A Message From Lucianne  







S-G1




























ST-GC



        
 

 
Home Page | Latest Posts | Links | Must Reads | Update Profile | RSS | Contribute | Register | Rules & FAQs
Privacy Policy | Search | Post | Contact | Logout | Forgot Password | Search Using Google


  Topic: Why Gore Vidal, Norman Mailer,
and Truman Capote All Failed
to Write the Great American
Novel
Change your user profile.
If you are having trouble posting, please take the time to register.
Your User Name :
Your Password
  I forgot my password
Your Reply  :
Preview Reply     Post Reply
Why Gore Vidal, Norman Mailer,
and Truman Capote All Failed
to Write the Great American
Novel

PJ Media, by Bruce Bawer

Original Article

Posted By:Mike PHX, 9/29/2012 2:46:37 PM

Many commentators have suggested that the passing of Gore Vidal at age eighty-six on July 31 marks the end of a remarkable generation of postwar American novelists the likes of whom we shall never see again. When people speak of that generation of novelists, they are usually referring to exactly three people: Norman Mailer (born in 1923), Truman Capote (1924), and Vidal (1925). All three made splashy literary debuts in the years shortly after the war. All three were not just writers but celebrities.

Comments:
Putting their personal, public lives aside, Capote wrote great non-fiction. I must have read In Cold Blood a half dozen times. Mailer wrote a few pretty good fiction in the sixties and The Executioner's Song wasn't as bad as the author suggests. But Vidal? He was just a chubby, lazy former debutante with delusions of grandeur.
Just IMHO, of course.

      


Post Reply  

Reply 1 - Posted by: Mike PHX, 9/29/2012 2:48:49 PM     (No. 8898732)

"a few pretty good fiction"?!
It's obvious why I failed to write the Great American Novel.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 2 - Posted by: dotty, 9/29/2012 2:56:33 PM     (No. 8898740)

Is this guy kidding? Capote considered the short story the greatest form of fiction writing and no one ever topped him at that. "A Christmas Memory" is the most perfect short story I have ever read. It makes the sweetest Christmas gift. IN COLD BLOOD was a brilliant a piece of writing as ever written and it invented a new literary form, "The non-fiction novel." Capote didn't fail at anything. He survived a family that failed him and became great.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


   

 

R-G1
  
R-VAR_AD


 
Reply 3 - Posted by: SoCalGal, 9/29/2012 3:08:52 PM     (No. 8898767)

Their agendas showed.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 4 - Posted by: earlybird, 9/29/2012 3:10:09 PM     (No. 8898771)

"Great American Novel" has nothing to do with short stories or non-fiction.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 5 - Posted by: vesicant, 9/29/2012 3:19:42 PM     (No. 8898788)

Who cares^3.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 6 - Posted by: Raristotle, 9/29/2012 3:44:41 PM     (No. 8898827)

You gotta first be American in ethos and spirit to be able to write the "Great American Novel". Capote might have been the most American of the three, but he didn't write novels, mainly. Vidal and Mailer never understood America.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 7 - Posted by: Susannah, 9/29/2012 3:49:46 PM     (No. 8898845)

What a great article; thanks for posting it. Mailer, Capote, and Vidal were unusually gifted at self-promotion.

It's interesting that Bawer mentions "Marjorie Morningstar" and "Raintree County." A lot of people did consider "Raintree County" the Great American Novel. Unfortunately, Lockridge committed suicide soon after it was published.

I always thought "The Young Lions," also mentioned here, was better than Mailer's novel. Irwin Shaw was pretty much the master of the short story. "The Green Nude" and "Girls in Their Summer Dresses" are classics.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


   

 

  


 
Reply 8 - Posted by: Mike PHX, 9/29/2012 3:52:23 PM     (No. 8898851)

#4, I was making the (again, my own) observation that Capote was better at non- than fiction, which is one of the reasons he didn't write TGAN. Though I'm sure he thought he was when writing the unfinished Answered Prayers.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 9 - Posted by: bob913, 9/29/2012 4:06:25 PM     (No. 8898884)

They were all bitter gay men?

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 10 - Posted by: earlybird, 9/29/2012 4:22:17 PM     (No. 8898913)

Maybe someone can tell me what makes Bawer an expert, an authority. I've never heard of him.

