When it comes to becoming a physician, the academic rigors, years of schooling, and personal sacrifice common to the effort are well-known. This process is a sort of rite of passage, an intellectual marathon that only the best and brightest can complete. As such, medical schools should select candidates best-suited to excel throughout school and cultivate the skills that will allow them to practice in the best health care system in the world. The process by which these candidates are selected, however, may come as a shock.
Comments: I know it sounds racist, but I will only go to white or asian doctors - I know they got into med school on merit.
I feel for the minority applicants who are highly qualified - they´re tainted with the affirmative action brush.
Educating good doctors has nothing to do with it. The only thing that counts is votes. Once you start going there for answers to confusing situations and questions, everything makes sense. Welcome to 21st century america.
Affirmative action is more liberal feel-good fantasy ideology. The concept itself is intellectually incoherent and as incompatible with the American system as slavery was to the ante-bellum Americans who were distressed by it. There is perhaps nothing more disgraceful than the academy´s embrace of this profoundly irrational and anti-egalitarian racket and fraud. The very people who are supposed to guard and transmit the hard-won skills of clear and honest thinking are the worst offenders in peddling the pernicious doctrine of affirmative action. I believe -though it is only a guess- that the main reason for this postmodern Treason of the Clerks(Julien Benda) is nothing but simple moral cowardice on the part of the silent majority of academics, which permits the zealots, scoundrels, incompetents and fanatics to control and drive events.
sad because there are good qualified blacks in all walks of life but how to pick them out from the trash? I am afraid it is just safer and easier to do as OP does. And i don´t limit it to just doctors. I now cast my vote the same way
"...medical schools should select candidates best-suited to excel thorughout school and coltivate the skills..." How quaint! Don´t you realize that that is old fashioned and wrong! The goal is to have a "rainbow of diversity" to show that we are an accepting, caring nation. Ability doesn´t count--it´s how we look in a group photo! /s
Reply 10 - Posted by:
The Advocate, 12/16/2012 11:33:48 AM (No. 9069137)
Went to a med school graduation. A black female was allowed to come onto the stage with her class to make her feel better even though she could not get her degree. She kept failing almost every class and had to repeat them. Would you want her to be your doctor if by some chance she stayed there long enough to finally get.,a pass?
You have to fly from point A to point B. You have 2 air carriers from which to choose. Both flights have identical schedules and the tickets cost the same. The only difference between the 2 air carriers is their name.
One is American Airlines. The other is Affirmative Action Airlines.
When affirmative action in admissions became well established in the 1970s, I am familiar with one state run medical school where the blacks admitted were run through a 5 year program, rather than the normal four years. They didn´t have the intellectual capacity to do the work in four years, is what I was told. They also, typically, did not do the obsessive studying required in medical school. I taught in a business related masters program, and we admitted any black who had completed an undergraduate degree, no matter the major, and we gave each of them an assistantship, which provided full tuition plus a stipend. Most of them were incapable of assisting the professor, so they did nothing. And when most of them were allowed to graduate, after barely squeezing through the program, employers wanted them, over our very best graduates! So the undergrad school was under affirmative action pressure to admit and graduate them, we, the graduate school, were under affirmative action pressure to admit and graduate them, and employers were under affirmative action pressure to hire and promote them. Such is life in modern America.
The thing that caught my attention in the article is the last bit- FTA "Once a tool that sought to eliminate race from the employment process in an effort to promote equality, affirmative action has taken on a life of its own. It is now a dominant force that has countered racism with more racism."
It is a though the writer has suddenly realized an epiphany that "Affirmative Action" is a racist thing now- I disagree!
Affirmative action by its very definition from the inception of it was racist and shameful in the extreme- it was and still is racism plain and simple and anyone with the lightest bit of wisdom could see that.
Our HR department hired an AA guy one day. In a matter of days it was obvious to everyone that he could not perform any of the tasks his resume said he could. Being a DoD contractor, and afraid to fire him, they spent the next eight months or so rewriting his resume, enrolling and mentoring him through Microsoft Office classes and sending out applications for him to other help wanted ads to get rid of him.
second post apologies, but - just because the physician is a white American is not enough. Make sure that physician attended a u.s. medical school. There are some whites who yearn for the M.D. degree, apply to American schools, get rejected, go to a mexican border town where there are medical schools established to teach such americans, or to grenada or some other off shore school. Avoid those ´physicians´ like the plague.
What do you mean EVEN in medical school, that was famously one of the first places for the battle in the Bakke decision forty years ago, where the courts ruled that it comprised reverse discrimination. But it has gone on anyway, apparently.
