off on the wrong branch of a family, so it´s hard to know if any of the genealogy is true.


Reply 28 - Posted by: ColonialAmerican1623, 1/17/2013 9:42:23 PM     (No. 9123293)

You never know, maybe we are all related.

Thanks to an article posted here recently, I found a copy of a letter between George Washington and a family member relating to a land purchase. Before that, in the 1600´s let´s just say we were in shipping.



Post Reply   Close thread 719381




Below, you will find ...

Most Recent Articles posted by "Drive"

and

Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)




Most Recent Articles posted by "Drive"



The Stingers of Benghazi
National Review Online, by Jim Geraghty    Original Article
Posted By: drive- 5/24/2013 7:31:36 AM     Post Reply
Earlier this week, Roger L. Simon of Pajamas Media broke a story with shocking revelations, contending that slain U.S. ambassador Chris Stevens was in Benghazi on September 11 to buy back Stinger missiles from al-Qaeda groups that had been originally provided to them by the U.S. State Department. Simon cited two former U.S. diplomats: Stevens’ mission in Benghazi, they will say, was to buy back Stinger missiles from al-Qaeda groups issued to them by the State Department, not by the CIA.

A loving father, an Afghan hero
and a fine soldier: Face of ´Riggers´
the innocent drummer, 25, ´butchered
on street by Muslim fanatics
Daily Mail (UK), by Rob Cooper*    Original Article
Posted By: drive- 5/23/2013 1:29:24 PM     Post Reply
The murdered British soldier executed by two Islamist fanatics was tonight named as Lee Rigby. The 25-year-old ´cheeky and humorous´ serviceman - described as a ´loving father´ to his two-year-old son Jack - was identified as police guarded his home in Middleton, Greater Manchester. Drummer Rigby, a keen football fan who followed Manchester United FC, was just starting his Army career and had recently fought in Afghanistan with the Royal Regiment of Fusiliers.

IRS emails: Who knew
what, and when?
Cincinatti/Gannett Media, by James Pilcher    Original Article
Posted By: drive- 5/23/2013 11:30:55 AM     Post Reply
New emails between Internal Revenue Service officials released Wednesday as part of congressional testimony give a better view of who knew of the screening of conservative tea party groups and the search terms being used, and when they knew it. The documents also show a bit of the process the IRS used in such situations, but do not answer the question at the heart of the controversy – who made the decision to search for such groups and why. The string of emails is from early June 2011, sparked by a request from Holly Paz,

Tensions Brew Inside White
House Over Counsel’s Role
Buzzfeed, by Evan McMorris-Santoro    Original Article
Posted By: drive- 5/23/2013 7:37:02 AM     Post Reply
WASHINGTON — As they watched President Obama lumber into controversy over mandating contraception coverage last winter, some White House staffers were banging their heads against the wall. The lawyers had done it again. Tensions between operatives and the lawyers hired to protect them from legal trouble are a constant in politics. But as President Obama’s beleaguered aides look for someone to blame in an escalating series of scandals, former political, communications, and policy officials complained to BuzzFeed that one culprit is a balance that has tilted too far toward the lawyer, allowing avoidable controversies to boil over.

Sal: Squeeze Weiner
for cost of election
New York Post, by David Seifman    Original Article
Posted By: drive- 5/22/2013 1:01:19 PM     Post Reply
With Anthony Weiner about to pop into the race for mayor, one of his Democratic rivals demanded yesterday that he pony up $350,000 for the cost of the election required to fill his hastily vacated congressional seat two years ago. Weiner resigned under pressure in June 2011 after it was disclosed he was tweeting lewd pictures of himself to women he’d met on the Internet. In the special election held that September to replace him, Republican Bob Turner pulled off a stunning upset victory over Democrat David Weprin. Taxpayers were stuck with the $350,000 election tab,

Fox News poll: Obama ratings dip,
voters say government ´out of control´
Fox News, by Dana Blanton    Original Article
Posted By: drive- 5/22/2013 12:53:01 PM     Post Reply
After a week of revelations about government spying on reporters and the Internal Revenue Service targeting conservatives, most voters feel “like the federal government has gotten out of control and is threatening the basic civil liberties of Americans.” At the same time, a new Fox News poll finds disapproval of President Obama’s job performance is above 50 percent for the first time in a year, his honesty rating is at a new low and half of voters already think he’s a lame-duck.

N.Y. Times editorial board:
Obama administration
threatening press freedom
Politico, by Dylan Byers    Original Article
Posted By: drive- 5/22/2013 8:31:26 AM     Post Reply
The New York Times editorial board has condemned the Obama administration for threatening press freedom in the wake of revelations that the Justice Dept. seized phone records belonging to Fox News reporter James Rosen. "With the decision to label a Fox News television reporter a possible ´co-conspirator´ in a criminal investigation of a news leak, the Obama administration has moved beyond protecting government secrets to threatening fundamental freedoms of the press to gather news," the board wrote in an editorial published on Wednesday. Noting past Obama administration intrustions into press freedom, including the Justice Dept.´s



Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)



Eva Longoria graduates with
master´s degree in Chicano studies

52 replie(s)
Los Angeles Times, by Nardine Saad    Original Article
Posted By: NorthernDog- 5/23/2013 3:03:53 PM     Post Reply
Eva Longoria is backing up her beauty with a whole lot of brain. The actress graduated with a master´s degree Wednesday. Longoria, 38, took home a real degree (not an honorary one) in Chicano studies from Cal State Northridge, where she physically attended classes for three years, according to TMZ. "Big day today!!! Very excited to graduate for my master´s degree in Chicano studies! You´re never too old or too busy to continue your education!" the actress wrote on her Who Say site Wednesday, sharing loads of pics of her big day, posing with her family, cohorts and diploma.