Why these three? I never liked any of them.

How about Dreiser? Even Margaret Miller, with GWTW?

Bawer tries for a big statement. Misses by miles.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 11 - Posted by: Susannah, 9/29/2012 4:27:57 PM     (No. 8898922)

Bawer's a literary critic, among other things, #11. But even if he weren't, he'd still be entitled to write a literate essay expressing his considered opinions about some novelists. He may not have mentioned Dreiser or Mitchell because of space limitations. He probably performed a service reminding some of his readers of the existence of Ross Lockridge and Irwin Shaw.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 12 - Posted by: Mike PHX, 9/29/2012 4:28:25 PM     (No. 8898925)

He was referring to a particular, post WWII generation.
Who is Margaret Miller? I never heard of her either.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


   

 

B-G1


 
Reply 13 - Posted by: Japanorama, 9/29/2012 6:24:58 PM     (No. 8899102)

The great American is the average American who made this country. These three were effete snobs, so they hadn't a clue.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 14 - Posted by: earlybird, 9/29/2012 6:33:04 PM     (No. 8899118)

"Margaret Miller" was a mind cramp.

Margaret Mitchell was the author I was referring to.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 15 - Posted by: Emerson, 9/29/2012 6:37:45 PM     (No. 8899129)

Bawer took lots of words to finally get to this:

Why were they better at non-fiction than fiction? A big part of the reason is that a great novelist needs to have the gift of profound empathy – the ability to create, care profoundly about, and comprehend to the depths of their souls characters radically different from himself. To be a great novelist requires that one be able to stand alone, as it were, at the edge of the party and observe other people patiently and unobtrusively – to look into their eyes and, in doing so, try to see into their souls.

None of these three were up to that; all were too wrapped up in themselves.


  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.


Reply 16 - Posted by: Japanorama, 9/30/2012 4:53:38 AM     (No. 8899689)

The human heart eludes mere technique.

  Click Here if you Like this Comment

   1  person like this.



Post Reply   Close thread 704118




Below, you will find ...

Most Recent Articles posted by "Mike PHX"

and

Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)




Most Recent Articles posted by "Mike PHX"



Interview: L.A. Street Artist Behind the
Ted Cruz Bad Boy Posters Speaks Out
PJ Media, by Paula Bolyard    Original Article
Posted By: Mike PHX- 3/20/2014 9:53:21 AM     Post Reply
Last weekend mysterious posters of Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) appeared in various locations around Beverly Hills. The posters featured an image of Cruz’s head — complete with a cigarette hanging out of his mouth — photoshopped onto a heavily inked torso. The headline on the posters read, “Beverly Hilton: Ted Cruz’s So-Cal ‘Blacklisted and Loving It’ Tour.” Cruz was in California last weekend to speak at the Claremont Institute’s Churchill dinner. The story went viral, appearing in media outlets as diverse as Drudge, Breitbart, Time, and Huffington Post. Most of them applauded Cruz’s sense of humor when he tweeted: “Saw

On Eve Of MLK Day, Will Adultery
Keep Epic Dr. King Movie Off
The Big Screen?
Deadline Hollywood, by Mike Fleming Jr    Original Article
Posted By: Mike PHX- 1/19/2014 3:25:44 PM     Post Reply
Oliver Stone has run smack into the same wall on a Dr. Martin Luther King Jr biopic that director Paul Greengrass hit when Universal kicked his MLK project Memphis to the curb two years back. Stone took to his Twitter account today to say that DreamWorks and Warner Bros rejected his script rewrite and that he was done with the movie that also had Jamie Foxx attached. It came down to the studios — which are in lockstep with the MLK estate that brought them the right to use his famous copyrighted speeches — rejecting Stone’s characterization of long-running rumors

50 Ways to Celebrate
Michelle Obama’s Birthday
ABC News, by Staff    Original Article
Posted By: Mike PHX- 1/17/2014 12:18:39 PM     Post Reply
First Lady Michelle Obama turns 50 today, and although the big White House celebration planned by President Obama isn’t until Saturday, that doesn’t mean you have to wait to celebrate. If your invite to Saturday’s dance party in Washington went missing, here are 50 other ways to honor the first lady on her big day — by doing some of her favorite things, from wearing stylish dresses to eating your veggies to doing the Dougie, preferably with Jimmy Fallon. 1. Dance to Beyonce 2. Eat your vegetables 3. Move into a massive new house with your family and invite your mother to move in