It´s fairly easy to learn if a doctor of any color has the ability and and intelligence to be a real healer. If the doctor must test everything over and over instead of relying on these abilities then find another one fast. The best way to pick is to make an appointment and interview him/her just like hiring any other potential service employee. An excellent doctor will also call upon other excellent providers for special needs.
My father is a retired MD who served on the admissions board of a state med school here back in the late 70´s/early 80´s. He saw this attitude even back then when AA was still in its early stages.
The school tried to set up a summer school program for accepted minority students that were academically-challenged. It was an attempt to help them get a leg up on the basic sciences that comprise the core curiculum for 1st & 2nd year students. However they made the participation voluntary. Results ? Out of approximately 30 new minority students who should have taken part, only 3 did. The rest couldn´t be botherd to give up their summer time. Priorities you see....
#13, I had a similar experience. Several years ago, I flew out of Cedar Rapids, Iowa, where I had been on a business trip. I sat next to a young woman who had finished med school at Iowa and was on her way to California to interview for residencies. I had heard of "grade norming" for minorities and asked her if that stuff went on at Iowa med school too. She said she didn´t think so, but what did happen was the minority students--or most-- took half the course load of the white and Asian students, and took 5-6 years to complete. She said they were all on full scholarships so were indifferent to the added costs. Not a confidence builder.
When I was a med student in the late 70´s all the black students were caught cheating in a test.They called the NAACP and the school backed down. They all graduated except one that had repeated the first year four times.I often wondered how many people they killed .
If there is one last precaution. Medical malpractice lawsuits are color blind. As such, incompetent docs will eventually be weeded out through threats or actual litigation. The unfortunate part is that it will take just one person to suffer that injury.
Also, as to the immediate acceptance of an Asian doc...many of those foreign born are brought here in under special visas for a lot lower wage, like in the science and tech engineering professions centered in Boston and Silicone Valley, CA.
This nation is as diversified as it will ever be, so let´s give up AA. There are plenty of excellent students that should be accepted on merit, not color. Wait until the Dream Act throws in more with English as a second language.
What are the chances your Medicare plan with only provide 2nd class docs because they cost less ?
Katie Couric is set to quit her troubled chat show little more than a year after its launch on ABC, MailOnline can reveal. The 56-year-old news veteran had wanted to see out her vision for the series - but will announce a new interview show with Yahoo in the next few days. And despite the fact her eponymous show, Katie, enjoyed a five-week ratings high last month, a source confirmed her show is poised to end on ABC at the end of its second season. Today, a source confirmed Katie was in ´ongoing negotiations with Yahoo adding: ´There´s a very
DENVER - Amendment 66, the K-12 education funding measure, has failed in Colorado. Even in Democratic strongholds of Boulder and Denver counties, the measure was failing or barely even. Amendment 66 constitutionally and statutorily would alter Colorado law to change how the state funds education. Firstly, it raises the state individual income tax rate from 4.63 percent to 5 percent on the first $75,000 of taxable income. That is equivalent to $472.5 if you earn exactly $75,000 in taxable income per year. If you earn more, any income beyond the $75,000 is taxed at a rate of 5.9 percent.
Thousands of Californians are discovering what Obamacare will cost them — and many don´t like what they see. These middle-class consumers are staring at hefty increases on their insurance bills as the overhaul remakes the healthcare market. Their rates are rising in large part to help offset the higher costs of covering sicker, poorer people who have been shut out of the system for years. Although recent criticism of the healthcare law has focused on website glitches and early enrollment snags, experts say sharp price increases for individual policies have the greatest potential to erode public support for President Obama´s
Kelly Ayotte is no stranger to the difficult balancing act of politics. In the 2010 New Hampshire Senate primary, the Republican state attorney general trumpeted an endorsement from Sarah Palin to help her fend off a tough GOP challenger, who had attempted to outflank her on the right. Then Ayotte tracked closely enough to the center to blow out her Democratic opponent, U.S. Rep. Paul Hodes, by 23 percentage points in the general election. (In the process, she won all 10 of the state’s counties.) Once she arrived in Washington, it wasn’t long before Ayotte began being mentioned as a
Immigration overhaul legislation has been dormant in the House for months, but a few Republicans are working behind the scenes to advance it at a time the Capitol is immersed in a partisan brawl over government spending and President Barack Obama´s health care law. The chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, Rep. Bob Goodlatte, has been discussing possible legal status for the estimated 11 million immigrants living in the U.S. illegally. He´s also been working with House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, a fellow Virginia Republican, on a bill offering citizenship to immigrants brought illegally
The Democratic Party of Sacramento County, California scrambled on Friday to deal with fallout from a series of tweets its communications chair sent Friday, in which he wished the children of a speechwriter in the office of Sen. Ted Cruz would endure a painful death. By day´s end Allan Brauer was apologizing, but not before galvanizing conservative Republic tweeters against him in a virtual online bloodbath and losing his political position over what the party called ´appalling and inexcusable´ comments.