Mark Levin Tears Into Obama: ‘Flat-
Out, Bald-Faced Lie’ That He Knew
Nothing About IRS Targeting

51 replie(s)
Mediaite, by Josh Feldman    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 5/23/2013 9:48:28 PM     Post Reply
Conservative radio host Mark Levin is very skeptical of the idea that President Obama had absolutely no idea about the IRS tea party targeting before the story broke in the news mere weeks ago. Levin declared adamantly that it is a “flat-out, bald-faced lie” that Obama didn’t know beforehand, citing prior reports by a few conservative news outlets picking up on the news well before the 2012 presidential election. Levin said, “I don’t believe for two seconds that Obama wasn’t aware of this.”

Obama nominates Nuland for
assistant secretary of state

51 replie(s)
Politico, by Reid J. Epstein    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 5/23/2013 10:08:52 PM     Post Reply
President Obama on Thursday nominated Victoria Nuland, a State Department official involved in the editing of the administration´s talking points on Benghazi, to be the next assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs. Nuland, a career foreign service officer who was until recently State´s top spokesperson, had long been expected to be nominated the post to replace Philip Gordon, who Obama picked to serve as Middle East coordinator for the National Security Council. Nuland´s nomination -- which requires Senate confirmation -- could come under scrutiny from Republicans who see her as playing a central role in shaping

Anthony Weiner says Houston
psychiatric facility made
him ‘a new man’

50 replie(s)
Houston Chronicle, by Nicole Narea    Original Article
Posted By: Dreadnought- 5/23/2013 10:52:02 PM     Post Reply
Anthony Weiner’s New York mayoral candidacy was only made more improbable today after he revealed that he visited a Houston psychiatric facility following his resignation from Congress in 2011. Haunted by scandal surrounding his sexually explicit online communications with women, the Democratic former congressman sought treatment for his compulsive behavior from mental health professionals at the Gabbard Center. According to its website, the facility provides “3-day outpatient psychiatric evaluation,” particularly to “professionals who are in personal or professional crises.” While Weiner did not disclose

Mark Levin: "RINO" Issa Didn´t
Investigate IRS Before Because
He "Despises The Tea Party"

43 replie(s)
Real Clear Politics, by Ian Schwartz    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 5/24/2013 5:38:38 PM     Post Reply
MARK LEVIN: So why didn´t Chairman Issa hold an investigative hearing a year ago? Why didn´t Chairman Camp, all Republicans, hold an investigative hearing a year ago, and all the other tripping over themselves right now? I´ll tell you why. Because the establishment Republicans, the RINO Republicans, despise the Tea Party. They despise the conservative movement. We exist to be managed, to be shuttled to the polling place, to vote for their candidates. The Karl Roves of the world, and all the rest of them. They fight us in the primaries, they fight us at the grassroots.

Fox News’s Roger Ailes responds
to Justice Dept. investigation

38 replie(s)
Washington Post, by Erik Wemple    Original Article
Posted By: Dreadnought- 5/23/2013 11:00:19 PM     Post Reply
Fox News chief Roger Ailes has sent a memo to his subordinates at the leading cable news network. He sent this memo to his staff today in connection with the federal investigation into an alleged leak to Fox News reporter James Rosen, a story that the Washington Post’s Ann E. Marimow broke earlier this week. The memo’s a masterpiece, too. For all those who wonder what it is about Ailes that endears his people to him — and that makes him such a good interviewee for any media reporter lucky enough to get an audience

Obama Asks Staff to
Start Cc’ing Him on Stuff

37 replie(s)
New Yorker, by Andy Borowitz    Original Article
Posted By: StormCnter- 5/24/2013 5:31:36 AM     Post Reply
WASHINGTON —In a dramatic departure from existing White House procedures, President Obama requested today that his staff start cc’ing him on stuff. “Look, I know a lot of you think I’m really busy and you don’t want to bother me,” the President reportedly told his staff in an Oval Office meeting. “But cc me anyway. It’s good for me to keep up on what’s going on around here.” “It’s not good when I turn on the news and they’re talking about something at the White House and I’m like, whoa, when did that happen?”


Post Reply   Close thread 719381





Home Page | Latest Posts | Links | Must Reads | Update Profile | Register | Rules & FAQs | Search | Post | Contact | RSS | Contribute | Logout | Forgot Password


© 2013 Lucianne.com Media Inc.

~~~c~~~