WWII soldier who hid in
jungle for 29 years dies at 91
Associated Press, by Staff    Original Article
Posted By: Mike PHX- 1/17/2014 12:08:00 PM     Post Reply
TOKYO -- Hiroo Onoda, the last Japanese imperial soldier to emerge from hiding in a jungle in the Philippines and surrender, 29 years after the end of World War II, has died. He was 91. Onoda died Thursday at a Tokyo hospital after a brief stay there. Chief government spokesman Yoshihide Suga on Friday expressed his condolences, praising Onoda for his strong will to live and indomitable spirit. "After World War II, Mr. Onoda lived in the jungle for many years and when he returned to Japan, I felt that finally, the war was finished. That´s how I felt," Suga

Madden, ´Partridge Family´ agent, dies in Fla.
Associated Press, by Frazier Moore    Original Article
Posted By: Mike PHX- 1/17/2014 11:57:49 AM     Post Reply
NEW YORK (AP) — Comic actor Dave Madden, who played the child-hating agent on the hit 1970s sitcom "The Partridge Family," died in Florida on Thursday at age 82. Madden died at a hospice center near his home in the Jacksonville area, his niece Mary Frances Miller said. Towering and rumpled, Madden was best known for his role as Reuben Kinkaid, who managed the Partridge family band and regularly clashed with its impish pre-teen bassist, played by Danny Bonaduce. While the series starred Shirley Jones, with her real-life stepson David Cassidy as the resident heart-throb, it was Madden and the freckle-faced Bonaduce who

   

 



 
Hilarity Ensues When Americans
Are Asked About Joe Biden
Cybercast News Service, by Matt Vespa    Original Article
Posted By: Mike PHX- 1/17/2014 11:32:33 AM     Post Reply
Recently, former Secretary of Defense Robert Gates wrote in his memoir that Vice President Joe Biden isn´t really an expert on anything, especially on foreign policy. Gates noted that Biden has been wrong on every foreign policy decision for the past four decades. So, what do Americans really think about Joe Biden? MRCTV´s Dan Joseph decided to investigate and let´s just say that the Vice President shouldn´t expect any positive comments about his political acumen anytime soon.

Emails Tie Top Christie Aide to
Lane Closings, Despite Denials
New York Times, by Kate Zernike    Original Article
Posted By: Mike PHX- 1/8/2014 10:28:04 AM     Post Reply
A series of newly obtained emails shows that Gov. Chris Christie’s office was closely involved with the lane closings at the George Washington Bridge in New Jersey in September, and that officials closed the lanes in what appeared to be retribution against the mayor whose town was gridlocked as a result. Mr. Christie, a Republican, has insisted that his staff and his campaign had nothing to do with the lane closings, and said that they were done as part of a traffic study. But the emails, obtained by The New York Times, show that Bridget Anne Kelly, a deputy chief of staff



Most Active Articles (last 48 hours)



Ben Carson: White House wanted
apology for ‘offending’ Obama

54 replie(s)
Daily Caller, by Alex Pappas    Original Article
Posted By: StormCnter- 4/15/2014 5:22:51 AM     Post Reply
Neurosurgeon Ben Carson says the White House wanted him to apologize for “offending” President Obama after he famously delivered a conservative message at the National Prayer Breakfast last year. Carson, the former director of pediatric neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins Hospital, recalls the events surrounding his 2013 speech in his new book, One Nation: What We Can All Do To Save America’s Future. The Daily Caller obtained an advance copy of the book, which is set for release May 20. “He did not appear to be hostile or angry,” Carson writes of Obama, “but within a matter of minutes after the conclusion of

Megyn Kelly and the
Sandberg Head Shaker

47 replie(s)
American Thinker, by Richard F. Miniter    Original Article
Posted By: magnante- 4/15/2014 9:16:05 AM     Post Reply
Megyn Kelly’s "Kelly File" is a great news show. She’s incisive, informed and customarily handles the toughest guest with aplomb. But her lengthy interview of Facebook C.O.O. Sheryl Sandberg about her second book in the Lean In series Lean In: For Graduates was a head shaker. Amazing that she of all people allowed Sandberg to restring the same old, same old, shamed, and shopworn feminist myths about women and girls and then jangle it in front of her viewing audience like something new out of the box. Indeed Kelly all but genuflected in front of this woman. Kept her on thru