Carl Guardino, head of the Silicon Valley Leadership Group, came away from a meeting with House GOP whip Kevin McCarthy of Bakersfield a few moments ago on Friday saying he “would bet on” comprehensive immigration reform getting to passage this year. “Kevin is a long-time personal friend,” Guardino said of McCarthy. “We just met one-on-one and I firmly believe, without breaking confidences, that we are going to see deliberative and thoughtful action in the House when they reconvene in September and October.” “I would bet on it,” he added.
I have never been much of a conspiracy theorist. For me it was always Oswald by himself from the Texas School Book Depository and nothing in the intervening fifty years has disabused me of this notion. For the most part, I’m an Occam’s Razor kind of guy — the most obvious explanation is likely to be true. (Snip) To put it bluntly, Occam’s Razor has moved. Things that were once possibilities now seem almost certainties to me. Principal among those is that Obama’s academic records are perpetually unavailable for a reason — and that reason is most likely that they reveal
One of President Obama´s chief political assets has been his ability to excite young people like almost no politician in history. But the days of America´s youth fawning over the president are over. A new Harvard University Institute of Politics poll released Wednesday confirms what other surveys have shown in recent months: Millennials have soured on Obama so much this year that their opinion of him largely mirrors the American public´s. Even though Obama does not ever have to face another election, he should be worried about the findings for a couple of reasons, which we will dive into momentarily.
A stunning new study unveiled on Fox News´ Hannity finds that President Barack Obama’s White House calendar records just one face-to-face meeting between Obama and his Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Kathleen Sebelius in the more than three-and-a-half years leading up to the disastrous Obamacare launch. The startling statistic comes from a new Government Accountability Institute (GAI) analysis of Obama’s own official White House calendar, as well as the Politico presidential calendar, and raises new questions about Obama’s executive leadership and management throughout the implementation of his singular legislative achievement. More alarming still, the president’s schedule lists 277 private
[Video] President Obama on Wednesday declared that addressing income inequality would be the focus of “all” of the White House’s efforts “for the rest of my presidency.” In a sweeping address that touched on raising the minimum wage, investing in infrastructure and ending tax breaks for the wealthy, Obama warned that the American economy has become “profoundly unequal,” declaring economic mobility the “challenge of our time.” “The combined trends of increasing inequality and decreasing mobility pose a fundamental threat to the American dream, our way of life, and what we stand for around the globe,” he said in an hour-long
Just over two weeks ago, MSNBC host Martin Bashir delivered a harsh piece of commentary that culminated in the suggestion that someone should “s-h-i-t” in former Alaska Governor Sarah Palin‘s (R-AK) mouth. Bashir offered an abject apology on his next broadcast, but a chorus of critics continued to demand action against the host. After a reported “vacation” for the host earlier this week, Bashir announced, Wednesday afternoon, that MSNBC and Martin Bashir are parting ways. Here’s the statement from Martin Bashir, via email: After making an on-air apology, I asked for permission to take some additional time out around the Thanksgiving holiday. Upon
Amid an array of “knock-out” attacks against a number of Jews in Brooklyn’s Crown Heights neighborhood, a city councilwoman pointed to the success of the Jewish community as triggering the aggression. Councilwoman-elect Laurie Cumbo emphasized that while she “admire[s] the Jewish community immensely” for its work ethic, black teens may see it differently. “While I personally regard this level of tenacity, I also recognize that for others, the accomplishments of the Jewish community triggers feelings of resentment, and a sense that Jewish success is not also their success,” Cumbo, who was recently elected, wrote in a letter. Chief among the issues
America is facing a wave of strikes by its fast-food workers on Thursday a day after Barack Obama warned that inequality in the USA had soared to the point that it now posed "a fundamental threat to the American dream". Low-paid workers in McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken and other fast-food outlets in 100 cities across America were due to start rolling strikes to protest at the low level of America´s $7.25 (£4.45) federal minimum wage. The strikes are the latest part of a mushrooming publicity campaign for higher wages among those working so-called "McJobs", with fast-food restaurants seen as a