Why You Should Be Sympathetic
Toward Cliven Bundy

44 replie(s)
Powerline, by John Hinderaker    Original Article
Posted By: Toledo- 4/15/2014 8:40:58 AM     Post Reply
On Saturday, I wrote about the standoff at Bundy Ranch. That post drew a remarkable amount of traffic, even though, as I wrote then, I had not quite decided what to make of the story. Since then, I have continued to study the facts and have drawn some conclusions. Here they are. First, it must be admitted that legally, Bundy doesn’t have a leg to stand on. The Bureau of Land Management has been charging him grazing fees since the early 1990s, which he has refused to pay. Further, BLM has issued orders limiting the area on which Bundy’s cows can

Biden Tells Boston Bombing
Survivors, ´It Was Worth It´ (Video)

37 replie(s)
Breitbart´s Instablog, by Debra Heine    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 4/15/2014 9:28:18 PM     Post Reply
Less than a minute into his speech at the Boston marathon bombing memorial on Tuesday, Vice President Joe Biden went tragically off script and told the crowd of Boston bombing survivors that "it was worth it." After expressing how impressed he was with the tribute, he said somberly, "let me say to those ´quote survivors,´ my God, you have survived and you have soared. It was worth it. I mean this sincerely - just to hear each of you speak. You´re truly, truly inspiring." The audience sat in stunned silence until Biden declared, "I´ve never heard anything so beautiful than

Which Actor Portrays The
Best James Bond?

37 replie(s)
American Spectator, by Jonah Goldberg and Taki Theodoracopulos    Original Article
Posted By: Drive- 4/16/2014 11:20:22 AM     Post Reply
Look, everyone loves Sean Connery, particularly Sean Connery. That’s why he plays Sean Connery in every movie he’s in. People love that Scottish brogue so much, they don’t mind that he has it when he plays Juan Sánchez Villa-Lobos Ramírez, an immortal Spaniard in Highlander. The guy even won an Oscar for playing an Irish cop with a Scottish accent. Talk about sexist double standards: Meryl Streep has to master foreign dialects to get her golden statuettes. Connery just has to show up on time. In economics you devalue a currency by printing too much of it. In film you

Casual marijuana use linked with
brain abnormalities, study finds

35 replie(s)
Fox News, by Loren Grush    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 4/15/2014 6:12:53 PM     Post Reply
Casual marijuana use may come with some not-so-casual side effects. For the first time ever, researchers at Northwestern University have analyzed the relationship between casual use of marijuana and brain changes – and found that young adults who used cannabis just once or twice a week showed significant abnormalities in two important brain structures. The study’s findings, to be published Wednesday in the Journal of Neuroscience, are similar to those of past research linking chronic, long-term marijuana use with mental illness and changes in brain development. Dr. Hans Breiter, co-senior study author, said he was inspired to look at the effects of casual

Glaring limits of the Civil Rights
Act: We need to redistribute wealth

34 replie(s)
Salon Magazine, by Matt Bruenig    Original Article
Posted By: KarenJ1- 4/14/2014 7:20:41 PM     Post Reply
Although the Civil Rights Act, the landmark legislation which just reached its 50th anniversary, made great strides in desegregating the economy, economic discrimination is still widespread, and anti-discrimination legislation alone can never rectify the economic damage inflicted upon blacks by slavery and our Jim Crow apartheid regime. The Civil Rights Act was a mild reform, all things considered, but one conservatives fought with vigor and one many conservatives are still bitter about to this day. When the Civil Rights Act passed in 1964, the primary purpose was to root out discrimination in public accommodations (like hotels and movie theaters)

   

Post Reply   Close thread 704118





Home Page | Latest Posts | Links | Must Reads | Update Profile | RSS | Contribute | Register | Rules & FAQs
Privacy Policy | Search | Post | Contact | Logout | Forgot Password | Search Using Google


© 2014 Lucianne.com Media Inc.

~~~c~~~